Managed Care Contracting and Disputes Managed care contracting and payer disputes.

A participating provider agreement sets a practice’s rates, its audit exposure, and its rights if the plan wants out. The terms worth negotiating are easiest to change before signing.

We represent physicians, group practices, and ambulatory providers in negotiating, reviewing, and enforcing contracts with commercial health plans and in disputes over payment and network termination.

Participating provider agreements usually consist of a short signature document that incorporates fee schedules, provider manuals, and payment policies the plan may change on notice. Reviewing the agreement means reviewing those incorporated documents as well: how rates are set and updated, which payment policies apply, what audit and recoupment rights the plan reserves, how disputes are resolved, and how either side can end the relationship.

New York law limits what a plan can require. Public Health Law § 4406-c and its counterpart for insurers, Insurance Law § 3217-b, bar contract terms that restrict a provider from discussing treatment options with patients, from advocating for a patient’s coverage, or from complaining to government agencies, and generally bar shifting the plan’s own liability to the provider. Public Health Law § 4406-d and Insurance Law § 4803 require a written explanation and an opportunity for a hearing before a plan terminates a participating professional mid-contract, subject to exceptions such as imminent harm to patients, fraud, and final disciplinary action.

Payment disputes under a participating agreement are governed by the contract, the Prompt Pay Law, and the overpayment recovery rules. Insurance Law § 3224-a generally requires payment of undisputed clean claims within 30 days when submitted electronically and 45 days on paper, with interest for late payment, and § 3224-b limits when and how a plan can recoup prior payments.

Our capabilities include:

  • Review and negotiation of participating provider agreements
  • Fee schedule, escalator, and payment policy terms
  • Prompt pay and underpayment claims
  • Termination hearings and non-renewal strategy
  • Arbitration and litigation of contract disputes
  • Credentialing and network participation issues
  • Transitions from participating to out-of-network status

Contract terms we review

  • Rates and updates

    Whether rates are a fixed schedule, a percentage of Medicare or another benchmark, and how and when the plan may change them.

  • Incorporated documents

    Provider manuals, payment policies, and coding edits the plan can amend on notice, and whether the practice can object or exit.

  • Products covered

    Which commercial, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid managed care, and exchange products the agreement covers, and whether the practice can opt out of any.

  • Audit and recoupment

    Records access, sampling and extrapolation rights, appeal procedures, and offset rights.

  • Disputes

    Internal appeal steps, mediation or arbitration clauses, venue, and limits on remedies.

  • Term and termination

    Renewal dates, notice periods for non-renewal and termination without cause, and continuation-of-care obligations.

New York protections for participating providers

Communication with patientsPlans may not restrict discussion of treatment options or advocacy for coverage (PHL § 4406-c; Ins. Law § 3217-b)
Mid-term terminationWritten reasons and a hearing before a panel including a clinical peer, with exceptions (PHL § 4406-d; Ins. Law § 4803)
Timing of terminationGenerally no earlier than 60 days after notice and 30 days after the panel’s decision
Non-renewalEither party may decline to renew on 60 days’ notice; not treated as a termination for hearing purposes
Clean claim payment30 days electronic, 45 days paper, with interest on late payment (Ins. Law § 3224-a)
Claim submissionPlans generally must allow at least 120 days after the date of service to submit claims

When a plan proposes to terminate

  1. Read the notice

    Identify whether it is a termination for cause, without cause, or a non-renewal, and the deadline to request a hearing.

  2. Request the hearing

    Request review in writing within the stated period, which must be at least 30 days.

  3. Prepare the record

    Assemble quality, credentialing, and claims data responding to each stated reason.

  4. Plan for patients

    Address continuation-of-care obligations and patient notices while the process runs.

Key terms

Participating provider agreement
The contract under which a provider joins a health plan’s network and accepts its rates.
Fee schedule
The list of amounts the plan pays for each service under the contract.
Escalator
A clause increasing rates on a set schedule or by reference to an index.
Provider manual
The plan’s administrative rules, usually incorporated into the contract by reference.
Payment policy
A plan rule on how particular services, codes, or modifiers are paid.
All-products clause
A term requiring the provider to participate in every product the plan offers.
Clean claim
A claim with the information needed to adjudicate it and no basis for dispute.
Prompt Pay Law
Insurance Law § 3224-a, setting payment deadlines and interest for late payment.
PHL § 4406-c
The statute barring HMO contract terms that restrict provider communication, advocacy, or complaints.
PHL § 4406-d
The statute requiring notice and a hearing before an HMO terminates a participating professional.
Insurance Law §§ 3217-b and 4803
The counterparts of PHL §§ 4406-c and 4406-d for insurers.
Clinical peer
A professional in the same or similar discipline who must sit on a termination hearing panel.
Continuation of care
Rules allowing certain patients to keep seeing a provider for a period after the provider leaves the network.
Network adequacy
Regulatory requirements that a plan’s network have enough providers to serve its members.

Questions we hear most

Can a health plan drop our practice from its network?

A plan generally may decline to renew a contract on 60 days’ notice, and the contract may allow termination without cause. A mid-term termination of a participating professional generally requires written reasons and the opportunity for a hearing under Public Health Law § 4406-d or Insurance Law § 4803.

Can a plan retaliate because we appealed denials for our patients?

No. New York law bars a plan from terminating or refusing to renew a contract solely because the provider advocated for a patient, filed a complaint, appealed a plan decision, or requested a hearing.

How quickly must a plan pay a clean claim?

Under Insurance Law § 3224-a, generally within 30 days of receipt for claims submitted electronically and 45 days for paper claims. If the plan disputes a claim or needs more information, it must say so within 30 days.

Should we sign a contract that lets the plan change its payment policies?

Most contracts allow some changes on notice. The questions are how much notice, whether material changes require consent or allow the practice to exit, and whether the change can reduce rates indirectly.

Is an arbitration clause in our payer contract enforceable?

Generally yes, and New York courts enforce arbitration agreements under CPLR Article 75 and the Federal Arbitration Act. Review the clause for its scope, the rules and forum, cost allocation, and any limits on remedies before signing.

What does the hearing panel look like in a termination?

Under PHL § 4406-d, a panel of at least three people appointed by the plan, at least one of whom is a clinical peer in the same discipline and the same or a similar area of practice.

Can we leave a network and bill out of network?

Yes, on the notice the contract requires, but patients’ continuation-of-care rights, state surprise bill rules, and the federal No Surprises Act will shape what can be billed and how payment disputes are resolved.

What is the deadline for submitting claims?

The contract sets it, but New York generally requires insurers and HMOs to allow at least 120 days after the date of service, with a process to reconsider some late claims.

Can a plan pay less than our contract rate?

Not if the contract sets the rate and the claim is payable. Underpayments can be appealed under the contract and pursued under the Prompt Pay Law and in arbitration or court as the contract allows.

Do these protections apply to self-funded employer plans?

State insurance laws generally do not apply to self-funded ERISA plans, though the network contract with the administrator may still be enforceable on its own terms.
Contact

Request a claims review

Tell us about your practice, your specialty, and your approximate volume of out-of-network commercial claims. We will review your accounts receivable at no charge, identify claims eligible under New York law or the No Surprises Act, and give you a candid assessment. Surprise billing arbitration is handled on a contingency basis under a written engagement letter.

Request a claims review

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content