Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

What makes a New York ground lease financeable?

A leasehold lender’s collateral is the ground lease itself, so the lease must protect it. Lenders generally require a term that runs well past the loan, notice of defaults and extra time to cure, the right to foreclose and transfer the leasehold, a new-lease right if the lease ends, no amendment or surrender without consent, priority over any fee mortgage, estoppel certificates on request, and a recorded memorandum of lease.

Why the ground lease is the lender’s collateral

In a typical unsubordinated ground lease, the landowner keeps the land free of the tenant’s debt. The tenant borrows against its leasehold estate — its right to occupy the land and own the improvements for the term — and the lender takes a leasehold mortgage. If the tenant defaults under the ground lease and the landowner terminates it, the leasehold, and with it the lender’s security, disappears.

That is why lenders read the ground lease as closely as the loan documents. A lease that lacks standard lender protections may be unfinanceable or financeable only on worse terms. Lenders that finance leasehold condominiums and co-ops look at the same issues; for buyers, see our article on buying an apartment on a ground lease in New York City.

Term versus loan

Lenders generally want the remaining term of the ground lease, including renewal options the tenant controls, to run well past the loan’s maturity. The margin a lender requires depends on the loan, the asset, and the lender’s own guidelines. A short remaining term can make refinancing difficult late in the lease, which in turn affects the value of the leasehold to a buyer.

Rent matters as well. A lender underwrites the project’s ability to pay ground rent through the loan term, so open-ended appraisal resets can be a financing issue as much as an economic one. See our article on ground lease rent resets in New York.

Leasehold mortgagee protections

The lender protections in a well-drafted ground lease usually include:

  • Permission to mortgage. An express right to mortgage the leasehold, often including refinancings and, in some leases, mezzanine financing secured by interests in the tenant.
  • Notice. The landowner must send the lender a copy of any default notice, and a notice to the tenant is not effective against the lender until the lender receives it.
  • Cure. Additional time for the lender to cure after the tenant’s cure period ends, with longer periods for non-monetary defaults and time to foreclose where a default can only be cured by the party in possession.
  • No termination while the lender is curing. The landowner agrees not to terminate while the lender is diligently pursuing a cure or foreclosure.
  • Foreclosure and transfer. The right to foreclose, take the leasehold or have a designee take it, and transfer it afterward with limited or no landowner consent.
  • No amendment, cancellation, or surrender. The lease cannot be amended, cancelled, or voluntarily surrendered without the lender’s consent, and the fee and leasehold do not merge if one party acquires both.
  • Proceeds. Casualty insurance and condemnation proceeds are applied to restoration or the debt on terms the lender can accept.

Landowners often negotiate limits on these rights: qualified lender definitions, outside dates for curing, an obligation to cure monetary defaults promptly, and conditions on transfers after foreclosure.

The new-lease right

A new-lease right obliges the landowner, if the ground lease is terminated for any reason — including a default that cannot be cured or rejection of the lease in a bankruptcy — to enter into a new lease with the lender or its designee on the same terms, for the remainder of the term and with the same priority. Lenders generally treat it as essential, because it addresses risks that notice and cure rights cannot.

Landowners usually condition the right on a timely request, payment of all rent and costs then due, and cure of curable defaults. The lease should also say what happens to subleases and to the improvements between termination and the new lease.

Fee mortgages, priority, and SNDAs

A landowner may mortgage the land while it is ground leased. The question for the leasehold lender is priority. If a fee mortgage is recorded ahead of the ground lease and is foreclosed, the ground lease may be at risk, along with the leasehold mortgage. Lenders therefore ask either that any fee mortgage be expressly subordinate to the ground lease or that the fee lender sign a subordination, non-disturbance, and attornment agreement (SNDA) protecting the tenant and its lender.

A subordinated ground lease is different. There the landowner agrees to subordinate the fee to the tenant’s mortgage, so a foreclosure of the leasehold loan can reach the land. Landowners who agree to subordinate usually do so for better economics, and the decision deserves careful review.

Estoppel certificates and recording the lease

Over a long term, the leasehold will be financed and refinanced repeatedly, and every lender and buyer will ask the landowner to confirm the lease’s status. Ground leases should require each party to deliver an estoppel certificate within a fixed time after request, confirming that the lease is in effect, the rent, and whether any defaults are known. Because the signing party can generally be held to its statements, both sides should review them carefully.

Under Real Property Law § 290(3), a lease for more than three years is a “conveyance,” and under § 291 an unrecorded conveyance is void as against a later good-faith purchaser for value whose conveyance is first recorded. Rather than record the full lease, parties usually record a memorandum of lease under § 291-c, which has like effect. The memorandum must identify the parties, refer to the lease and its date, describe the premises, state the term and its commencement and termination dates, and describe any renewal or extension rights, and it must be signed and acknowledged by all parties.

Defaults and Yellowstone injunctions

When a commercial landlord serves a notice to cure, the tenant’s cure period can run out while the parties dispute whether there is a default at all. New York courts developed the Yellowstone injunction, named for First National Stores v. Yellowstone Shopping Center, 21 N.Y.2d 630 (1968), to toll the cure period while the dispute is decided. In Graubard Mollen Horowitz Pomeranz & Shapiro v. 600 Third Avenue Associates, 93 N.Y.2d 508 (1999), the Court of Appeals recited the elements: the tenant holds a commercial lease, received a notice of default, notice to cure, or threat of termination, requested relief before the lease was terminated, and is prepared and able to cure by any means short of vacating.

In 159 MP Corp. v. Redbridge Bedford, LLC, 33 N.Y.3d 353 (2019), the Court of Appeals enforced a commercial lease clause waiving the tenant’s right to bring a declaratory judgment action. The Legislature responded with Real Property Law § 235-h, which addresses such waivers; at least one trial court has held that it does not apply retroactively. For a ground tenant and its lender, the timing of cure periods, lender notice, and Yellowstone relief should be planned together. See our Yellowstone injunctions page.

Bankruptcy of the tenant or the landowner

If the ground tenant files for bankruptcy, 11 U.S.C. § 365 governs the lease. Until the lease is assumed or rejected, § 365(d)(3) requires the debtor to timely perform its obligations arising after the order for relief under a nonresidential real property lease. Under § 365(d)(4), a nonresidential lease not assumed within 120 days after the order for relief, or by plan confirmation if earlier, is deemed rejected and the property must be surrendered; the court may extend the period once by 90 days for cause, and further extensions need the landlord’s written consent. If the lease is rejected, a lender’s new-lease right becomes critical.

If the landowner files, § 365(h) protects the tenant. If the debtor-landlord rejects the lease, the tenant may treat the lease as terminated, where the rejection would entitle it to do so under the lease or applicable law, or, if the term has begun, retain its rights for the balance of the term and any renewal or extension, to the extent enforceable under nonbankruptcy law. A tenant that stays may offset damages from the landlord’s nonperformance against rent. Lenders often require the lease to provide that the tenant cannot elect to treat the lease as terminated without the lender’s consent.

Financing also carries tax costs. Leasehold mortgages are generally subject to New York’s mortgage recording tax; see our article on ground lease transfer taxes in New York.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.