Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
What happens to deferred 1031 gain when the owner dies?
Under current federal law, heirs generally take a basis equal to the property’s fair market value at death under Internal Revenue Code § 1014, so gain deferred through one or more 1031 exchanges is generally never taxed. Planners call this “swap till you drop.” Congress can change the rule, and the property still counts at full value for New York estate tax, whose 2026 exclusion is $7,350,000.
How “swap till you drop” works
In a 1031 exchange, the replacement property generally takes the basis of the property given up, adjusted for any boot and added investment. An investor who exchanges several times over decades can own a building worth many times its tax basis, with all of that gain deferred.
Under Internal Revenue Code § 1014(a), property acquired from a decedent generally takes a basis equal to its fair market value at the date of death, or at the alternate valuation date if the estate elects it. The heirs’ basis is reset, and the deferred gain — including gain from every earlier exchange in the chain — is generally never subject to income tax. Because the heirs start with a new basis, they generally have no depreciation recapture on the decedent’s deductions either. New York’s income tax follows the federal basis rules, so the result is generally the same for New York purposes.
Example: an owner’s building has a basis of $800,000 after three exchanges and is worth $5 million at death. If the owner had sold it the day before, about $4.2 million of gain would have been taxable. If the heirs sell it shortly after death for $5 million, there is generally little or no gain.
The law can change
The step-up at death and the 1031 exchange are both creatures of statute. Over the years, proposals have been made to cap exchange deferral or to tax unrealized gain at death, and some may return. A plan that holds property for life only to capture the step-up should be reviewed whenever the tax law changes, and it should still make sense as an investment if the rules shift.
If the owner dies in the middle of an exchange
An exchange started by the owner is not necessarily cancelled by the owner’s death. The IRS has reportedly allowed an estate to complete an exchange the decedent began in a private letter ruling, but a private ruling binds the IRS only as to the taxpayer that requested it. The § 1031 deadlines are not extended for a death, so the estate must still identify replacement property within 45 days and acquire it within the exchange period.
In New York, that timing is the practical problem. An executor has authority only after the Surrogate’s Court issues letters, which can take weeks or months. Property held in a funded revocable trust avoids that gap, because the successor trustee can act at once. See how long probate takes in New York and our comparison of a will and a revocable trust.
The income tax result of a death mid-exchange — whether the estate’s replacement property takes a stepped-up basis, and how the decedent’s final return reports the sale — is technical and fact-specific. The executor should involve a tax adviser and the qualified intermediary immediately.
DST and TIC interests in an estate
Investors near the end of an exchange chain often move into Delaware statutory trust (DST) interests, which require no management and come in fractional units. For an estate, that structure can be convenient: a DST holding can generally be divided among several heirs in proportionate interests without selling the underlying property, and each heir receives a stepped-up basis in the inherited share. The trade-off is liquidity. DST interests usually cannot be sold quickly, and heirs generally wait for the trust’s sponsor to sell the property.
Tenancy-in-common (TIC) interests are undivided interests in the real property itself. Heirs who inherit a TIC interest become co-owners with the other investors and are bound by the co-ownership agreement; disagreements can lead to a partition action. Whether a DST interest is treated like real property or like an intangible for New York estate tax purposes is a question to raise with counsel: for a nonresident, it can affect whether an interest in New York property is taxed, and for a resident, whether an interest in out-of-state property is excluded. Our article on DST and TIC interests in a 1031 exchange explains the structures themselves.
New York estate tax still applies
The step-up eliminates income tax on the deferred gain; it does nothing for estate tax. The property is included in the estate at full fair market value. For New York residents dying in 2026, the New York basic exclusion amount is $7,350,000, and if the taxable estate exceeds 105 percent of that amount — $7,717,500 — the exclusion is lost and the entire estate is taxed. Our article on the New York estate tax cliff explains the computation.
Location matters. A New York resident’s estate generally does not include real or tangible property located outside New York, so a replacement property in another state may fall outside the New York estate — though that state may impose its own estate tax and require its own probate proceeding. A nonresident’s estate is taxed by New York on New York real and tangible property. See moving out of New York: estate tax and domicile. The estate also needs cash to pay any tax within nine months, which can be hard when the main asset is a building or an illiquid DST.
Gifting exchanged property versus holding it
A lifetime gift removes the property and its future growth from the estate, which can help with New York estate tax. But under § 1015, the recipient generally takes the donor’s basis, so the deferred gain moves to the recipient rather than disappearing. For highly appreciated exchange property, holding until death and passing a stepped-up basis is often worth more to the family than the estate tax saved by a gift.
- New York adds back to a resident’s estate taxable gifts made within three years of death, with exceptions described in our estate tax articles; the add-back does not apply to deaths on or after January 1, 2032.
- A gift soon after an exchange can raise questions about whether the replacement property was held for investment. Timing should be reviewed with a tax adviser.
- A deed by gift without consideration is generally exempt from the State transfer tax, but a mortgage on the property can change the analysis.
- Gifts of interests in an LLC that owns the property, rather than deeds, are a common way to transfer value gradually; the LLC agreement must allow it.
Coordinating the plan
- Title. Know which person, trust, or LLC holds each property and DST interest, and whether it passes under the will, a trust, or the entity’s agreement.
- Records. Keep each Form 8824 and closing statement in the chain. Even with a step-up, the estate and heirs may need the history.
- Appraisals. Obtain a date-of-death appraisal to document the new basis, even when no estate tax return is due.
- Liquidity. Plan how the estate will pay New York estate tax and carrying costs without a forced sale.
- Heirs. Decide whether heirs will hold, sell, or exchange. Heirs can generally start their own exchanges with inherited investment property. Partnership interests raise separate issues; see our article on drop-and-swap exchanges.
- Review. Revisit the plan after each exchange; the basics of the exchange itself are in our guide to 1031 exchange timelines in New York.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.