Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
Why are so many rent-stabilized apartments in NYC vacant, and what can owners do?
Owners point to the 2019 rent law: no vacancy increase, no deregulation, and renovation recovery capped, now at $30,000 or $50,000 per apartment over 15 years. Tenant advocates say many vacancies are ordinary turnover. Owners must still register the unit, keep it in good repair, and avoid harassment. Options include the IAI tiers, combining units, HPD programs, or selling. A City Council bill would only require an HPD study and plan.
How many rent-stabilized apartments are vacant?
The answer depends on who is counting and what they count. As of November 2026, the most widely reported figure comes from the owners’ own annual registrations with New York State Homes and Community Renewal (HCR), the agency whose Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR) administers rent stabilization. According to Gothamist, HCR told the Rent Guidelines Board in 2026 that 57,421 stabilized apartments were registered as vacant as of April 1, 2025, about 8,000 more than a year earlier. THE CITY, analyzing the same registration data obtained through a Freedom of Information Law request, reported about 57,000 vacant units in 2025, roughly 5.6 percent of about one million stabilized apartments, up from 3.7 percent in 2016.
HCR itself has cautioned, as reported in the press, that a vacant registration is a point-in-time snapshot that does not show why a unit is empty, its condition, or whether it is simply between tenants. The count can also include new buildings still leasing up.
The City’s own 2023 Housing and Vacancy Survey, an interview-based survey, measured something narrower. It found 26,310 rent-stabilized units that were vacant and not available for rent in 2023, down from 42,860 in 2021, and a net rental vacancy rate of 0.98 percent within the rent-stabilized stock. Across all housing types, renovation was the second most common reason a vacant unit was off the market. Neither data source, by itself, tells an owner, a buyer or a policymaker how many units are being held off the market deliberately.
Why owners say units sit empty: the 2019 rent law
The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 (HSTPA) changed what happens when a stabilized tenant moves out. Before June 14, 2019, an owner could generally add a statutory vacancy increase of up to 20 percent, sometimes a longevity bonus, and eventually remove a high-rent apartment from stabilization. HSTPA repealed the vacancy bonus, the longevity bonus, high-rent vacancy deregulation, and high-income deregulation.
Today, the rent on a new lease starts from the prior legal regulated rent. HSTPA eliminated the statutory vacancy increase and does not allow rent guidelines boards to set a separate vacancy rate; a one- or two-year guideline can be added on a vacancy lease only if the Board’s order authorizes it, and no more than one guideline adjustment per guideline year (see the Rent Guidelines Board’s vacancy lease page and HCR’s Fact Sheet #5 on vacancy leases). Orders #52 through #58 have authorized it. Order #58 sets 0 percent for one- and two-year leases beginning October 1, 2026, and applies to vacant units that become occupied during its term. Lawful IAI and MCI increases can also be added, and on a vacancy the owner may add any remaining balance of a phased-in MCI increase under Rent Stabilization Law § 26-511. No vacancy-lease increase can be collected while a DHCR order reducing the rent for decreased services is in effect. Owners have challenged the freeze in court; see our article on the 2026 rent freeze and the RGB lawsuit.
One rule helps some owners. If the outgoing tenant paid a preferential rent below the legal regulated rent, the owner may, at its option, charge the next tenant either the preferential rent or up to the previously established legal regulated rent, adjusted by the most recent applicable guideline and other lawful increases (Rent Stabilization Code, 9 NYCRR § 2521.2(a); see HCR’s Fact Sheet #40 on preferential rents). The legal regulated rent must have been registered with DHCR and stated in the prior lease. In buildings that are stabilized under a regulatory agreement and receive project-based rental assistance, the statute adds a condition: the vacancy must not have been caused by the owner’s failure to keep the apartment habitable. Bills to apply that condition to all stabilized apartments have been introduced but, as of November 2026, have not become law. How post-2019 concessions are treated is a separate and contested question; see our article on Grey v. LIC and rent concessions.
Owners and their trade groups argue that, for an apartment that needs a full renovation after a decades-long tenancy, the allowable rent does not cover the cost of the work, so the unit stays empty. Tenant advocates respond that many vacancies are ordinary turnover and that the numbers are being used to argue for weaker protections. Both positions appear in the public record; the law described below applies either way.
