Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

How does decanting a trust work in New York?

Under EPTL § 10-6.6, an authorized trustee with discretion to distribute principal may appoint it to a new irrevocable trust with updated terms. The grantor and any trustee who is a current or possible beneficiary cannot decant. The trustee signs an acknowledged instrument and serves it on the grantor, anyone who can remove the trustee, and the interested beneficiaries. It takes effect 30 days later unless all consent sooner.

What decanting is and why it is used

The name comes from wine: the trustee pours the trust property out of the old vessel into a new one. Legally, decanting treats a trustee’s discretionary power to distribute principal as a power to distribute it in further trust. The old trust is the invaded trust, and the new one is the appointed trust. Common reasons to decant include:

  • modernizing administrative provisions, such as investment powers, trustee succession, and the ability to hold real estate or a closely held business;
  • adding or updating supplemental needs trust provisions for a beneficiary with a disability;
  • extending the term of a trust that would otherwise distribute outright to a beneficiary who is not ready;
  • fixing drafting problems without a court proceeding; and
  • moving administration or changing provisions that create unnecessary tax or administrative cost.

Decanting has become more relevant as older trusts meet new circumstances, including the federal basic exclusion of $15,000,000 per person for 2026, which has led many families to revisit trusts drafted under earlier tax assumptions.

Who can decant: the authorized trustee

Only an authorized trustee may decant. The statute defines the term as a trustee with authority to pay principal to one or more current beneficiaries, and it excludes the trust’s creator and any trustee who is a current or possible beneficiary of income or principal. A family member who serves as trustee and is also a beneficiary therefore cannot decant on their own. Where one trustee is disqualified, an independent co-trustee may hold the power, which is why independent trustees are often named in trusts expected to need flexibility.

The trust instrument matters too. A spendthrift clause or a general prohibition on amending or revoking the trust does not by itself prevent decanting, but a provision that expressly prohibits it does. And a trustee may not decant where there is substantial evidence that the creator would have opposed the change, unless it can be shown that the creator would likely have changed that intent in light of later circumstances.

Unlimited and limited discretion

Unlimited discretion (§ 10-6.6(b))The trustee may appoint principal to a new trust for one or more current beneficiaries, to the exclusion of others, may name successor and remainder beneficiaries from among the existing ones, and may grant a current beneficiary a power of appointment
Limited discretion (§ 10-6.6(c))The new trust must have the same current, successor, and remainder beneficiaries and the same distribution language, but may change other terms and may extend the trust’s term
BothNo current need to distribute principal is required, and the trustee must act in the best interests of the beneficiaries as a prudent person would

Unlimited discretion means a power over principal that is not limited by a standard. Language such as “best interests,” “welfare,” “comfort,” or “happiness” does not by itself limit it. A power limited to health, education, maintenance, and support is the classic example of limited discretion.

What a decanting cannot do

  • Reduce, limit, or modify a beneficiary’s current right to mandatory income or principal, an annuity, or a unitrust interest, or a withdrawal right, once it has taken effect. An appointment to a qualifying supplemental needs trust under EPTL § 7-1.12 is an exception to this rule.
  • Decrease or indemnify against a trustee’s liability, or exonerate a trustee, for failure to exercise reasonable care, diligence, and prudence.
  • Eliminate a person’s right to remove or replace the authorized trustee, unless a court directs otherwise.
  • Jeopardize specified tax benefits originally claimed for contributions to the trust, such as the annual gift tax exclusion, the marital deduction, or the charitable deduction.
  • Change the trustee’s compensation without a court’s direction. No trustee may take a commission for making the appointment.
  • Violate the rule against perpetuities and related limits; an appointment that does is void in its entirety.

Notice, timing, and filing

The trustee acts by a written instrument, signed, dated, and acknowledged, that states whether all or part of the principal is appointed and, if part, the approximate percentage. A copy must be served on the creator if living, anyone with the right to remove or replace the authorized trustee, and the persons interested in both the invaded and appointed trusts, or their guardians or other representatives. Service is by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested, by personal delivery, or as a court directs.

The decanting takes effect 30 days after service unless everyone entitled to notice consents in writing to an earlier date, and the trustee may revoke it before then. A person interested may serve a written objection before the effective date; the statute provides that failing to object is not consent. Court approval is not required, but the trustee may ask the court to approve the decanting, which is often prudent when the change is significant or a beneficiary objects. The original instrument is generally filed within 20 days after it takes effect with the court that has jurisdiction over the trust, although no filing is required for a lifetime trust that has never been the subject of a Surrogate’s Court proceeding.

Matter of Chheda: the limits in practice

In Matter of Chheda, decided by the Erie County Surrogate’s Court on August 20, 2025, a will created a trust that paid the surviving spouse income quarterly and allowed principal for her care, with the remainder to the children. Two of the children, who were co-trustees and also beneficiaries, petitioned under SCPA § 1502 to appoint an additional, non-beneficiary co-trustee so that the trust could be decanted. The other family members consented.

The court denied the petition. It noted that beneficiary-trustees are excluded from the definition of authorized trustee, which was why the petitioners wanted an outside co-trustee. It found that the proposed decanting would have reduced the income and principal available to the surviving spouse, contrary to the statute’s protection of mandatory rights and to the testator’s intent, which more than thirty years of administration under the trust’s original terms reflected. And it applied SCPA § 1502(2), which bars appointing a trustee where the appointment would contravene the will’s express terms. The decision suggests that a court may decline to add a trustee for the sole purpose of decanting, at least where the decanting would cut against the will’s terms or the creator’s intent. It is a trial-level decision on its own facts, and other courts may weigh different facts differently.

Decanting compared with other options

Decanting is one of several routes. A lifetime trust can be amended or revoked by the creator with the written consent of all beneficially interested persons under EPTL § 7-1.9, and a court can construe ambiguous language or, in limited cases, reform an instrument. Our guide to modifying an irrevocable trust in New York compares them. Where beneficiaries believe a trustee is misusing the decanting power, the remedies discussed in our guide to removing an executor or trustee may apply.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.