ERISA Provider Appeals ERISA appeals for providers.

Most employer health plans are governed by ERISA. When a plan denies or underpays a claim, the internal appeal is often the only record a court will ever see.

We help physicians and practices appeal denied and underpaid claims under employer-sponsored health plans governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, and pursue claims in court when appeals fail.

The Department of Labor’s claims procedure regulation, 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1, requires a group health plan to decide post-service claims within set time limits, to explain the specific reasons for a denial, and to give claimants at least 180 days to appeal. On appeal, the claimant is entitled to a full and fair review, including free access to documents relevant to the claim.

Providers usually need standing. A provider may pursue a patient’s ERISA benefits as the patient’s authorized representative or under a valid assignment of benefits, but many plans contain anti-assignment clauses. Courts generally enforce those clauses, so documentation obtained at intake matters.

Where a plan gives its administrator discretion to interpret plan terms, courts generally review a denial under a deferential standard, and their review is largely confined to the administrative record. That makes the appeal the place to build the case.

Our capabilities include:

  • Authorized representative and assignment documentation
  • Requests for plan documents and claim files
  • Level-one and level-two appeals
  • External review where available
  • Coordination with No Surprises Act and state remedies
  • ERISA benefit litigation

Key deadlines for group health plans

Post-service claim decisionWithin 30 days, with one possible 15-day extension
Time to appeal a denialAt least 180 days after notice of the adverse determination
Post-service appeal decisionWithin 60 days for one level of appeal, or 30 days per level for two levels
Urgent care claimsMuch shorter timelines apply
Documents relevant to the claimMust be provided free of charge on request

Building an appeal record

  1. Confirm authority

    Obtain the patient’s authorized representative designation or confirm a valid assignment.

  2. Request the file

    Ask for the plan document, summary plan description, claim file, and criteria relied on.

  3. Answer every reason

    Address each reason for denial with records, coding support, and medical necessity evidence.

  4. Preserve the issues

    Raise every argument in the appeal, since later review is generally limited to the record.

Key terms

ERISA
The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, which governs most private employer benefit plans.
29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1
The Department of Labor regulation setting claims and appeals procedures for ERISA plans.
Adverse benefit determination
A denial, reduction, or termination of a benefit, or a failure to pay in whole or in part.
Post-service claim
A claim for benefits for care already provided.
Full and fair review
The appeal the regulation requires, by a reviewer who did not make the initial decision.
Authorized representative
A person, such as a provider, designated to act for the claimant in the claims process.
Assignment of benefits
The patient’s transfer of the right to plan payment to the provider.
Anti-assignment clause
A plan provision barring assignment of benefits.
Summary plan description
The plain-language document describing the plan’s benefits and procedures.
Administrative record
The documents before the plan when it decided the claim and appeal.
Abuse of discretion
A deferential standard of review that applies when the plan grants its administrator discretion.
Deemed exhaustion
A rule under which a claimant may go to court if the plan fails to follow the required procedures.
External review
Review by an independent organization available for many non-grandfathered group health plans on medical judgment issues.
Section 502(a)(1)(B)
The ERISA provision allowing a participant to sue to recover benefits due under the plan.

Questions we hear most

Can a provider appeal an ERISA claim?

Yes, as the patient’s authorized representative or under a valid assignment of benefits. Plans may have their own procedures for designating a representative.

What is an anti-assignment clause?

A plan provision that prohibits assigning benefits to a provider. Courts generally enforce these clauses, which can prevent a provider from suing in its own name, so an authorized representative designation is often needed.

How long does a plan have to decide an appeal?

For post-service claims, generally 60 days for a single level of appeal, or 30 days per level if the plan has two levels.

How does ERISA relate to the No Surprises Act?

Self-funded ERISA plans are subject to the federal No Surprises Act for covered out-of-network services, and payment disputes for those services go to federal IDR. Other denials, such as medical necessity or coverage, follow the ERISA claims and appeals process.

Do I have to exhaust appeals before suing?

Generally yes. Courts usually require exhaustion of the plan’s internal appeals, subject to exceptions such as the plan’s failure to follow the claims regulation.

What documents should I request?

The plan document, summary plan description, the claim file, any internal guidelines or criteria relied on, and the identity of any medical reviewers consulted.

Is external review available?

For many non-grandfathered group health plans, yes, for denials involving medical judgment, after internal appeals.

What damages are available under ERISA?

Generally the benefits due under the plan, with possible interest and attorney’s fees in the court’s discretion. Extra-contractual and punitive damages generally are not available.

Can I bring state-law claims instead?

Claims to recover plan benefits are generally preempted by ERISA. Some claims based on independent promises, such as a separate payment agreement, may be treated differently.

How long do I have to sue?

ERISA does not set a limitations period for benefit claims, so courts look to plan terms or analogous state law. Many plans set their own contractual limitations period, which courts generally enforce if reasonable.
Contact

Request a claims review

Tell us about your practice, your specialty, and your approximate volume of out-of-network commercial claims. We will review your accounts receivable at no charge, identify claims eligible under New York law or the No Surprises Act, and give you a candid assessment. Surprise billing arbitration is handled on a contingency basis under a written engagement letter.

Request a claims review

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content