Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

How are ground lease rent resets decided in New York?

By the lease. Long ground leases adjust rent through fixed escalations, inflation indexing, periodic appraisal resets to a percentage of land value, or a mix. In an appraisal reset, the valuation instructions usually matter most. New York’s Court of Appeals has held that, absent an agreement to the contrary, the effect of the lease must be considered in valuing the property, so parties who intend an unencumbered valuation must say so.

Why ground rent has to adjust

A ground lease commonly runs for 49 to 99 years. Rent that made sense when the lease was signed can be far too low or far too high decades later. Ground leases are also generally net, with the tenant paying taxes, insurance, and operating costs, so the ground rent is the landowner’s return on the land itself.

Rent adjustment provisions are where landowners protect that return and where tenants and their lenders look for predictability. A tenant’s lender underwrites the project’s ability to pay ground rent for the life of the loan, so an open-ended reset can affect financeability as well as economics. For the lender’s side of that analysis, see our article on leasehold financing on New York ground leases.

Fixed escalations, CPI, and appraisal resets

Fixed escalationsScheduled increases, such as a set percentage every five years. Predictable and easy to underwrite, but over decades they can drift far from actual land value in either direction.
CPI adjustmentsRent adjusted by an inflation index, often with a floor and a cap. Tracks general prices, not the value of the particular site, and requires a fallback if the index changes or is discontinued.
Appraisal resetsRent reset at set intervals, often many years apart, to a stated percentage of appraised value. Tracks the land, but introduces valuation risk and the cost of the appraisal process.
HybridFixed or CPI increases between periodic appraisal resets, often with a no-decrease clause, a cap on any single reset, or a phase-in of large increases.

None of these is inherently landlord- or tenant-friendly. A fixed schedule protects a tenant against a surge in land values and protects a landowner against a decline. An appraisal reset shares that risk, and the terms of the appraisal decide how it is shared.

Valuation assumptions that drive the result

In an appraisal reset, the lease tells the appraisers what to value. Small changes in those instructions can produce very different numbers. The points that most often matter are:

  • Land only or land and buildings. Some leases value the land alone; others value the “demised premises,” which can include the improvements.
  • Vacant or encumbered. Valuing the land as if vacant and free of the lease usually produces a higher figure than valuing it subject to a long lease at below-market rent with use restrictions.
  • Highest and best use or permitted use. If the lease restricts use, an instruction to value at highest and best use can assume a use the tenant is not allowed to make. An instruction to value at the permitted use ties the value to the lease.
  • Zoning and development rights. Whether the appraisers consider the zoning in effect on the valuation date, the floor area actually built, or unused development rights.
  • The valuation date. The date on which value is measured, and whether later events can be considered.
  • The rate. The percentage of value that becomes the new rent. A rate fixed decades in advance may not reflect returns at the time of the reset.

Ambiguity is expensive. Where the lease does not answer one of these questions, the parties may disagree before the appraisers even begin, and the dispute can end up in court.

How appraisal procedures usually work

Most reset clauses follow a familiar pattern, though the details vary from lease to lease:

  • the parties try to agree on value within a set period before the reset date;
  • if they cannot, each appoints a qualified appraiser, often with minimum experience requirements for the property type and market;
  • if the two appraisals differ by more than a set amount, the appraisers or the parties select a third appraiser;
  • the third appraiser either determines value independently, chooses the figure closest to its own, or must pick one of the two submitted figures (sometimes called baseball-style); and
  • the lease allocates the appraisers’ fees and says what rent is paid while the process is pending, usually with a true-up afterward.

The procedure should also say what happens if a party fails to appoint an appraiser on time, whether the appraisers may hear from the parties, and whether the result is final. A clear procedure reduces the room for a procedural fight layered on top of the valuation dispute.

How New York courts approach reset disputes

New York courts start with the text of the lease. The key Court of Appeals decision is 936 Second Ave. L.P. v. Second Corporate Development Co., 10 N.Y.3d 628 (2008). The lease there reset rent for a renewal term at 7% of the value of the demised premises, including the buildings, determined by appraisers. The landowner’s appraiser ignored the net lease and valued the property at $7.1 million; the tenant’s appraiser considered the lease and arrived at $3.43 million. The lease excluded certain damage and destruction from consideration but was silent about the lease itself.

The Court held that, “absent an agreement to the contrary, the effect of a net lease must be considered in valuing property,” relying on the long-standing rule, stated in Plaza Hotel Assoc. v. Wellington Assoc., 55 Misc. 2d 483 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. County 1967), aff’d, 22 N.Y.2d 846 (1968), that valuations of land must take into consideration all encumbrances, including restrictions on use, unless there is a clear provision to the contrary. It added that parties who want the lease excluded “need only include language to that effect in their agreement.”

The Court distinguished New York Overnight Partners v. Gordon, 88 N.Y.2d 716 (1996), in which the lease defined the land to exclude the buildings and improvements. There, the Court affirmed an order directing the appraiser to value the land as if vacant and unimproved while also considering the effect of the lease on the value of the land.

The practical lesson is that New York courts will not supply an unencumbered valuation the lease does not clearly require. A landowner who intends the land to be appraised as vacant and free of the lease must say so, and a tenant who intends the lease and its use restrictions to be considered should say that too, rather than relying on a default rule.

Drafting points for landowners

  • State expressly whether the land is valued as vacant and unencumbered by the lease, and at its highest and best use, if that is the intended basis.
  • Add a no-decrease clause so a reset cannot reduce rent below the rent then in effect, if the economics support it.
  • Consider interim fixed or CPI increases between resets, so rent does not stay flat for decades.
  • Set appraiser qualifications and a firm timetable, with a remedy if the tenant fails to appoint.
  • Coordinate the reset with participation rent, purchase option pricing, and any leasehold condominium structure, so the formulas do not conflict.

Drafting points for tenants and their lenders

  • Require the appraisers to consider the lease, its remaining term, and its use restrictions, or to value at the permitted use rather than a hypothetical highest and best use.
  • Negotiate a cap on any single reset, a phase-in of large increases, or a collar around a fixed schedule.
  • Give the leasehold lender notice of the reset process and, where appropriate, the right to participate.
  • Make sure the rent during a pending appraisal is defined and that a delay in the process cannot trigger a default.
  • Model the reset under several land-value scenarios and confirm the project can carry the highest plausible rent through the loan term.

Taxes and related issues

Rent provisions also affect taxes. For New York State transfer tax purposes, the consideration for a qualifying long-term lease is measured by the present value of the rent, so the rent schedule is part of the tax calculation. See our article on ground lease transfer taxes in New York. Landowners weighing a ground lease against an outright sale may also find our article on selling versus ground leasing useful.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.