Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Should a New York landowner ground lease instead of selling?

A ground lease lets an owner keep the land, collect rent for decades, and recover the land, and usually the building, when the lease ends, instead of taking a lump sum now. The trade-offs are long-term exposure to the tenant and to rent that may lag the land’s value, less control, and a more complex estate. The tax results differ from a sale and should be modeled with tax advisers first.

Why some owners lease instead of sell

Families, estates, religious institutions, and other long-term holders often own land that a developer wants. A sale ends the relationship. A ground lease lets the owner keep title, collect rent, and leave the land to the next generation, while the developer finances and builds on it and owns the building for the term.

Developers accept ground leases because they reduce the capital needed up front: the developer pays rent instead of a purchase price. That means a landowner who insists on a ground lease is asking the developer to accept rent, resets, and an eventual reversion, and the price of that request shows up in the rent and the other terms. Our ground lease practice page outlines how the structure works for both sides. Public owners, such as the City and State authorities, lease land under their own statutes, described in our article on ground leases of public land.

Income versus a lump sum

A sale produces cash at closing. A ground lease produces rent, usually on an absolute net basis, with the tenant paying taxes, insurance, and operating costs. The comparison is not just the total dollars. It is the present value of the rent, the risk that the tenant stops paying, and what the family would do with sale proceeds.

  • Fixed escalations give predictability but can fall behind land values over decades.
  • Rent resets to a percentage of appraised land value can keep rent current, but they invite disputes over valuation assumptions. See our article on ground lease rent resets.
  • A family that needs liquidity, or whose members disagree about holding, may be better served by a sale, or by a lease that permits a later sale of the fee subject to the lease.
  • Rent and sale proceeds are generally taxed differently, and the timing of tax differs as well. Those effects should be modeled with the family’s accountant before the decision is made.

The reversion

When the lease ends, the land and the improvements generally revert to the owner, unless the lease provides otherwise. On a 99-year lease that may be several generations away, so its present value is modest. As the term runs down, the reversion becomes more valuable, and the tenant’s incentive to invest in the building falls.

Owners should address end-of-term behavior in the lease itself: maintenance and capital repair standards that continue to the last day, reserve or inspection rights in the final years, the condition in which the building must be surrendered, and whether the tenant may or must demolish. Late-term extension requests are common, and the lease can set the framework for them. If the building will be residential, the remaining term also matters to apartment buyers and their lenders, as our article on buying an apartment on a ground lease explains.

Estate planning and the step-up in basis

Keeping the land can matter for estate planning. Under the federal income tax rules, property acquired from a decedent generally takes a basis equal to its fair market value at death, which can reduce gain on a later sale by the heirs. Land subject to a long ground lease is valued with the lease in place, so the rent and term affect the value reported for estate tax and the basis the heirs receive. These are general rules with exceptions, and the family’s tax advisers should confirm how they apply.

A lease that runs for decades also outlives the people who sign it. Many families hold the fee in an LLC or trust so that decisions about consents, estoppels, resets, and extensions can be made by a manager or trustee rather than by a growing number of co-owners. We coordinate the ground lease with the owner’s estate plan. For heirs who already hold property, see our guide to inheriting New York City real estate.

Section 1031 and long leaseholds

Since 2018, Section 1031 exchanges have been limited to real property. Treasury Regulation § 1.1031(a)-1(c) gives, as an example of a like-kind exchange, a leasehold of a fee with 30 years or more to run exchanged for real estate. The IRS has applied that example in later rulings.

Signing a ground lease is generally not itself an exchange, because the owner keeps the land. The rule matters when an owner sells other property and wants to acquire a long leasehold as replacement property, or when an owner considers exchanging property for a leasehold rather than a fee. How renewal options count toward the 30 years, and how a particular lease is characterized, are questions for tax advisers. The exchange deadlines are summarized in our article on 1031 exchange timelines.

The risks of leasing

  • Tenant default. If the tenant stops paying, the owner’s remedies are usually subject to the leasehold lender’s notice, cure, and new-lease rights, so recovering the land can take time.
  • Rent erosion. Rent that is fixed or capped can fall far below market over a long term, and a reset formula drafted loosely can be litigated for years.
  • A stalled project. If the tenant does not finish construction, the owner may be left with a partially built site and a lender in the way.
  • Loss of control. For the term, the tenant decides how the property is used and managed within the limits of the lease.
  • Complexity at the end. Casualty, condemnation, environmental conditions, and late-term disputes all fall back on the owner if the lease does not address them.
  • Transfer taxes. A very long lease can be taxed as if it were a sale, as discussed below.

These risks can be priced and managed. They are the reason a ground lease takes longer to negotiate than most sales. On the lender side of the table, see our article on leasehold financing.

Protections landowners should negotiate

  • A rent formula with clear escalations, reset dates, and valuation instructions for the appraisers.
  • A security deposit, letter of credit, or guaranty, at least until construction is complete and the building is stabilized.
  • Construction start and completion deadlines, with remedies if the project stalls.
  • An unsubordinated fee, so the land is not pledged for the tenant’s loan, unless the owner chooses otherwise for a price.
  • Lender protections that are limited in time and scope, with monetary defaults cured promptly.
  • Use, maintenance, insurance, and rebuilding obligations that run for the full term.
  • Limits on transfers before completion, and standards for later assignees.
  • Estoppel, reporting, and audit rights.
  • End-of-term condition, surrender, and removal obligations.
  • Care with purchase options and rights of first refusal, which can depress the value of the fee.

We represent landowners in ground leases, and we work with the owner’s appraisers and accountants on rent and tax questions.

Transfer taxes: the 49-year line

New York State’s real estate transfer tax treats the creation of a lease as a conveyance only where the sum of the term and any renewal options exceeds 49 years, substantial capital improvements are or may be made for the tenant, and the lease covers substantially all of the premises (Tax Law § 1401(e)); the regulations define “substantially all” as 90% or more of the rentable space. New York City’s real property transfer tax has no 49-year test. It treats the grant of a leasehold as a transfer, but under the City’s rules a grant solely for rent, as defined for Commercial Rent Tax purposes, is not taxed, while a premium or other payment for the lease can be.

The result is that a long ground lease can carry transfer tax at signing, sometimes computed on the value of the rent stream. The structure of the term and options, and who bears the tax, should be settled before the term sheet is signed. Our article on ground lease transfer taxes explains how the State and City taxes apply.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.