Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Can an irrevocable trust be changed in New York?

Sometimes. The main routes are a consent amendment, in which the grantor revokes or amends a lifetime trust with the written, acknowledged consent of everyone beneficially interested under EPTL § 7-1.9; decanting by an authorized trustee under EPTL § 10-6.6; a court proceeding to construe or, in limited cases, reform the trust; and changing trustees. New York has no general nonjudicial settlement statute as of this writing.

Why trusts need changing

Irrevocable trusts are built to last, which is the problem. A trust drafted twenty years ago may name a trustee who has died or moved away, require distributions at an age that no longer makes sense, lack powers to manage real estate or a family business, or fail to protect a beneficiary who now receives public benefits. Tax law changes too: the federal basic exclusion of $15,000,000 per person for 2026 means some trusts designed to save federal estate tax now matter more for income tax, creditor protection, or control. Before choosing a route, identify exactly what needs to change and whether the change is administrative, such as trustee succession or investment powers, or beneficial, such as who receives what and when.

Route 1: consent of the grantor and all beneficiaries

EPTL § 7-1.9 provides that when all persons beneficially interested in a trust consent in writing, the creator may revoke or amend all or part of it. The consents and the amending instrument must be acknowledged or proved in the manner required for recording a deed, and if the original trust was recorded, the revocation and consents must be recorded in the same counties.

  • The grantor must be living and able to act, so the statute does not help after the grantor’s death or for a trust created by will.
  • Every person beneficially interested must consent. Minors, unborn or unascertained beneficiaries, and incapacitated beneficiaries cannot simply sign, which can make the route unavailable without court involvement.
  • For trusts created on or after September 1, 1951, a gift to a class described only as the creator’s heirs, next of kin, or distributees does not create a beneficial interest in them, so their consent is not needed for that reason.
  • Revoking or amending a trust can have gift, estate, and Medicaid consequences, which should be reviewed first.

Route 2: decanting by the trustee

Under EPTL § 10-6.6, an authorized trustee, meaning a trustee other than the grantor and other than a current or possible beneficiary, may appoint principal to a new irrevocable trust. A trustee with unlimited discretion over principal has broad power to rewrite the beneficial terms; a trustee with limited discretion may change other terms but must keep the same beneficiaries and distribution standards. Decanting does not require the beneficiaries’ consent or court approval, but it does require a signed, acknowledged instrument served on the grantor if living, anyone with power to remove the trustee, and the interested persons, and it takes effect 30 days after service unless they all consent sooner.

Decanting cannot reduce a mandatory income, annuity, or unitrust right that has taken effect, except for an appointment to a qualifying supplemental needs trust, and the trustee generally may not decant against substantial evidence of the grantor’s contrary intent unless it can be shown that the grantor would likely have changed that intent. Our guide to decanting a trust in New York covers the statute and the 2025 decision in Matter of Chheda in detail.

Route 3: construction and reformation in court

When the problem is that the trust is unclear, a construction proceeding asks the court to decide what it means. For wills and testamentary trusts, SCPA § 1420 allows a fiduciary or interested person to petition the Surrogate’s Court, and a construction question raised in an accounting is treated the same way. For lifetime trusts, CPLR Article 77 allows a special proceeding in Supreme Court to determine any matter relating to an express trust. A construction decree binds the parties to the proceeding.

Reformation goes further: it changes the words to match what the creator intended. New York courts have reformed trusts in limited circumstances, such as to correct a clear drafting error or to carry out a creator’s evident tax objectives, but they generally require strong proof of the intended terms and do not rewrite a trust simply because the family would now prefer something different. Reformation is a court remedy, with notice to the interested parties, not a private agreement.

Route 4: changing the trustee

Many problems with an old trust are really problems with who is running it. The instrument may allow a trustee to resign, a beneficiary or trust protector to remove and replace the trustee, or a trustee to appoint a co-trustee or successor. Where the instrument is silent or the parties disagree, the court can accept a resignation, appoint a successor, or remove a trustee on statutory grounds; see our guide to removing an executor or trustee. A court will not, however, appoint a trustee where the appointment would contravene the express terms of the will or lifetime trust instrument, a rule the Surrogate’s Court applied under SCPA § 1502(2) in Matter of Chheda.

A new trustee, especially an independent one, can also make decanting possible where the current trustees are beneficiaries and therefore not authorized trustees, but only if the appointment is otherwise appropriate and consistent with the instrument.

What about a settlement agreement among the family?

Many states that adopted the Uniform Trust Code allow interested persons to resolve trust matters by a nonjudicial settlement agreement. As of this writing, New York has not enacted a general statute of that kind; proposals for a New York trust code have been introduced but not adopted. Family members can still agree on how they will exercise their own rights, release claims, or consent to a trustee’s accounting, and such agreements can be part of a court-approved settlement. But an agreement among beneficiaries does not, by itself, rewrite the trust’s terms or bind beneficiaries who did not sign it.

Choosing a route

Grantor living, all beneficiaries adult and willingConsent amendment under EPTL § 7-1.9
Independent trustee with discretion over principalDecanting under EPTL § 10-6.6
Ambiguous languageConstruction proceeding (SCPA § 1420 or CPLR Article 77)
Clear drafting mistakeReformation proceeding
Trustee problem, terms acceptableResignation, removal, or appointment of a successor under the instrument or by the court
Beneficiary now needs public benefitsDecanting to a supplemental needs trust, or a court proceeding

We represent grantors, trustees, and beneficiaries in each of these routes, including beneficiaries who object to a proposed change. Any change should be reviewed for tax, Medicaid, and creditor-protection consequences before it is made.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.