Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
Does New York tax a 1031 exchange?
Generally not on the deferred gain. New York’s income tax starts from federal adjusted gross income, so gain deferred under § 1031 is generally deferred for New York as well. Transfer taxes are different: State and City transfer taxes still apply to the sale and the purchase, the buyer’s mansion tax applies to residential replacement property of $1 million or more, and new financing pays mortgage recording tax.
Income tax: New York follows the federal deferral
New York Tax Law § 612(a) defines a resident’s New York adjusted gross income as federal adjusted gross income, adjusted by a list of specific modifications. None of the modifications we reviewed addresses like-kind exchanges. As a result, gain that qualifies for deferral under Internal Revenue Code § 1031 is generally deferred for New York State purposes too, and New York City’s resident income tax, which uses the same base, generally follows.
The flip side is that New York also follows the federal result when an exchange is only partly deferred. Boot — cash or debt relief the investor keeps — is taxed federally to the extent of gain, and that recognized gain flows into the New York return in the same way. For how boot arises and how the deadlines work, see our guide to 1031 exchange timelines in New York.
Nonresident sellers: Form IT-2663 at the closing
Under Tax Law § 663, a nonresident individual, estate, or trust that sells or transfers New York real property must estimate the personal income tax on the gain and pay it when the deed is recorded. The payment is made with Form IT-2663, which is submitted with the deed to the county recording officer, not mailed to the Tax Department. For conveyances in 2026, the estimated tax is 10.90 percent of the gain, computed as for federal income tax purposes.
A nonresident who is not required to recognize gain can certify that on the form instead of paying. The Tax Department’s instructions tell a seller in a like-kind exchange to mark the box for transfers where no gain or loss is recognized, give a brief summary, and state that the transaction is an IRC § 1031 exchange. The form is still filed; only the payment is avoided.
- The form asks for the gain, or portion of the gain, that will be reported on the seller’s federal return for the year, so estimated tax is generally due on gain recognized because of boot, although the instructions do not discuss exchanges with boot specifically. If boot will produce recognized gain, the seller should work out with a tax adviser before closing how the form will be completed and how much to pay.
- The estimated payment is not a final tax. Payments made with Form IT-2663 cannot be refunded before an income tax return is filed, and the seller may still have to file a New York nonresident return to report the sale.
- If the exchange later fails, the certification at closing does not protect the gain. Our article on what happens when a 1031 exchange fails covers the New York follow-up.
Transfer taxes are not deferred
A 1031 exchange defers income tax. It does not change the fact that two deeds are recorded. New York Tax Law § 1405(b) lists the conveyances exempt from the State real estate transfer tax, and a like-kind exchange is not among them. New York City’s real property transfer tax likewise applies to each conveyance.
| NYS transfer tax, base rate | 0.4% of consideration |
|---|---|
| NYS additional base tax in NYC | Raises the State rate to 0.65% for residential property of $3 million or more and other property of $2 million or more |
| NYC transfer tax, residential (1–3 family, condo, co-op) | 1% up to $500,000; 1.425% above |
| NYC transfer tax, other property | 1.425% up to $500,000; 2.625% above |
| Who pays | The grantor (seller) generally; the buyer becomes liable if the seller does not pay or is exempt |
In an exchange, the investor is the seller on one side and the buyer on the other. On the relinquished property, the investor generally pays the transfer taxes as seller. On the replacement property, the seller customarily pays, but new-development contracts often shift the taxes to the buyer, and the buyer is liable if the seller is an exempt entity. Read the transfer-tax clause in the replacement contract with the same care as the price. For the seller-side costs in more detail, see NYC closing costs for sellers.
The mansion tax on residential replacement property
Tax Law § 1402-a adds a 1 percent tax, paid by the buyer, when residential real property is conveyed for $1 million or more. The Tax Department treats property as residential if it is or may be used as a personal residence at the time of the conveyance, which includes a one-, two-, or three-family house, an individual condominium unit, and a co-op apartment. An investment condo bought as a rental is therefore generally subject to the tax even though no one in the investor’s family will live there.
In New York City, a supplemental tax applies to residential conveyances of $2 million or more, at rates that rise with the price from 0.25 percent to 2.9 percent, in addition to the 1 percent. Buildings with four or more units and commercial property are not residential real property for these purposes. For investors weighing a condo or co-op as replacement property, our article on 1031 exchanges into NYC co-ops and condos covers the building-level issues.
Mortgage recording tax on new financing
To avoid taxable boot, an investor usually has to replace the debt paid off on the sale with new debt or additional cash. New debt secured by a mortgage on New York real property pays mortgage recording tax when the mortgage is recorded. The State’s current rate table (Form MT-15, revised January 2025) lists these total rates for New York City:
| Mortgages under $500,000 | $2.05 per $100 |
|---|---|
| 1–3 family and residential condo mortgages of $500,000 or more | $2.175 per $100 |
| All other mortgages of $500,000 or more | $2.80 per $100 |
Where the seller of the replacement property has an existing mortgage, assigning and consolidating that loan through a consolidation, extension and modification agreement (CEMA) may limit the tax to the new money. Loans secured by co-op shares are generally not mortgages of real property and do not pay this tax. The lender, title company, and closing attorney should confirm the computation before the closing date is fixed.
Exchanging out of New York
Some states track gain when their property is exchanged for property elsewhere. California requires taxpayers who exchange California property for out-of-state replacement property to file Form FTB 3840 each year until the deferred California-source gain is recognized, and treats that gain as California income when the replacement property is later sold. Oregon, Massachusetts, and Montana reportedly have similar claw-back rules.
New York has no comparable annual reporting requirement. For a nonresident who exchanges New York property for property in another state, New York generally taxes only New York-source income, and a later sale of the out-of-state replacement property would not generally be New York-source. A New York resident, by contrast, is taxed on all income, so a later sale while still a resident is taxed by New York in the usual way. Residents who move away, and anyone exchanging into New York from a state with a claw-back rule, should have a tax adviser confirm how each state will treat the deferred gain.
Before you sign
- Confirm who pays State and City transfer taxes under each contract, and budget for the mansion tax and any supplemental tax on a residential replacement.
- If you are a nonresident seller, prepare Form IT-2663 with the exchange documents in hand, and decide in advance how any boot will be handled on the form.
- Size the replacement financing to replace the old debt, and ask whether a CEMA is available to reduce mortgage recording tax.
- In a reverse or improvement exchange, an accommodation titleholder takes title, which adds conveyances; each one needs its own transfer-tax review.
- Ask your tax adviser to run the federal, State, and City numbers for your own facts before you commit to the replacement property.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.