Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

How do ground leases of public land work in New York?

City and State agencies and authorities often lease land instead of selling it, keeping ownership while requiring development. A New York City lease generally needs mayoral approval, a recent appraisal, a public hearing, and land use review under ULURP. State authorities follow their own statutes and the Public Authorities Law. These leases commonly carry PILOTs, affordability or use requirements, and labor conditions, so developers should plan for long approval periods.

Why governments ground lease their land

A public owner that sells land gives up control once the deed is delivered. A ground lease lets the City or a State authority keep title, require a particular development, collect rent or PILOTs, enforce affordability or public-access commitments for decades, and recover the land at the end. That is why much of Battery Park City, many waterfront sites, and many City development sites are leased rather than sold.

A recent example shows the typical structure. In November 2025, the NYCEDC board considered a 99-year City lease of a Willets Point site, approved by the Queens Borough Board under Charter § 384(b)(4), to the New York City Land Development Corporation for assignment to the developer. According to the board materials, base rent is $1 a year while the housing rents are regulated, rent resets to an appraised fair market value when the regulatory period ends and every 25 years after that, and the tenant pays PILOTs.

City land: Charter § 384

ApprovalNo City real property may be sold, leased, exchanged, or otherwise disposed of without the Mayor’s approval (§ 384(a)).
PriceLeases generally go at public auction or by sealed bid, for the highest marketable price or rental (§ 384(b)(1)).
Public hearingRequired before a lease is authorized (§ 384(b)(1)).
Maximum termNo lease may run longer than 99 years (§ 384(b)(1)).
AppraisalRequired within six months before authorization (§ 384(b)(2)).
Local development corporationsThe Mayor may lease to a local development corporation without competitive bidding, with approval of a majority of the borough board (§ 384(b)(4)).
Land use reviewLeases other than office space are subject to ULURP, limited to land use impact (§ 384(b)(5)).

Waterfront property, airports, and certain other property are also governed by § 1301 of the Charter, which requires ULURP review and a public hearing on 30 days’ notice for many waterfront leases, and City Council approval for certain leases for waterfront commerce or navigation. The particular route depends on the property and the agency that controls it.

ULURP and the approvals around it

Charter § 197-c(a)(10) lists the sale, lease (other than of office space), exchange, or other disposition of City real property among the actions that require the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure. Once an application is certified, the community board has 60 days to hold a hearing and make its recommendation, the borough president has 30 days after that, and the City Planning Commission has 60 days after the borough president’s time expires. The City Council’s role depends on the action and is set out in § 197-d. A community board may waive its hearing on a lease that does not involve a substantial land use interest, and the Commission may waive a hearing on a lease application.

  • Pre-certification work with the Department of City Planning and the sponsoring agency, which often takes longer than the formal review.
  • Environmental review under CEQR and SEQRA.
  • Companion zoning actions, which are reviewed alongside the disposition.
  • Agency board approvals, such as the NYCEDC board, and mayoral authorization before the lease is signed.

We help developers plan the sequence. See our zoning and land use practice for the land use side.

NYCEDC and HPD as lessors

NYCEDC typically selects developers through a request for proposals and administers the lease. Many leases run from the City to a local development corporation, such as the New York City Land Development Corporation, under Charter § 384(b)(4), and then to the developer by assignment or sublease. The developer negotiates with the agency, but the form of lease, the rent, and the use commitments reflect City policy and the approvals already given.

The Department of Housing Preservation and Development disposes of City land for affordable housing. Its dispositions commonly involve an urban development action area designation and project approval under Article 16 of the General Municipal Law, together with a disposition reviewed under Charter § 197-c or, for eligible affordable housing dispositions since the 2025 Charter amendments, under the expedited procedure in Charter § 197-e. Some HPD dispositions are conveyances of the fee, and others use long-term ground leases. Either way, a regulatory agreement typically governs rents and incomes. See our affordable housing practice.

State land and public authorities

State authorities that own or control land lease it under their enabling statutes and the Public Authorities Law. Under § 2897 of that law, an authority that negotiates a disposal, rather than bidding it, must submit an explanatory statement, including to the Authorities Budget Office, at least 90 days before the transaction. According to the ABO’s guidance, leases are covered where the estimated annual rent exceeds $15,000.

  • Empire State Development carries out projects under the Urban Development Corporation Act through general project plans, with environmental review and, in some cases, Public Authorities Control Board approval. In its proposed Gowanus plan, ESD would take title to the sites for a nominal amount and net ground lease them back to the developers, so that PILOTs replace City real estate taxes for a 35-year post-construction period. That plan states that it does not override local law, so City zoning still applies.
  • The Battery Park City Authority owns the land of Battery Park City and leases it to the buildings there. In December 2025, it extended the Brookfield Place ground lease from 2069 to 2119.
  • The Hudson River Park Trust leases commercial facilities in the park under the Hudson River Park Act, which limits lease terms, with longer terms allowed for specified piers. Confirm the current statute for the particular pier.

PILOTs and real estate taxes

Land owned by the City or a State authority is generally exempt from real estate taxes. Public ground leases therefore commonly require the tenant to make payments in lieu of taxes, either set by formula or tied to what taxes would otherwise be. In Battery Park City, residents pay PILOTs to the Authority, and in ESD projects a PILOT agreement can replace City taxes for a defined period.

PILOTs are often the largest operating cost after debt service, and lenders underwrite them like taxes. The developer should know how the PILOT is calculated, whether it phases in, what happens when it ends, and whether any tax incentive programs apply in addition. See our real estate tax incentives practice.

Affordability, prevailing wage, and other conditions

Public leases usually carry conditions that a private landowner would not impose. Housing sites commonly require income-restricted units under a regulatory agreement. Leases may also include public-access, community facility, and local hiring commitments, and remedies if they are not met.

Labor costs can change as well. New York Labor Law § 224-a requires prevailing wage on private construction projects that meet a statutory cost threshold and receive public funds equal to at least 30% of construction costs. The statute counts savings from below-market rents and other reduced costs as public funds, so a discounted ground lease can help bring a project within the law. The statute contains exclusions, including for certain affordable housing projects. Whether a project is covered should be analyzed before the rent is agreed.

What developers should plan for

  • A timeline measured in years, from RFP designation through ULURP, environmental review, and board approvals, before the lease is signed.
  • Rent that starts low but resets, often by appraisal on a fixed cycle. See our article on rent resets.
  • Financing terms that a public lessor may limit more than a private one, including lender cure periods and new-lease rights. See leasehold financing.
  • Transfer restrictions and agency consent before completion or stabilization.
  • Construction milestones, completion guaranties, and recapture rights if the project stalls.
  • Transfer tax analysis at signing and on any later assignment. See ground lease transfer taxes.
  • End-of-term reversion of the land and improvements to the public owner.
  • For residential projects, the effect of the lease on future buyers. See our article on buying an apartment on a ground lease.

Landowners weighing whether to lease or sell their own land face many of the same trade-offs, discussed in our article on ground leasing instead of selling. We represent developers and institutions in public-private ground leases and the approvals that come with them.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.