No Surprises Act Arbitration Federal No Surprises Act arbitration.

For self-funded employer plans and other coverage outside New York’s reach, the federal independent dispute resolution process decides out-of-network payment. Its deadlines are short and strictly applied.

The No Surprises Act, in effect since January 1, 2022, protects patients from balance bills for emergency care, certain non-emergency care at in-network facilities, and air ambulance services, and sends payment disputes between providers and plans to arbitration.

The federal process is “baseball-style”: each side submits a final offer, and a certified IDR entity selects one. The entity considers the qualifying payment amount — generally the plan’s median contracted rate — along with the other statutory factors. Federal courts vacated rules that would have required arbitrators to give the QPA presumptive weight.

Most federal claims are lost on timing, not merits. Open negotiation must begin within 30 business days of the initial payment or denial, and IDR must be initiated within four business days after negotiation ends. We calendar every claim from day one.

The Departments finalized the Federal Independent Dispute Resolution Operations rule in 2026 (91 Fed. Reg. 33900, June 4, 2026; effective August 3, 2026). It phases in over time: a lower administrative fee for disputes initiated on or after June 11, 2026; new batching rules for disputes whose open negotiation begins on or after November 1, 2026; remittance codes on payments for services furnished on or after January 1, 2027; and portal-based open negotiation once the Departments announce it.

Our capabilities include:

  • Open negotiation notices and payer correspondence
  • Timely IDR initiation through the federal portal
  • Batching of qualifying claims
  • IDR entity selection and conflict review
  • Offers and supporting submissions
  • Tracking payment of determinations

How the federal process runs

  1. Initial payment or denial

    The plan pays or denies within 30 calendar days after receiving a clean claim.

  2. Open negotiation

    Either side may begin a 30-business-day negotiation period within 30 business days of the initial payment or denial.

  3. Initiation and selection

    If negotiation fails, IDR must be initiated within four business days. A certified IDR entity is then selected by the parties or assigned.

  4. Offers and determination

    Each side submits its offer and support. The entity generally decides within 30 business days of selection, and payment is due within 30 calendar days after the determination.

Services the federal law reaches

  • Emergency services

    Out-of-network emergency care, including post-stabilization services in many cases.

  • Care at in-network facilities

    Non-emergency services by out-of-network providers at in-network hospitals and ambulatory surgery centers. Ancillary services — anesthesiology, radiology, pathology, neonatology, assistant surgeons, hospitalists, and intensivists — cannot be removed from these protections by patient consent.

  • Air ambulance

    Out-of-network air ambulance services.

The 2026 Operations Rule

  • Administrative fee

    $15 per party per dispute for disputes initiated on or after June 11, 2026, down from $115.

  • Batching

    For disputes whose open negotiation begins on or after November 1, 2026, new rules govern which line items may be batched, with a cap on the number of line items in a batched dispute. For self-insured plans, items may be batched only if paid by the same plan.

  • Open negotiation

    The 30-business-day period runs from the first open negotiation notice, and the other side must respond no later than the 15th business day. A late response does not extend the period. Notices will move to the federal portal on a date the Departments will announce.

  • Payer disclosures

    Plans must give QPA information with the initial payment or denial, identify the plan or issuer and plan sponsor by legal name, and tell the provider how to begin open negotiation.

  • Remittance codes

    Claim adjustment and remittance advice codes are required on remittances to non-contracted providers for items and services furnished on or after January 1, 2027.

Key terms

No Surprises Act
The federal law, effective January 1, 2022, that protects patients from certain balance bills and created the federal IDR process for payment disputes.
Certified IDR entity
An independent entity certified by the federal Departments to decide payment disputes between providers and plans.
Federal IDR portal
The online system through which parties initiate and manage federal IDR disputes.
Initial payment or denial
The plan’s first response to a clean claim, which starts the 30-business-day window to begin open negotiation.
Open negotiation notice
The notice that starts the 30-business-day negotiation period required before IDR.
Notice of IDR initiation
The notice filed to start IDR, generally within four business days after open negotiation ends without agreement.
QPA
The qualifying payment amount, generally the plan’s median contracted rate for the same or similar service in the geographic region, adjusted for inflation.
Additional factors
The other statutory considerations, such as the provider’s training and experience, market share, patient acuity, case complexity, and good-faith negotiation efforts.
Batching
Combining multiple qualifying claims into a single dispute, generally where they involve the same plan and the same or similar service within a set time period.
Bundled payment
A single payment covering multiple items or services, which can be submitted as one dispute in some circumstances.
Cooling-off period
A 90-calendar-day period after a determination during which the initiating party generally cannot start a new IDR against the same party for the same item or service.
Administrative fee
A non-refundable fee each party pays to the federal government for each dispute, set by the Departments and subject to change.
Certified IDR entity fee
The entity’s fee, which each party pays at the outset and which is refunded to the prevailing party.
Eligibility determination
The entity’s decision whether a dispute is properly within the federal process, made before it considers the merits.
Specified state law
A state law, such as New York’s for fully insured plans, that determines payment instead of the federal process.
Air ambulance services
Out-of-network air medical transport, covered by the No Surprises Act’s protections and IDR process.