The renovation math: IAI rules after the 2024 changes
An individual apartment improvement (IAI) is work inside one apartment, such as a new kitchen, bathroom, or wiring, that lets the owner add a monthly increase to the legal rent. HSTPA capped IAI spending at $15,000 over 15 years and made the increase temporary. Changes to the law effective October 17, 2024 created two tiers, eliminated the limit of three separate IAIs, and, according to HCR, made the increase permanent.
| Tier 1 cap | Up to $30,000; occupied or vacant units |
|---|---|
| Tier 1 monthly increase | 1/168 of cost in buildings of 35 or fewer units (up to $178.57); 1/180 in larger buildings (up to $166.67) |
| Tier 2 cap | Up to $50,000; vacant units only; DHCR must first certify eligibility |
| Tier 2 eligibility | Unit timely registered as vacant in 2022, 2023 and 2024 (an owner may use this route only once), or vacant after at least 25 years of continuous occupancy |
| Tier 2 monthly increase | 1/144 of cost in buildings of 35 or fewer units (up to $347.22); 1/156 in larger buildings (up to $320.51) |
HCR describes these limits as applying within a 15-year period. Costs already recovered under the 2019 rules between June 14, 2019 and October 17, 2024 count against the new cap.
The paperwork matters as much as the cap. Under HCR’s Operational Bulletin 2024-2 (revised October 29, 2025), every IAI is reported on Form RN-19N with before and after photos. A Tier 2 owner must, before work begins, show a substandard condition or exhausted useful life, submit photos and permits, and affirm that it has had no DHCR or court finding of harassment or willful overcharge in the prior five years. After the work, it files invoices and proof of payment and pays a 1 percent fee on the claimed cost. Costs paid to an affiliated contractor are disallowed, an outside contractor must be licensed, and hazardous violations for the apartment must be cleared. HCR asks for cancelled checks, a paid invoice, a signed contract, a contractor’s affidavit, and photos. An unsupported increase can become an overcharge, potentially with treble damages; see our discussion of overcharge exposure.
MCIs, operating costs, and where the numbers break down
A major capital improvement (MCI) is building-wide work, such as a new boiler, roof, windows, or rewiring. It requires a DHCR order on an application filed within two years of installation. Under current rules, MCI increases are capped at 2 percent of the rent per year, are removed after 30 years, are amortized over 12 years (35 or fewer units) or 12.5 years (more than 35 units), and are not available in buildings where 35 percent or fewer of the units are rent regulated or where hazardous violations are on file. An MCI helps pay for systems; it does not pay for renovating one empty apartment.
Owners also cite rising operating costs, including taxes, insurance, fuel, labor, and debt service, which the Rent Guidelines Board tracks each year. For an investor, the practical question is unit by unit: what the legal rent will be after the permitted increases, what the work will cost, and whether the building’s finances can carry the gap. That analysis belongs in any purchase of a stabilized building.
What owners must do while a unit is vacant
- Register it with DHCR. Annual registration is required for every rent-regulated building and reflects each apartment’s status on April 1; filings are due by July 31. A vacant unit is registered as vacant. HCR says delinquent owners face a fine of $500 per unregistered unit for each month registrations are late, and an owner that fails to register generally cannot collect increases above the last registered rent until it does.
- Register the building with HPD. Buildings with three or more units must register annually with the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) by September 1. Without a valid registration, an owner cannot bring a nonpayment case, request a violation dismissal, or certify corrections, and faces civil penalties.
- Keep the vacant unit in good repair. Local Law 1 of 2024 requires owners of multiple dwellings to maintain unoccupied units. If HPD receives a complaint, including through 311, that a vacant unit has pests, leaks, mold, refuse, unsecured openings, or inadequate firestopping that may affect an occupied unit, the owner must schedule an inspection within 21 days. HPD checks those items and smoke and carbon monoxide detectors, issues violations for hazardous conditions, and posts them online.
- Do lead turnover work before re-renting. In multiple dwellings built before 1960, HPD requires turnover work before a new tenant moves in, whether or not the new tenant has a child under six, including correcting peeling paint, abating door and window friction surfaces and chewable surfaces, and making floors, sills and window wells smooth and cleanable, with records kept for 10 years.
- Check insurance. Property and liability policies often limit coverage for vacant or unoccupied space. Ask the broker how your policy treats long-vacant apartments, and secure the units against water, fire, and entry.
- Pull permits. Renovations need the right Department of Buildings filings, and Tier 2 IAIs require submitting permits to DHCR. Open violations can block both IAI and MCI increases. Clearing them early keeps both options open.
Options for bringing a vacant unit back under current law
- Renovate within the IAI tiers. For a unit registered vacant in 2022 through 2024, or vacated after a tenancy of 25 years or more, Tier 2 allows up to $50,000 once DHCR certifies eligibility. Run the numbers before applying: the increase is fixed by formula, not by market rent.
