Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

What are an executor’s duties and commissions in New York?

Once the Surrogate’s Court issues letters testamentary, an executor must collect the assets, pay valid debts and taxes, and distribute what remains as the will directs. Executors usually wait at least seven months after letters issue before significant distributions, because of SCPA 1802. Statutory commissions under SCPA 2307 are 5 percent of the first $100,000, stepping down to 2 percent above $5 million. An executor who distributes too early or self-deals can be personally liable.

What the job is

An executor is a fiduciary who must collect the decedent’s assets, pay valid debts and taxes, and distribute what remains as the will directs, putting the estate’s interests ahead of his or her own. The duty of loyalty and the duty of care apply from the day letters issue until the estate is closed and the executor is discharged.

Step by step

  • Locate the original will and file the probate petition in the Surrogate’s Court of the county where the decedent lived.
  • Obtain letters testamentary. Before then, the named executor generally cannot sign for the estate, though the court can issue preliminary letters if action is urgent.
  • Obtain a taxpayer identification number for the estate and open an estate bank account. Never deposit estate funds into a personal account.
  • Secure and insure property. Change locks if needed, keep insurance in force on real estate and valuables, and pay co-op maintenance or condominium charges to avoid arrears.
  • Inventory the assets and obtain date-of-death values, including appraisals for real estate and closely held businesses.
  • Identify creditors, review claims, and pay valid debts in the priority SCPA 1811 sets, starting with funeral and administration expenses.
  • File the decedent’s final income tax returns, the estate’s fiduciary income tax returns, and any estate tax returns.
  • Account to the beneficiaries and obtain receipts and releases, or file a judicial accounting.
  • Distribute the remaining assets and close the estate.

Creditors and the seven-month window

SCPA 1802 protects an executor who, in good faith, pays claims or distributes the estate after seven months from the issuance of letters, against creditors who had not presented claims by then. Before that point, an executor who distributes and later finds the estate short can be personally liable to a creditor for the amount wrongly distributed. Claims are not barred by the seven-month period itself; it limits the fiduciary’s exposure and affects what the creditor can recover from the remaining assets. Executors therefore typically make only modest distributions, if any, during the first seven months.

Taxes

Final individual income tax returnsFederal and New York, for the year of death
Estate fiduciary income tax returnsFederal Form 1041 and New York Form IT-205, for each year the estate earns income above filing thresholds
New York estate tax return, Form ET-706Due nine months after death if the estate is above the filing threshold
Federal estate tax return, Form 706Due nine months after death if required, or to elect portability for a surviving spouse

Extensions to file are available in some cases, but interest and penalties can still accrue on unpaid tax. Federal and New York law can make an executor personally responsible for unpaid taxes if estate assets were distributed first, so tax reserves should be held back until the returns are accepted.

Accounting and closing

An executor must account for every dollar received, spent, and distributed. Most estates close informally: the executor gives the beneficiaries an accounting and each signs a receipt and release. If a beneficiary will not sign, or the executor wants the protection of a court decree, the executor files a judicial accounting, and the decree settling the account discharges the executor for the matters it covers.

Commissions

SCPA 2307 sets the executor’s commission as a percentage of the property the executor receives and pays out:

First $100,0005 percent
Next $200,0004 percent
Next $700,0003 percent
Next $4,000,0002.5 percent
Above $5,000,0002 percent

For example, on a $1,000,000 estate the statutory commission would be $5,000 plus $8,000 plus $21,000, or $34,000. Property specifically left to a beneficiary, and real estate that passes without being sold, are generally treated differently in the calculation. When there are multiple executors and the estate is $300,000 or more, each is generally entitled to a full commission, up to three; above that, three commissions are divided according to services. A will can fix a different amount, and an executor may waive commissions. Commissions are taxable income to the executor, while legal fees are separate and are reviewed by the court for reasonableness.

Personal liability risks

  • Distributing before paying creditors, taxes, and expenses.
  • Commingling estate funds with personal funds.
  • Self-dealing, such as buying estate property or using it without full disclosure and consent or court approval.
  • Letting property go uninsured or unmaintained, or leaving cash idle for an extended period.
  • Missing tax deadlines, which can produce penalties charged against the executor.

We represent executors through probate, accountings, and disputes with beneficiaries, and we advise beneficiaries who question how an estate is being run.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.