Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

How do you compel an executor or trustee to account in New York?

Start with a written request for information. If the fiduciary does not respond or refuses to account, a beneficiary or other interested person can petition the Surrogate’s Court under SCPA § 2205 to compel an account, or bring a CPLR Article 77 proceeding in Supreme Court for many lifetime trusts. The court sets a deadline, can suspend a fiduciary who ignores it, and then rules on objections to the account.

What an accounting is

An accounting is the fiduciary’s formal report of everything that happened to the estate or trust: what was received, what was sold and for how much, what was paid out for expenses, taxes, and commissions, what was distributed and to whom, and what is left. In a judicial accounting, it is prepared on a standard set of schedules and filed with the court, which settles it by decree after interested persons have had a chance to object.

Accountings can be informal or judicial. Many estates close with an informal account, in which the executor shares the numbers and the beneficiaries sign receipts and releases. A judicial accounting is reviewed and settled by the court, and the decree protects the fiduciary from later claims on the matters it covers. A fiduciary can start one voluntarily, but when the fiduciary will not, a beneficiary can compel it. For an overview of the executor’s side of the process, see our guide to executor duties and commissions.

First step: a written request for information

Before going to court, ask in writing. Request an inventory of assets, account statements, the estate or trust tax returns, a list of expenses and distributions, and an informal account. A clear, dated request does two things. It often resolves the issue, because many fiduciaries are disorganized rather than dishonest. And if it is ignored, it supports a proceeding under SCPA § 2102, which allows a court to require a fiduciary to supply information about the estate’s assets or affairs that is relevant to the petitioner’s interest after a written request has gone unanswered.

Section 2102 also reaches beyond information. Other subdivisions allow a proceeding to compel payment of a legacy, a distributive share, or a trust interest, and to resolve disagreements between co-fiduciaries.

Petitioning to compel an account

SCPA § 2205 allows the Surrogate’s Court, at any time and in the best interests of the estate, to require a fiduciary to file an intermediate or final account. The court can act on its own initiative or on the petition of:

  • a person interested in the estate, such as a beneficiary or distributee;
  • a creditor;
  • a public administrator or county treasurer;
  • a person acting for an infant who is interested in the estate;
  • the fiduciary of a deceased interested person;
  • a surety on the fiduciary’s bond;
  • a successor or remaining fiduciary, where a predecessor or co-fiduciary was removed or its letters revoked;
  • a co-fiduciary who has filed its own account; and
  • the attorney general, where part of the estate may pass to the State.

The petition is filed in the Surrogate’s Court that issued the fiduciary’s letters. For a lifetime trust, CPLR Article 77 allows a special proceeding in Supreme Court to determine a matter relating to any express trust, and the parties may examine the trustee under oath about the administration. Surrogate’s Court often has jurisdiction over lifetime trusts as well, so the choice of forum is a strategic decision.

If the fiduciary still will not account

SCPA § 2206 gives the court real tools. If the fiduciary does not appear, does not account, and does not show good cause, the court may order the account within a set time, suspend the fiduciary’s letters, appoint a successor, and schedule hearings. If the fiduciary still refuses, the court may state the account itself after hearing the parties and enter whatever order justice requires. Under SCPA § 719, failing to appear or to file an account after being cited is also a ground on which the court can act on the fiduciary’s letters without a further petition. Our guide to removing an executor or trustee explains those remedies.

Objections, examinations, and surcharge

Filing the account is not the end. Interested persons may examine the fiduciary under oath and then file objections to specific items. Common objections include:

  • assets missing from the account or valued too low;
  • sales to the fiduciary or relatives, or loans to a fiduciary’s business;
  • failure to diversify or to monitor investments as the Prudent Investor Act, EPTL § 11-2.3, requires;
  • unreasonable delay in selling property, paying taxes, or distributing;
  • commissions calculated incorrectly, and legal or accounting fees that are excessive or duplicative; and
  • distributions that do not follow the will or trust.

If objections are sustained, the court can surcharge the fiduciary, making the fiduciary personally repay the loss, and can reduce or deny commissions in appropriate cases. Where an objection turns on what the will means, SCPA § 1420 treats it as a request to construe that provision. Many contested accountings settle once the numbers are on the table, often in court-annexed mediation.

The statute of limitations

Timing is a common defense. In Matter of Eisdorfer, decided in 2020, the Appellate Division, Second Department, held that a proceeding to compel a fiduciary to account is governed by the six-year limitations period of CPLR 213(1). Following the Court of Appeals’ decision in Matter of Barabash, the period generally begins only when the fiduciary openly repudiates the fiduciary role and the repudiation is made known to the beneficiaries. A mere lapse of time is not enough, and the party invoking the statute bears the burden of proving open repudiation.

That rule helps beneficiaries of long-running estates and trusts, but it is not a reason to wait. Other claims, such as fraud or claims against third parties, can have different periods, records disappear, and a final decree settling an account generally binds the parties who were properly before the court.

Practical steps for beneficiaries

  • Get a copy of the will or trust and the fiduciary’s letters, which identify the court.
  • Write to the fiduciary asking for specific information, and keep a record of the request and any reply.
  • Gather what you already know about the assets: account statements, deeds, prior tax returns, and correspondence.
  • Calendar the dates that matter, including when letters were issued and any communication in which the fiduciary refused to account.
  • Ask whether you can resolve the issue through an informal account, and review any release carefully before signing it.
  • If you are a fiduciary, consider whether a voluntary judicial accounting would protect you from a long-running dispute.

We represent beneficiaries who need answers and fiduciaries who want to account and close an estate or trust. If the dispute concerns whether the will itself is valid, see our guide to contesting a will in New York.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.