- Combine or reconfigure apartments. Under 2023 and 2024 amendments, when stabilized units are combined, the first rent is generally the combined legal rents of the prior units plus authorized increases, and the new apartment stays stabilized if any source unit was regulated. Combining can make a layout more rentable, but it is no longer a path to a market rent, and increases can be denied where the vacancy followed harassment or fraud.
- Substantial rehabilitation. Buildings substantially rehabilitated as family units on or after January 1, 1974 are exempt from stabilization. The exemption is building-wide, under DHCR guidance generally requires replacing most building-wide systems in a substandard or seriously deteriorated building, and for work begun on or after January 1, 2024 requires the owner to seek DHCR approval within one year of completion and obtain it. Approval must be denied if the owner or a predecessor harassed tenants in the five years before completion. It is rarely a fit for a single vacant apartment in an occupied building.
- City programs. HPD’s Unlocking Doors pilot offers up to $50,000 per unit for qualifying repairs to apartments registered vacant in 2023 and 2024 with legal rents under set thresholds, if the owner offers a two-year lease to a CityFHEPS voucher holder. The pilot is limited to 200 units, and The Real Deal reported in September 2025 that it had not yet made an award; check with HPD whether it is accepting applications. The relaunched J-51 property tax abatement for capital improvements and HPD’s CPAR loans for moderate rehabilitation support buildings with affordable rents, in exchange for continued stabilization and other terms. Eligibility is program-specific.
- Sell. Some owners conclude a building’s economics work better for a buyer with a different cost of capital or a preservation subsidy. Beginning in late 2027, sales of certain covered buildings will be subject to New York City’s Community Opportunity to Purchase Act; see our COPA guide.
What the law does and does not prohibit
As of November 2026, we are not aware of any state or city law that requires an owner to re-rent a vacant stabilized apartment by a deadline or penalizes leaving it empty. A state bill that would prohibit intentionally withholding a housing accommodation from the market and impose civil penalties (S.1217 / A.1618) remained in the Senate and Assembly housing committees as of its last recorded action, a re-referral on January 7, 2026, and has not become law. That could change. The absence of a vacancy penalty is not a safe harbor: a long-vacant unit must still be registered accurately and maintained, and the circumstances of how a unit became vacant can be examined in harassment, overcharge and fraud proceedings.
Other rules apply with full force. New York City’s Housing Maintenance Code prohibits harassing tenants to induce them to leave, and amendments enacted in 2023 and 2024 allow combined-unit increases to be denied where a vacancy resulted from harassment, fraud or other evasion, and require denial of a substantial-rehabilitation exemption where the owner engaged in harassment in the five years before the work was completed. Rent registrations and IAI filings must be accurate; false filings can produce overcharge liability and loss of the increase.
Good Cause Eviction is not the issue here. That law governs rent increases and evictions in many unregulated apartments, and rent-stabilized units are exempt from it; see our Good Cause article for the rules that do apply to market-rate units.
Pending: City Council Int. 1165-2026 (as of November 20, 2026)
On November 12, 2026, Council Member Farah N. Louis introduced Int. 1165-2026, “A Local Law in relation to an analysis and plan on vacant rent-stabilized dwelling units.” Legistar shows it was referred the same day to the Committee on Housing and Buildings, with no further action. According to a November 12, 2026 report in 6sqft, Speaker Julie Menin supported the bill at that day’s Stated Meeting, calling it “unconscionable” that over 50,000 rent-stabilized units are sitting vacant.
As introduced, the bill would require HPD to analyze factors that may contribute to vacancies — financial conditions such as inflation, renovation costs, operating costs, insolvency, and rent collected; habitability standards and enforcement; financial incentives and owner participation rates; the laws governing owners’ use of these units; physical condition by building age and borough; and how many stabilized and market-rate units the owners of vacant units hold. HPD would then propose policies, including grants, subsidies, loans, tax incentives, and vouchers; penalties, fines, or fees for units that remain unavailable; habitability enforcement; renovation programs; and data collection. The analysis and plan would be due to the Speaker and the Mayor, and posted on HPD’s website, within 60 days after the law takes effect, which would be immediately on enactment.
It is a study bill. As introduced, it imposes no new duty, fee, or penalty on any owner, and it could be amended, merged with other bills, or never pass. What owners should watch: whether the committee holds a hearing, whether the text is amended to add mandates, and, if it passes, what HPD’s plan recommends, especially any proposed penalties or new data reporting, which would need separate legislation. Meanwhile, accurate DHCR registrations and maintained vacant units put an owner in the strongest position under any outcome.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.