Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Is the NYC rent freeze in effect?

Yes. Rent Guidelines Board Order #58 sets 0% for one- and two-year rent-stabilized leases beginning October 1, 2026 through September 30, 2027. Landlords have challenged it in Kenilworth Holdings v. Rent Guidelines Board, now in Supreme Court, New York County, but as of November 13, 2026 we are not aware of a decision on the merits. Owners should keep offering timely renewals at the frozen rate.

What Order #58 provides

Each year the Rent Guidelines Board sets the maximum increases for rent-stabilized renewal leases. On June 25, 2026, it adopted Apartment and Loft Order #58, which applies to leases commencing on or after October 1, 2026 and on or before September 30, 2027.

One-year renewal leases0%
Two-year renewal leases0%
Loft units (Article 7-C)0% above base rent for one- and two-year periods
Rent-controlled units vacated after September 30, 2026Special guideline of 49% above the maximum base rent
Units decontrolled after September 30, 202649% above the maximum base rent

The order keeps the usual technical rules. A lease of up to one year is treated as a one-year lease, and a lease of more than one year and up to two years is treated as a two-year lease. Increases under an escalator clause that has not been deleted in writing are offset against the guideline increase, and adjustments lawfully added to the base rent under earlier orders remain part of the rent.

What matters is the commencement date of the renewal lease, not the date it is offered or signed. A renewal that begins on or after October 1, 2026 is governed by Order #58. A renewal that began before that date is governed by the prior order, which allowed 3% for one-year and 4.5% for two-year leases.

The Kenilworth Holdings challenge

On July 22, 2026, a group of owners led by Kenilworth Holdings LLC brought an Article 78 proceeding and declaratory judgment action against the Rent Guidelines Board in Supreme Court, Richmond County, under Index No. 85199/2026. The petitioners argue that the freeze was arbitrary and capricious and that the outcome was decided in advance, pointing among other things to a Board member’s resignation on the morning of the vote. The Board contends that the order was lawful and rational and that review is limited to the administrative record.

On August 21, 2026, the Richmond County court transferred the case to New York County, reasoning that the Board deliberated and voted in Manhattan. The case now carries New York County Index No. 453580/2026. Some news reports still describe it as a Staten Island case; it is not.

On September 16, 2026, the court granted the owners’ request for limited expedited discovery of communications between the Mayor’s Office and the Board, to test whether City Hall improperly influenced the Board’s process. Discovery of this kind is unusual in an Article 78 proceeding. The court reserved decision on the merits and on the Board’s cross-motion to dismiss. According to news reports of a September 24, 2026 hearing, the court also declined the owners’ request to restore the prior year’s 3% and 4.5% increases while the case is pending, indicating that it did not believe it had authority to do so, and the freeze took effect on October 1, 2026.

As of November 13, 2026, we are not aware of a decision on the merits, and the freeze is in effect for renewals beginning on or after October 1, 2026. The court has reportedly indicated that it expects to rule before the end of the year. We will update this article when it does.

How a ruling could change things

  • If the court upholds the order, the freeze stays in place through September 30, 2027, subject to any appeal by the owners.
  • If the court annuls the order, the usual remedy in an Article 78 proceeding is to send the matter back to the agency rather than to set rents itself. The Board would then have to act again, and the question of what happens to leases that began in the meantime would follow.
  • Whether any later increase could apply retroactively to renewals already in effect is unsettled. Some practitioners expect that it could; others expect that signed renewals would stand. No court has decided the point in this case.
  • If the City appeals an adverse ruling, CPLR 5519(a)(1) generally provides an automatic stay when a governmental party appeals, which could keep the freeze in place during the appeal. The Appellate Division can vacate or limit that stay, and how it applies would depend on the form of the ruling.
  • An appeal by either side to the Appellate Division, First Department, would likely take months.

What owners should do now

  • Keep sending renewal offers on time. Rent stabilization rules generally require the offer no more than 150 and no less than 90 days before the current lease expires, on the required renewal form.
  • Offer the renewal at the rates Order #58 allows for the lease’s commencement date. An offer that charges more than the lawful rent invites an overcharge claim.
  • Do not hold back renewal offers to wait for the court. A late offer does not change which order applies and can extend the existing lease and create disputes.
  • Be careful with “reopener” riders that would raise the rent if the freeze is struck down. Renewals generally must be at the lawful rent and otherwise on the same terms and conditions as the expiring lease, and we are not aware of DHCR guidance or a court decision approving such a rider. Treat it as a risk decision, not a solution.
  • Keep records of every offer, the date it was sent, and the tenant’s response. Accurate records matter more than usual while the outcome is uncertain.
  • Revisit underwriting, budgets, and loan covenants on the assumption that the freeze holds for this guideline year, and treat any later increase as upside.

Preferential rents, MCIs, and IAIs

For tenants who were paying a preferential rent on or after June 14, 2019, renewal increases are generally calculated on the preferential rent actually charged, not the higher legal regulated rent. With a 0% guideline, those tenants’ rents generally stay where they are on renewal, and the legal regulated rent on file also does not increase from the guideline.

Major capital improvement (MCI) increases and individual apartment improvement (IAI) increases are not guideline increases. They depend on DHCR approval or on the statutory rules for apartment improvements, including written tenant consent for an IAI in an occupied unit, and they are subject to their own caps. Order #58 does not set or eliminate them. An owner relying on one should state its basis clearly in the renewal and be sure the underlying approval or documentation is in order.

What tenants should know

  • If your renewal lease begins on or after October 1, 2026, the guideline increase is 0% for either a one-year or a two-year term.
  • You generally have 60 days from the date of the owner’s renewal offer to choose a term, sign, and return it.
  • An owner may still add an increase that is lawfully authorized outside the guidelines, such as an approved MCI. Ask for the basis in writing if you are unsure.
  • If the court later changes the outcome, guidance on existing leases is likely to follow. Keep a copy of your signed renewal and your rent records.

Good Cause Eviction does not apply to rent-stabilized apartments, so its separate limit on rent increases is not part of this analysis. We represent owners and investors in rent-stabilized buildings in renewal practice, overcharge matters, DHCR proceedings, and the litigation that follows when rent rules change.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.