Questions we hear most

Which plans are subject to federal IDR?

Principally self-funded (ERISA) employer plans, and other plans where no specified state law such as New York’s applies. Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, and VA coverage are excluded.

Can several claims be filed together?

Yes. Qualifying claims involving the same provider and plan within the same 30-business-day window may be batched into one dispute. For disputes whose open negotiation begins on or after November 1, 2026, the 2026 Operations Rule sets new batching criteria and a cap on line items per dispute.

What is the cooling-off period?

After a determination, the initiating party generally cannot bring a new dispute against the same opposing party for the same service for 90 calendar days, though claims arising during that period can be filed afterward.

What does federal IDR cost?

Each party pays a non-refundable administrative fee, $15 per party for disputes initiated on or after June 11, 2026, and the certified IDR entity’s fee up front. The prevailing party’s entity fee is refunded.

How does the 2026 Fifth Circuit decision affect the QPA?

In August 2026 the full Fifth Circuit held that parts of the QPA methodology were unlawful, including counting rates for services a provider does not actually furnish and excluding bonus and incentive payments. Plans will need to recalculate affected QPAs. We review the QPA disclosed on each claim.

What happens if I miss the four-business-day initiation deadline?

A late initiation can make the dispute ineligible, and the federal rules allow extensions only in limited circumstances, such as certain extenuating circumstances recognized by the Departments. This is why we calendar every claim from the initial payment. Missed deadlines are rarely recoverable.

How is the IDR entity chosen?

The parties may jointly select a certified IDR entity, generally within three business days after initiation; if they do not agree, one is assigned. Each side may raise conflicts of interest. The selected entity must attest that it has no conflict.

When do we submit our offer?

Each party generally submits its offer and supporting information within ten business days after the entity is selected. The entity then decides, generally within 30 business days after selection. Late submissions can harm the case.

Does the arbitrator have to choose the QPA?

No. The entity considers the QPA along with the additional statutory factors, and federal courts vacated rules that would have given the QPA presumptive weight. Evidence on the additional factors matters.

Can the plan challenge whether my claim is eligible?

Yes. The non-initiating party may object to eligibility, and the entity decides eligibility before reaching the merits. Common disputes involve the plan type, whether state law applies, and timing. We address eligibility in the initiation papers.

What can we submit during the cooling-off period?

During the 90-day cooling-off period, the initiating party generally cannot start a new dispute against the same party for the same item or service. Under the federal rules, claims whose negotiation periods end during cooling-off can generally be submitted within 30 business days after the period ends. Timing these claims takes planning.

Who is the right party to negotiate with for a self-funded plan?

Self-funded plans often use an insurer or third-party administrator to process claims, and the plan’s notices should identify the contact for open negotiation. Communications should go to the party designated to receive them. We confirm contacts before sending notices.

Is a settlement during open negotiation binding?

Yes, an agreed amount during open negotiation resolves the claim on those terms. The agreement should be documented, and payment should follow within the agreed time. We reconcile settlements as carefully as awards.

Can a plan pay less than the award?

No. The determination is binding, and the plan must pay the difference between the determined amount and what it already paid, generally within 30 calendar days after the determination. Late or partial payment can be pursued through the enforcement routes on our award enforcement page.

Do Medicare Advantage claims go to federal IDR?

No. Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, and other government programs are generally outside the No Surprises Act’s IDR process; they have their own payment rules. The process applies to group health plans and individual health insurance coverage.

What if the claim involves both state and federal law?

Where a specified state law applies, such as New York’s law for fully insured plans issued in New York, that law governs instead of the federal process. Some situations are less clear, and the eligibility analysis should be done carefully before filing.
Contact

Request a claims review

Tell us about your practice, your specialty, and your approximate volume of out-of-network commercial claims. We will review your accounts receivable at no charge, identify claims eligible under New York law or the No Surprises Act, and give you a candid assessment. Surprise billing arbitration is handled on a contingency basis under a written engagement letter.

Request a claims review

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content