Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Can you remove an executor or trustee in New York?

Yes, but only on grounds the law recognizes. Under SCPA § 711, a beneficiary, co-fiduciary, creditor, or surety can petition the Surrogate’s Court to suspend or revoke letters for reasons such as wasting estate property, unauthorized investments, disobeying court orders, or failing to account. Under SCPA § 719, the court can also act without a petition in some cases, such as commingling. Disagreement or hostility alone is usually not enough.

Why removal is hard

A will names the executor and a trust names the trustee because the person who created them chose that fiduciary. Courts give that choice weight. Removing a fiduciary disrupts administration, adds cost, and overrides the decedent’s or grantor’s judgment, so courts generally treat it as a serious remedy reserved for cases where the estate or trust is at real risk. The petitioner should expect to prove a ground the statute recognizes, with evidence, not just show that the family and the fiduciary do not get along.

Grounds under SCPA § 711

IneligibilityThe fiduciary was ineligible or disqualified when letters issued, or became so later
Waste and mismanagementWasting or improperly applying property, making unauthorized investments, or otherwise improvidently managing or injuring the property
UnfitnessMisconduct, dishonesty, improvidence, want of understanding, or other conduct that makes the fiduciary unfit for the office
Disobeying the courtWillfully refusing, or without good cause neglecting, to obey a lawful court order or a provision of law governing the fiduciary’s duties
False statementLetters obtained through a false statement of a material fact
Removing propertyRemoving estate property from New York without prior court approval
Address changeFailing without sufficient reason to notify the court of a change of address within 30 days
Testamentary trusteeViolating or threatening to violate the trust, insolvency, or other unsuitability to execute the trust
Lifetime trusteeAny ground on which the Supreme Court would remove or suspend the trustee
Failure to accountFailing to file an account within the time and in the manner the court directs

Who may petition: a co-fiduciary, a creditor, a person interested in the estate, a person acting on behalf of an infant, or a surety on the fiduciary’s bond. The petition asks the court to cite the fiduciary to show cause why the letters should not be suspended, modified, or revoked.

When the court acts on its own: SCPA § 719

Some situations are serious enough that the court may act without a petition or further process. SCPA § 719 lists them, including when:

  • a fiduciary cited to account fails to appear without a satisfactory excuse, or fails to file the account;
  • the fiduciary has absconded or is concealing themselves so that process cannot be served;
  • the fiduciary fails to provide information about the estate as ordered under SCPA § 2102;
  • the fiduciary is convicted of a felony, is judicially committed, or is declared incompetent;
  • the fiduciary mingles estate funds with personal funds or deposits them in an account not held in a fiduciary capacity; or
  • any of the facts listed in § 711 are brought to the court’s attention.

In practice, these provisions often come into play after a beneficiary has started a proceeding to compel information or an accounting and the fiduciary does not comply. See our guide to compelling an executor or trustee to account.

Conflicts of interest

Many executors and trustees are also beneficiaries, and some have business or personal dealings with the estate. A conflict alone is not always a ground for removal, especially when the testator or grantor knew about it and chose the fiduciary anyway. Courts are more likely to act when a conflict leads to actual harm or a real risk of it: the executor who wants to buy the house below value, the trustee who will not pursue a claim against a relative, or the co-owner of the family business who uses the estate’s shares to keep control. Self-dealing and failure to act impartially are also grounds for objections to the fiduciary’s account and for surcharge.

Suspension, successors, and interim protection

Removal takes time. While the proceeding is pending, the court may suspend a fiduciary’s letters or limit the fiduciary’s powers, for example by restricting the sale of real property or requiring that funds be held in a restricted account. If letters are revoked, the court appoints a successor, often the alternate named in the will or trust, or, where none is available or appropriate, another eligible person or the public administrator in some estates. The removed fiduciary generally must account for the period of service and deliver the property to the successor.

Lifetime trusts

For a lifetime trust, removal can be sought in Supreme Court under CPLR Article 77 or, where the Surrogate’s Court has jurisdiction over the trust, under SCPA § 711, which allows removal of a lifetime trustee on any ground on which the Supreme Court would act. Many trust instruments also give a beneficiary, protector, or committee a power to remove and replace trustees without going to court. Check the instrument first: an in-document removal power is usually faster and cheaper than litigation. A trustee also cannot use a decanting to eliminate another person’s existing right to remove or replace the trustee, unless a court directs otherwise; see our guide to decanting a trust in New York.

Building the case

  • Document requests and responses, including requests for information that went unanswered.
  • Account statements, closing statements, and tax returns showing what the fiduciary did with the assets.
  • Evidence of self-dealing, such as transactions with relatives or the fiduciary’s own businesses.
  • Court orders the fiduciary has not followed, and deadlines missed.
  • A realistic assessment of the cost and delay of removal compared with alternatives such as a compelled accounting, a surcharge, or a negotiated resignation.

We represent beneficiaries seeking to remove fiduciaries and fiduciaries defending their administration. If the dispute is about whether the will should have been admitted at all, see our guide to contesting a will.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.