Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
What did Grey v. LIC Development Owner decide?
In March 2026, the First Department upheld summary judgment for a tenant class on overcharge claims based on rent concessions offered after June 14, 2019, treating them under the preferential rent rules. It declared rent-free early occupancy licenses void as an unlawful waiver of rent stabilization and froze affected tenants’ rents under RSL § 26-517(e) until proper registrations are filed.
The case
Grey v LIC Development Owner, L.P. is a class action by tenants of rent-stabilized apartments in a rental building owned by LIC Development Owner, L.P. The tenants claimed that the owner’s use of rent concessions and rent-free early occupancy licenses produced rent overcharges. In an April 4, 2025 order, Supreme Court (Bluth, J.) granted the tenants summary judgment on their post-HSTPA concession claims and denied it on the pre-HSTPA claims.
The Appellate Division, First Department (Manzanet-Daniels, J.P., Kapnick, Shulman, and Hagler, JJ.) decided both sides’ appeals on March 17, 2026. It modified the order to grant the tenants more relief on the early occupancy licenses and otherwise affirmed. It also affirmed the denial of the owner’s motion to renew.
Concessions after the HSTPA
The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 (HSTPA), effective June 14, 2019, changed how preferential rents work. Once an owner charges a tenant less than the legal regulated rent, renewal increases are generally calculated from the rent actually charged, not from the higher legal rent, for the life of the tenancy.
The court noted that DHCR’s guidance changed with the HSTPA. Revised Fact Sheet 40 defines a preferential rent as “a rent which an owner agrees to charge that is lower than the legal regulated rent” and does not address concessions at all. The court rejected the owner’s argument that the change in guidance was unexplained or arbitrary, and it affirmed summary judgment for the tenant class on overcharge claims arising from concessions offered after June 14, 2019, with related declaratory and injunctive relief.
In affirming the denial of the owner’s motion to renew, the court also held that proposed legislation on net-effective rents, which was never enacted, was not a change in the law, noting that legislative inactivity is inherently ambiguous.
Concessions before June 14, 2019
The court reached the opposite result for concessions offered before the HSTPA. Those concessions were tied to specific months, and under DHCR’s guidance at the time, they did not affect the legal regulated rent. The court therefore held that the tenants were not entitled to summary judgment on those claims.
The line between the two periods matters. A building with concessions on both sides of June 14, 2019 may face different outcomes for different tenants, and pre-HSTPA claims also raise separate questions about how far back the rent history can be examined.
Early occupancy licenses are void
The owner had given incoming tenants an early occupancy license, with a rent concession, to occupy the apartment before the lease began. Each license stated that the occupancy was exempt from the Rent Stabilization Law. The court held that this was a waiver of rent stabilization protections, and that an agreement waiving a benefit of the rent stabilization laws is void as against public policy. That the license benefited the tenant did not save the waiver.
Because the licenses were void, neither side could rely on them, but they could still support a finding of overcharge. The court also held that some class members received renewal leases at unauthorized intervals under the void licenses, rather than at the statutory one- or two-year terms. The court directed that the leases be extended to proper one- or two-year terms.
The rent freeze
Rent Stabilization Law § 26-517(e) bars an owner that has not filed a proper and timely registration from collecting rent above the legal regulated rent in effect on the date of the last preceding registration statement, until a proper registration is filed. The court applied it here.
For any class member who received a renewal lease, before or after the HSTPA, at an unauthorized interval because of the early occupancy licenses, the court vacated the increases taken at those intervals and froze the rent until proper registrations are filed. The freeze in Grey rests on the license agreements, not on the concessions alone, and owners should not assume that every concession error triggers the same remedy.
What the court left open
- How the renewal rent is calculated when a concession was spread over the lease or concentrated in particular months. The decision does not set out a formula.
- Whether a concession must be carried into each renewal as a term of the tenancy, an issue commentators expect to be litigated.
- The measure of damages for the class, which the decision does not compute.
- Further review. As of November 13, 2026, we have not located a reported decision on any motion for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeals.
The decision also notes the rule that, in a building receiving 421-a benefits, the initial legal regulated rent is the initial adjusted monthly rent charged and paid, but no more than the rent approved by HPD. Concessions offered at initial lease-up may therefore affect the rent from which every later increase is measured.
What owners and tenants should do now
Owners
- Inventory every post-June 14, 2019 concession, free month, and net-effective deal in stabilized units, including 421-a and 485-x affordable units.
- Stop using license, occupancy, or side agreements that purport to place any period of occupancy outside rent stabilization.
- Check that each renewal was offered at a proper one- or two-year interval measured from the actual start of occupancy.
- Reconcile DHCR registrations with the rent actually charged and paid, and correct them. A rent freeze lasts until proper registrations are filed.
- Assess exposure before a dispute: for claims governed by the HSTPA, recovery generally reaches the six years before the complaint, older rent history may be examined to set the legal rent, treble damages apply unless the owner proves the overcharge was not willful, and attorney’s fees are awarded against an owner found to have overcharged.
- Buyers of new-construction rentals should add concessions, licenses, and registration accuracy to diligence and to seller representations.
Tenants
- Gather your lease, renewals, any license or occupancy agreement, and records of what you actually paid.
- Request your rent history from DHCR and compare the registered rent with the rent you were charged.
- Note when you first moved in. Renewal intervals are measured from the start of occupancy.
We represent owners and tenants in rent overcharge litigation, DHCR proceedings, and the review of leasing practices and registrations for rent-stabilized buildings.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.