Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
How can a New York community legally restrict residents to people 55 or older?
Under the federal Fair Housing Act, housing for older persons is exempt from the ban on familial status discrimination if it is solely occupied by people 62 or older, or if at least 80% of occupied units have at least one resident 55 or older and the community publishes and follows age policies and verifies ages at least every two years. New York State and City law contain parallel exemptions.
Why age restrictions need an exemption
The federal Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on familial status, which protects households with children under 18. A community that excludes children would ordinarily violate that rule. The Housing for Older Persons Act of 1995 and HUD’s regulations create an exemption for housing that meets specific standards. HUD’s rules say the familial status provisions do not apply to housing that qualifies under one of three categories: state and federal programs HUD determines are specifically designed and operated to assist elderly persons, housing for people 62 or older, and housing for people 55 or older.
The exemption is narrow. It removes only the familial status protection. A qualifying community must still comply with every other fair housing rule, including the prohibitions on disability, race, and national origin discrimination and the duty to make reasonable accommodations.
The 62-or-older category
Under 24 CFR 100.303, housing qualifies if it is intended for, and solely occupied by, persons 62 years of age or older. The rule allows the community to keep this status while some units are vacant and held for older residents, and while employees under 62 who perform substantial management or maintenance duties live on site. Because every resident must generally be 62 or older, this category does not accommodate a younger spouse or caregiver as readily as the 55-and-older category does.
The 55-or-older category
| Occupancy (24 CFR 100.305) | At least 80% of occupied units must be occupied by at least one person 55 or older |
|---|---|
| Intent (24 CFR 100.306) | The community must publish and adhere to policies and procedures showing its intent to operate as 55-or-older housing |
| Verification (24 CFR 100.307) | Reliable surveys and affidavits, with procedures to update occupancy information at least once every two years |
| New construction (24 CFR 100.305(d)) | Newly constructed housing need not meet the 80% test until at least 25% of the units are occupied |
| Good faith defense (24 CFR 100.308) | Protects a natural person from personal monetary liability for familial status discrimination if he or she relied in good faith on a written, sworn certification that the community qualifies |
Several details trip communities up. HUD’s guidance says phrases such as “adult living” or “adult community” are inconsistent with the required intent. Units occupied by certain employees, and units occupied by people under 55 who are needed as a reasonable accommodation for a disabled resident, are excluded from the calculation. A community may adopt stricter rules than the 80% minimum, including requiring a person 55 or older in every unit, but it may not evict or refuse to renew families with children to reach the 80% figure. Acceptable proof of age includes a driver’s license, birth certificate, passport, immigration card, military identification, or a signed certification by an adult household member, and a summary of the occupancy surveys must be available for inspection on request.
New York State law
The New York State Human Rights Law, Executive Law § 296(5), prohibits housing discrimination based on age and familial status, among other characteristics. Its age protections apply to adults; the statute says its housing provisions relating to age do not apply to persons under 18.
The statute contains its own exemption. With respect to age and familial status, its housing provisions do not apply to restricting the sale, rental, or lease of housing exclusively to persons 62 or older and their spouses, or to housing intended and operated for occupancy by at least one person 55 or older per unit, with the federal Fair Housing Act standards applied in deciding whether housing qualifies as 55-or-older housing. Parallel provisions cover land and real estate brokers. In practice, a community that satisfies the federal standards and follows them is in the strongest position under State law as well.
New York City law
The New York City Human Rights Law, in Administrative Code § 8-107(5), also prohibits housing discrimination based on age and on the presence of children. The City law’s published text, in § 8-107(5)(h) and (i), exempts housing for older persons as defined in the federal Fair Housing Act from its protections for families with children, and permits restricting the sale or rental of housing exclusively to persons 55 or older, subject to its own conditions. Because the City law is construed broadly in favor of those it protects, owners and boards in the five boroughs should review their policies under the City law specifically and not assume the federal analysis ends the inquiry. Our article on tenant screening and fair housing discusses the broader State and City protections.
Condominiums, co-ops, and homeowners associations
In an ownership community, the age restriction usually lives in the declaration, by-laws, offering plan, proprietary lease, or recorded covenants. The documents should do several things:
- state the community’s intent to operate as housing for older persons, using language consistent with the federal regulations;
- set the occupancy rule, including whether every unit or only 80% must have a person 55 or older, and how the board allocates the remaining units;
- address surviving spouses, younger spouses and partners, caregivers, guests and length of stays, heirs who inherit a unit, and rentals;
- require residents to provide proof of age and to cooperate with surveys at least every two years; and
- give the board a consistent process for reviewing exceptions and requests for reasonable accommodation.
Adding or removing an age restriction is a significant amendment. It usually requires the vote set by the governing documents and, for a sponsor-controlled building, attention to the offering plan. A restriction applied inconsistently, or one that the community cannot document, may fail when it is challenged.
What buyers and owners should check
- Ask for the written age policy and the governing document provisions that impose it.
- Ask for a summary of the most recent occupancy survey and confirm when ages were last verified.
- Check the rules for a younger spouse, partner, or adult child, and for a caregiver who needs to live in the unit.
- Check what happens if you die or move to assisted living: whether a younger heir may occupy, rent, or only sell the unit.
- Check rental and resale restrictions, which can affect financing and value.
- For owners and boards, keep survey records, apply the policy uniformly, and review marketing language against the regulations.
Families planning for an older relative’s move should also consider the care side; see our guide to adult home and assisted living resident rights, and for income-restricted senior buildings, our guide to affordable senior housing in New York City.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.