Underpayment Litigation Underpayment claims outside arbitration.

Some underpaid claims are too old, or the wrong type, for arbitration. Many can still be pursued in court.

Arbitration is not the only remedy for an underpaid out-of-network claim. Depending on the plan and the claim’s age, a physician may have contract, ERISA, or prompt-pay claims against the payer.

For fully insured plans, a physician holding a valid assignment of the patient’s benefits may sue on the plan contract. New York’s general six-year limitations period for contract claims, CPLR § 213(2), can reach claims well beyond the practical window for arbitration — subject to the plan’s own terms, including anti-assignment and contractual limitations clauses.

For self-funded plans, benefit claims usually proceed under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), after the plan’s internal appeals are exhausted. In-network physicians who are underpaid under their own participation agreements have contract remedies of their own.

Our capabilities include:

  • Claim triage by plan type, age, and assignment
  • Contract actions on assigned benefits
  • ERISA appeals and benefit litigation
  • In-network participation agreement disputes
  • Prompt-pay interest claims
  • Portfolio litigation against repeat payers

Matching each claim to a forum

  • Recent fully insured claims

    New York Independent Dispute Resolution.

  • Older fully insured claims

    A contract action on assigned benefits, generally within six years under CPLR § 213(2), subject to plan terms.

  • Self-funded plans

    Federal No Surprises Act arbitration for eligible services, and ERISA benefit claims after internal appeals.

  • In-network underpayments

    Claims under the participation agreement, through its dispute process or in court.

Key terms

Underpayment
A plan payment below what the provider is owed under the plan, an assignment, a contract, or a determination.
Assignment of benefits
The patient’s transfer of the right to plan benefits to the provider, which allows the provider to sue the plan on the patient’s claim.
Anti-assignment clause
A plan provision restricting assignment of benefits, which can defeat a provider’s standing unless waived or unenforceable.
ERISA
The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, the federal law governing most employer-sponsored plans, including self-funded plans.
ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B)
The provision that allows a participant, or a provider with a valid assignment, to sue to recover benefits due under the plan’s terms.
Exhaustion
The requirement that a claimant complete the plan’s internal appeals before suing under ERISA, subject to limited exceptions.
Internal appeal
The plan’s review process for an adverse benefit determination; for group health plans, claimants generally have at least 180 days to appeal.
Standard of review
How a court reviews a plan’s benefit decision: de novo unless the plan grants discretion, under Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. Bruch, 489 U.S. 101 (1989).
ERISA preemption
The rule that ERISA displaces many state-law claims that relate to an employer plan, which can limit theories against self-funded plans.
Contractual limitations period
A plan term setting a deadline to sue, which courts generally enforce if reasonable, as in Heimeshoff v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co., 571 U.S. 99 (2013).
CPLR § 213(2)
New York’s general six-year limitations period for contract claims, which applies to many fully insured plan claims, subject to plan terms.
Participation agreement
An in-network provider’s contract with a plan, which sets rates and dispute procedures for underpayment claims.
Quantum meruit
A claim for the reasonable value of services provided, sometimes asserted where no contract governs payment.
Prompt pay law
Insurance Law § 3224-a, which sets payment deadlines for New York insurers, generally 30 days for electronic claims and 45 days for paper claims, with interest on late payment.
Plan documents
The plan’s governing documents and summary plan description, which define benefits and are central to any ERISA claim.

Questions we hear most

Can claims I wrote off years ago still be pursued?

Often. Older fully insured claims may support a contract action, and the general limitations period is six years, subject to the plan’s terms. We review the documents before advising.

Does the plan’s anti-assignment clause matter?

It can. Some plans restrict assignment of benefits, which affects who may sue. We review the plan language and the assignment early.

Do I have to appeal internally first?

For ERISA plans, generally yes — the plan’s internal appeal must usually be exhausted before suit.

How do we know whether a patient’s plan has an anti-assignment clause?

The plan documents and summary plan description will say, and the provider can request plan documents through the patient or in the course of an appeal. Some EOBs and payer manuals also refer to assignment rules. We review the plan language before asserting a claim.

Can a plan waive its anti-assignment clause?

In some circumstances, courts have found waiver where a plan dealt directly with the provider as assignee, such as by paying the provider directly or addressing appeals to it, though results vary. The facts of the payer’s conduct matter.

What if the patient signed an assignment but the plan says it is invalid?

The validity of an assignment depends on its wording and the plan’s terms. A broad assignment that clearly transfers the right to benefits and to sue is generally more effective. We review the form your practice uses and recommend improvements.

Should we appeal every underpayment internally?

For self-funded ERISA plans, internal appeals are generally required before suit and also build the record a court will review. For fully insured plans, appeals can still be useful. A consistent appeal process protects later claims.

What does a court review in an ERISA benefit case?

Courts often decide ERISA benefit claims on the administrative record, the documents before the plan when it decided the appeal. That is why appeals should include the evidence you want a court to see. The standard of review depends on the plan’s language.

Can we sue on many claims at once?

Yes, where the claims involve the same payer and similar issues, they may be brought in a single action, which can make litigation more efficient. Whether claims can be grouped depends on the forum, the plan types, and the legal theories.

Is it worth pursuing claims under a few hundred dollars?

Individually small claims may not justify litigation, but a portfolio of similar claims against the same payer can. We triage claims by value, age, and plan type to focus on those with a realistic path to recovery.

How do in-network underpayments differ?

In-network claims are governed by the participation agreement, which often has its own dispute process, deadlines, and arbitration clause. Statutory surprise-billing arbitration generally does not apply. The contract decides the forum.

Can the prompt pay law apply to underpaid claims?

The prompt pay law requires New York insurers to pay undisputed portions of claims within its deadlines and imposes interest on late payment. It applies to New York-regulated insurers, not self-funded ERISA plans. Whether it helps depends on the claim.

Can we recover attorney’s fees in an ERISA case?

ERISA allows a court, in its discretion, to award reasonable attorney’s fees to a party that achieves some degree of success on the merits. Fee awards are not automatic.

What records should we keep to support future claims?

Keep claim forms, EOBs, assignment forms, appeal letters, plan correspondence, and the patient’s plan identification. Records of how the practice set its charges also help. Organized records are often the difference between a claim that can be pursued and one that cannot.
Contact

Request a claims review

Tell us about your practice, your specialty, and your approximate volume of out-of-network commercial claims. We will review your accounts receivable at no charge, identify claims eligible under New York law or the No Surprises Act, and give you a candid assessment. Surprise billing arbitration is handled on a contingency basis under a written engagement letter.

Request a claims review

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content