New York IDR Arbitration New York Independent Dispute Resolution for physicians.
We represent out-of-network physicians in surprise bill and emergency services disputes with New York-regulated health plans, in the IDR process administered by the Department of Financial Services.
New York’s Independent Dispute Resolution process, created by Financial Services Law Article 6, lets an out-of-network physician contest a fully insured plan’s payment for emergency services or a surprise bill. The process changed significantly in 2026.
The patient is held to in-network cost-sharing, and the dispute over the rest of the bill runs between the physician and the plan. An independent dispute resolution entity reviews both positions and selects either the physician’s fee or the plan’s payment — it does not split the difference.
Because the reviewer chooses one number, the outcome turns on the record. We build the submission around the statutory factors, with benchmark data, the physician’s credentials and charge history, and the clinical facts that made the case complex.
Our capabilities include:
- Eligibility review: plan type, service type, and surprise bill criteria
- Assignment of benefits and surprise bill forms
- Filing through the DFS IDR portal
- Evidentiary submissions built on the statutory factors
- Negotiated settlements before determination
- Follow-up on payment of determinations
What the reviewer considers
Usual and customary cost
The 80th percentile of charges for the same service by providers in the same or a similar specialty in the same geographic area, as reported in the benchmark database DFS designates — FAIR Health.
Disparity between fee and payment
Whether there is a gross disparity between the physician’s fee and what the plan pays similarly qualified out-of-network physicians, and what other plans pay the physician.
Training, education, and experience
The physician’s qualifications, including board certification and fellowship training.
The physician’s usual charge
What the physician ordinarily charges for comparable services to patients in plans where the physician is out of network.
Circumstances and complexity
The complexity of the case, including the time and place of service.
Patient characteristics
Individual patient factors that bear on the care provided.
What changed in 2026
Medicaid managed care removed
Under Part BB of Chapter 57 of the Laws of 2026, signed May 28, 2026, disputes involving Medicaid managed care plans can no longer be filed in New York IDR. The exclusion applies to disputes filed on or after May 28, 2026.
Empire Plan and SEHP added
For disputes submitted on or after August 26, 2026, the Empire Plan and the Student Employee Health Plan are covered. For these State Plans, the reviewer selects whichever amount is closer to the 50th percentile of allowed amounts, may depart from it only with a written explanation, and may not award more than the 80th percentile of allowed amounts. Different rules apply to certain hospital-employed physicians.
Both sides pay up front
The filing party pays the full reviewer fee when it submits, and the other party pays when it responds. A non-patient filer that does not pay is ineligible. The prevailing party’s payment is refunded within 30 calendar days of the decision, and settlements and split decisions are refunded pro rata.
Contract and prior-authorization bar
The reviewer may not award a fee if the plan shows that the physician, or an affiliate, had a contract covering the same service at the same location on the date of service, or that the plan gave a compliant prior-authorization notice identifying the service as out of network. The plan must raise this at the outset.
Longer decision period
The reviewer generally decides within 45 business days after receiving all the information it needs, up from 30 days. Any settlement negotiation runs at the same time.
How it was adopted
DFS implemented the August 26 changes through an emergency amendment to 23 NYCRR Part 400 while permanent rules proceed. We follow each step of the rulemaking.
Emergency services and surprise bills
Emergency services
Out-of-network emergency care is covered by the New York process for fully insured plans, and the patient owes only in-network cost-sharing.
Surprise bills
Generally, services by an out-of-network physician at an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgery center where the patient did not knowingly choose that physician, or an out-of-network referral made without the patient’s written acknowledgment. For surprise bills, the patient’s assignment of benefits is part of the filing.
Key terms
- Financial Services Law Article 6
- The New York statute, enacted in 2014, that created the surprise bill protections and Independent Dispute Resolution process.
- DFS
- The New York State Department of Financial Services, which administers the IDR program and regulates New York insurers.
- IDRE
- An independent dispute resolution entity certified by DFS to review the dispute and decide payment.
- Surprise bill
- Generally, services by an out-of-network physician at an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgery center where the patient did not knowingly choose that physician, or certain referrals made without the patient’s written consent.
- Emergency services
- Care for a condition that would lead a prudent layperson to expect serious harm without immediate attention; New York’s IDR covers out-of-network emergency physician services for fully insured plans.
- Assignment of benefits
- The patient’s transfer of the right to plan payment to the physician; for surprise bills, the patient’s assignment is part of the filing.
- Surprise bill certification form
- The DFS form a patient uses to certify that a bill is a surprise bill and assign benefits to the provider.
- Usual and customary cost
- The 80th percentile of charges for the same service by providers in the same or similar specialty in the same geographic area, as reported in FAIR Health data.
- FAIR Health
- The independent nonprofit whose benchmark database DFS designates for usual and customary cost.
- Geographic area
- The region, defined by the benchmark data, used to compare a physician’s charge to other providers’ charges.
- Gross disparity
- A factor the IDRE considers: whether there is a large gap between the physician’s fee and what the plan pays similarly qualified out-of-network physicians.
- Baseball-style determination
- The IDRE selects either the physician’s fee or the plan’s payment, with no compromise in between.
- Settlement before determination
- A negotiated resolution reached after filing but before the IDRE decides; since August 26, 2026, the up-front fees are then refunded pro rata.
- Fully insured plan
- A health plan issued by an insurer or HMO and regulated by New York, as opposed to a self-funded employer plan.
- CPI-adjusted threshold
- A dollar threshold, adjusted for inflation, below which certain low-cost emergency claims are generally not eligible for New York IDR.
Questions we hear most
Which plans does New York IDR cover?
Is the decision binding?
Who pays the reviewer’s fee?
Can I still file Medicaid managed care disputes?
Does the patient need to sign anything?
Do I need a patient signature for an emergency services dispute?
What if the patient will not sign the surprise bill form?
How long does New York IDR take?
Can the IDRE order the parties to negotiate?
Does every out-of-network claim qualify?
Can I file disputes for services at a hospital where I have privileges?
What if the plan pays more after I file?
What evidence carries the most weight?
Can uninsured patients’ bills go to New York IDR?
Is there a deadline to file in New York?
Do New York determinations apply to future claims?
Request a claims review
Tell us about your practice, your specialty, and your approximate volume of out-of-network commercial claims. We will review your accounts receivable at no charge, identify claims eligible under New York law or the No Surprises Act, and give you a candid assessment. Surprise billing arbitration is handled on a contingency basis under a written engagement letter.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Request a claims review
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.