Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Can I use a Delaware statutory trust or tenancy-in-common interest in a 1031 exchange?

Generally yes. Under Rev. Rul. 2004-86, an interest in a properly structured Delaware statutory trust is treated as an interest in the underlying real estate. Tenancy-in-common interests are direct ownership and can qualify if the co-ownership is not a partnership, with Rev. Proc. 2002-22 as the IRS’s guide. Both trade management for illiquidity, fees, and little control, and most are sold as private securities offerings.

Who considers fractional replacement property

The typical candidate owns a New York City rental building or a few units, has a low tax basis after years of depreciation, and is tired of the work: tenant turnover, rent regulation, violations, Local Law 97, and capital repairs. Selling outright would trigger federal and New York tax on the gain. A 1031 exchange defers that tax but ordinarily means buying and running another property. A fractional interest lets the owner exchange into institutional real estate, such as a net-leased store, an apartment complex, or a warehouse anywhere in the United States, and receive whatever distributions the property produces without managing it.

The exchange rules themselves do not change. The interest must be identified within 45 days and acquired within 180, as explained in our guide to 1031 exchange timelines, and the proceeds must stay with the qualified intermediary.

Delaware statutory trusts

A Delaware statutory trust is a trust formed under Delaware law that holds title to one or more properties. In Rev. Rul. 2004-86, the IRS ruled that a DST can be classified as a trust rather than a business entity, and that investors who exchange real property for DST interests are treated as acquiring an interest in the trust’s real estate rather than a trust certificate. That treatment depends on keeping the trustee’s role passive. In the ruling, the trustee could not:

  • sell the property and buy other property;
  • accept new contributions of money or property from investors;
  • renegotiate or refinance the loan;
  • renegotiate the lease or sign leases with new tenants, except in a tenant’s bankruptcy or insolvency; or
  • make more than minor non-structural changes to the property unless required by law.

The ruling says that a trustee with those powers would make the DST a business entity, generally taxed as a partnership, and partnership interests do not qualify for an exchange. Sponsors therefore commonly lease the whole property to a master tenant affiliated with the sponsor, which handles active management. Many offering documents also allow the trust to convert into a limited liability company if the property runs into trouble. A conversion may be necessary to save the investment but generally means the interest is treated as a partnership interest from then on, which affects any later exchange.

Tenancy-in-common interests

A tenancy-in-common interest is an undivided fractional interest in the deed itself. Because co-owners who do more than hold and rent property can be treated as partners, the IRS published Rev. Proc. 2002-22, which lists conditions it requires before it will consider a ruling that a co-ownership is not a partnership. They include a limit of 35 co-owners, with a married couple counted as one, and unanimous approval of any sale, lease, hiring of a manager, or blanket loan. The IRS described these as guidelines for ruling requests rather than substantive rules, but sponsors and lenders generally structure TIC offerings to follow them.

The unanimity rule is the practical problem: one co-owner can block a sale or refinancing. In recent years DSTs have become the more common fractional structure. TIC ownership remains useful for smaller groups, including co-owners leaving a partnership, as discussed in our article on drop-and-swap exchanges.

DST and TIC compared

What you ownDST: a beneficial interest in a trust treated as an interest in the real estate. TIC: a deeded undivided interest in the property
Number of investorsDST: no 35-person limit; often many investors. TIC: generally up to 35 under Rev. Proc. 2002-22
DecisionsDST: the trustee and sponsor decide within narrow limits; investors do not vote. TIC: major decisions require all co-owners
FinancingDST: one loan obtained by the trust before investors buy in. TIC: one loan with each co-owner typically forming its own single-purpose entity
Raising new moneyDST: not permitted. TIC: possible if co-owners agree
Leaving earlyBoth: generally no market; resale depends on the sponsor or another buyer

The trade-offs

  • Illiquidity: the sponsor decides when the property is sold, often after five to ten years. There is usually no public market for the interests.
  • Fees: offering costs, sales commissions, acquisition fees, asset management fees, and a share of sale proceeds can be significant. Compare the price paid for the property with independent values and read the fee table in the offering documents.
  • No control: investors cannot fire the manager, refinance, or decide to sell.
  • Sponsor and tenant risk: results depend on the sponsor’s competence and on often one tenant or one market. A DST cannot raise new capital if the property needs it.
  • Securities rules: most DST and TIC interests are sold in private offerings that are limited to accredited investors. As of November 2026, the SEC’s definition for individuals includes net worth over $1 million, excluding the primary residence, or income over $200,000 ($300,000 with a spouse or partner) in each of the past two years, with a reasonable expectation of the same in the current year. Review the private placement memorandum carefully, and ask who is being paid to recommend the investment.

Replacing debt and balancing the exchange

To defer all of the gain, an investor generally must replace the debt paid off on the sale, as well as reinvest the cash. Most DSTs carry a loan arranged by the sponsor, and the investor’s share of that loan is generally treated as debt on the replacement property. A leveraged DST can therefore help an owner whose New York building carried a mortgage. Confirm the calculation with your tax adviser before identifying property.

DST interests are also used to complete exchanges. An investor who buys a building with most of the proceeds can place the remainder in a DST rather than take taxable cash, and a DST can serve as a backup identification if a direct purchase falls through after day 45. Interests sell out, so confirm availability and the closing timetable with the sponsor before identifying it.

The estate planning angle

Many owners plan to hold DST interests for life. Under current federal law, heirs generally receive a basis equal to the property’s value at death, which can eliminate the gain deferred through a chain of exchanges. Fractional interests are easier to divide among several heirs than one building, and when the sponsor later sells, each heir can decide separately whether to exchange again or take cash. Our article on 1031 exchanges and the step-up in basis covers this in more depth.

The interests remain part of the taxable estate, and New York’s estate tax has a sharp cliff for estates just over the exemption. New York income tax also continues to apply: a New York resident is generally taxed on the income from the interest wherever the property is located, whether or not it is distributed. See New York taxes on 1031 exchanges.

Questions to ask before you invest

  • Who is the sponsor, and how have its prior offerings performed through full cycles?
  • What are all of the fees, and how do they compare with the property’s value?
  • Who is the tenant, how long is the lease, and what happens if the tenant leaves?
  • What are the loan’s terms, maturity, and any cash-trap provisions?
  • Can the trust convert into an LLC, and what would that mean for a later exchange?
  • Does the closing timeline fit within your 45 and 180 days?

This article explains how these structures work under the tax rules. It is not a recommendation to buy any DST or TIC interest. These interests are securities, and whether one suits you depends on your finances and goals, so review any offering with an independent financial adviser and your tax adviser, as well as counsel.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.