Payer Audit and Recoupment Defense Payer audits and recoupment defense.

A records request from a health plan can turn into a demand to repay years of claims. How the practice responds in the first weeks shapes the outcome.

We represent physicians and practices when commercial health plans audit claims, allege overpayments, or offset future payments against past claims.

New York limits how insurers recover overpayments from providers. Insurance Law § 3224-b requires an insurer to give a health care provider written notice at least 30 days before beginning overpayment recovery, and, except in cases of fraud, abuse, or certain other circumstances, bars an insurer from starting recovery more than 24 months after the original payment. Contracts with participating providers often add their own audit and appeal procedures.

Extrapolation and coding disputes deserve scrutiny. Plans may review a sample of claims and project an error rate across a larger universe. The sampling method, the coding guidance applied, and the medical necessity criteria used are all open to challenge.

Our capabilities include:

  • Responses to medical records requests
  • Review of audit findings and sampling methods
  • Internal appeals and contract dispute procedures
  • Challenges to recoupment and offsets
  • Negotiated repayment and settlement terms
  • Compliance reviews to reduce future audit risk

How a commercial payer audit unfolds

  1. Records request

    The plan asks for medical records for a set of claims, often with a short deadline.

  2. Findings

    The plan issues findings, sometimes extrapolating an error rate across other claims.

  3. Notice of recovery

    Under New York law, the plan must give written notice at least 30 days before recovering an overpayment.

  4. Appeal and negotiation

    The provider appeals under the contract or plan procedures and negotiates any repayment.

  5. Recoupment or resolution

    The plan recovers by demand or offset, or the matter is resolved by agreement or in litigation.

Issues we raise

  • Timeliness

    Whether the recovery began within the 24-month limit and with proper notice.

  • Documentation

    Whether the records support the services billed, including addenda and attestations made in the ordinary course.

  • Coding and policy

    Whether the plan applied the coding rules and payment policies in effect on the date of service.

  • Sampling

    Whether the sample was valid and the extrapolation was permitted by the contract.

Key terms

Recoupment
A health plan’s recovery of money it claims it overpaid, by demand or by offset.
Offset
Reducing payments on current claims to recover an alleged overpayment on past claims.
Insurance Law § 3224-b
The New York statute governing insurers’ overpayment recovery from providers.
Post-payment audit
A review of claims after they have been paid.
Prepayment review
A plan’s review of claims, often with records, before paying them.
Extrapolation
Projecting an error rate from a sample of claims to a larger group of claims.
Medical necessity
Whether a service was reasonable and necessary under the plan’s criteria.
Coding validation
Review of whether CPT and diagnosis codes match the documentation.
Special investigations unit
A plan unit that investigates suspected fraud or abuse.
Participating provider agreement
The contract between a provider and a plan, which often sets audit and appeal rules.
Payment policy
A plan’s published rules on how it pays particular services.
Prompt pay law
Insurance Law § 3224-a, which sets deadlines for paying clean claims.

Questions we hear most

How far back can a New York insurer recoup a payment?

Generally no more than 24 months after the original payment, under Insurance Law § 3224-b, except in cases such as fraud or abuse and other circumstances the statute specifies.

Does the insurer have to warn us before recouping?

Yes. Under § 3224-b, the insurer must give written notice at least 30 days before beginning overpayment recovery efforts.

Should we send the records the plan asked for?

Usually yes, but review the request first. Send complete, organized records by the deadline, and keep a copy of exactly what was produced.

Can the plan offset our future claims?

Plans commonly recover by offset once notice and any contract procedures are satisfied. The timing and amount can be challenged.

Is an out-of-network provider subject to plan audits?

Plans may request records to adjudicate claims, and § 3224-b’s recovery rules apply to health care providers generally. The plan’s rights also depend on any assignment of benefits and the plan documents.

What if the plan says the claims were coded incorrectly?

Compare the coding guidance in effect on the date of service with the documentation. Disagreements over modifiers and levels of service are common and often negotiable.

Should we stop billing the plan during an audit?

Not without advice. Continuing to bill properly documented services is usually appropriate, but billing practices identified in the audit should be reviewed.

Can an audit lead to removal from a network?

Participating provider contracts often allow termination for cause or without cause on notice. Contract terms and any applicable statutory protections should be reviewed.

What does the 24-month limit not cover?

The statute’s exceptions, including fraud and abuse, and adjustments under certain government program and contract arrangements. The exceptions should be read against the specific facts.

Does a settlement have to admit wrongdoing?

No. Repayment agreements can resolve an audit without admissions, and terms such as payment schedules and releases are negotiable.
Contact

Request a claims review

Tell us about your practice, your specialty, and your approximate volume of out-of-network commercial claims. We will review your accounts receivable at no charge, identify claims eligible under New York law or the No Surprises Act, and give you a candid assessment. Surprise billing arbitration is handled on a contingency basis under a written engagement letter.

Request a claims review

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content