Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

How can LLC members who want to go separate ways each do a 1031 exchange?

Partnership and LLC interests do not qualify for a 1031 exchange, so the property must be exchanged by whoever owns it. In a drop-and-swap, the LLC deeds the property to its members as tenants in common, and each member then sells its share and exchanges or takes cash. The IRS may challenge whether members held the property for investment, so do it well before a sale and plan for New York transfer taxes.

Why the LLC is the taxpayer

When an LLC taxed as a partnership owns a building, the LLC sells the building and the LLC must buy the replacement property. Members cannot exchange their LLC interests for real estate: partnership interests were expressly excluded from Section 1031 before 2018, and current Treasury regulations list them among the interests that are not real property. A narrow exception applies only to a partnership that has validly elected out of the partnership tax rules under Section 761(a), which is uncommon for operating real estate.

If every member agrees on one replacement property, the LLC can simply complete the exchange itself, as described in our guide to 1031 exchange timelines. The problems arise when members want different outcomes.

The options at a glance

The LLC exchanges as a wholeSimplest. All members stay together in the replacement property.
The LLC exchanges and redeems a departing memberThe LLC completes the exchange, and the departing member is paid out. Any cash used is generally taxable, and payment terms may be structured to defer it.
Drop-and-swapThe LLC distributes the property to the members as tenants in common before the sale. Each member then sells its share and exchanges or takes cash on its own.
Swap-and-dropThe LLC completes the exchange and later distributes the replacement property to the members.
Buyout before the saleMembers who want to stay buy out those who want cash, and the remaining owners decide on the sale later.

Each option has different tax, financing, and transfer tax results. The right one depends on how many members want out, the debt on the property, and how soon a sale will happen.

How a drop-and-swap works

The LLC deeds the property to its members as tenants in common, each receiving an undivided share in proportion to its interest. A distribution of property from a partnership is generally not taxable under Section 731, although other rules, including rules for property contributed within the prior seven years and for shifts in debt, should be checked. Each member, or a single-member LLC it forms, now owns a share of the real estate directly. When the building is sold, each co-owner’s share of the proceeds goes either to its own qualified intermediary for an exchange or to the co-owner in cash.

The co-owners should sign a tenancy-in-common agreement covering management, expenses, decisions, and a sale. Co-owners who share in operations can be treated as a partnership again, which would defeat the purpose. Many advisers draft these agreements with the guidelines of Rev. Proc. 2002-22 in mind, which our article on DST and TIC interests describes. The lender must consent to the transfer, since most loans prohibit it, and new title insurance is usually needed for each co-owner.

The holding-period and “held for” risk

Section 1031 requires that the relinquished property be held for investment or business use by the taxpayer making the exchange. The IRS has argued that members who receive property moments before a sale did not hold it for investment, and that in substance the LLC sold the property. There is no statutory minimum holding period, and courts have reached different results:

  • In Magneson v. Commissioner, 753 F.2d 1490 (9th Cir. 1985), and Bolker v. Commissioner, 760 F.2d 1039 (9th Cir. 1985), the Ninth Circuit allowed exchanges where property moved into or out of an entity close in time to the exchange.
  • In Mason v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1988-273, the Tax Court treated the dissolution of partnerships as a distribution of their property to the partners, followed by like-kind exchanges made by the former partners individually.
  • In Chase v. Commissioner, 92 T.C. 874 (1989), the Tax Court found that the partnership, not the partner, made the sale, and the exchange failed.

The practical lessons are consistent. Distribute the property well before marketing it if possible, and certainly before a contract is signed. Have the co-owners act as co-owners, with their own bank accounts, tax reporting, and decisions. Avoid having the LLC negotiate the sale and then deed the property out on the day of closing. How long is long enough is a judgment for tax counsel; there is no safe harbor.

Swap-and-drop

In the reverse order, the LLC completes the exchange and later distributes the replacement property to its members, or a member later contributes its exchange property to a new entity. Magneson upheld a contribution to a partnership after an exchange, but the IRS can argue that replacement property distributed soon after the exchange was not acquired to be held for investment by the LLC. Waiting a meaningful period before the distribution reduces that risk. Holding the replacement property until death may also be part of the plan; see 1031 exchanges and the step-up in basis.

Related-party rules

If co-owners exchange properties with one another, or one co-owner’s exchange involves a property owned by another, the related-party rule of Section 1031(f) may apply. Related persons include family members and partnerships and LLCs in which a person owns more than 50 percent. If either party disposes of the exchanged property within two years, the deferred gain can be triggered, subject to limited exceptions, and the deferral is denied for transactions structured to avoid the rule. Our article on failed 1031 exchanges explains what happens if the deferral is lost.

New York transfer taxes

A deed from an LLC to its members is a conveyance for both the State real estate transfer tax and, in New York City, the City’s real property transfer tax. Both laws exempt a mere change of identity or form of ownership, but only to the extent beneficial ownership stays the same (Tax Law § 1405(b)(6) and 20 NYCRR 575.10; NYC Admin. Code § 11-2106(b)(8)). A distribution in exact proportion to the members’ interests may fall largely within the exemption. A distribution in which members receive different buildings or different percentages is generally taxable on the portion that shifts.

  • Step transactions: in a 2025 decision, the New York City Tax Appeals Tribunal limited the exemption where a new member was admitted to the grantee entity about two months after the deed. Changes in ownership soon after a distribution can be combined with it.
  • Controlling interests: transferring or acquiring 50 percent or more of an entity that owns New York real property, counted over three years, is itself a taxable conveyance. A buyout of a departing member can trigger tax even without a deed.
  • Debt: State law generally includes mortgages in taxable consideration, and the State’s continuing-lien deduction is limited to certain residential and smaller conveyances. City rules differ. Have the transfer tax returns prepared for the specific structure.
  • The later sale: each co-owner’s sale to the buyer is taxed in the ordinary way. A 1031 exchange does not affect transfer taxes; see New York taxes on 1031 exchanges.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.