Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Can New York landlords use AI tenant screening tools?

Yes, but the landlord remains responsible for screening decisions even when a vendor’s algorithm makes the recommendation. A tool that penalizes vouchers or other lawful income creates source-of-income discrimination exposure, and in New York City the Fair Chance for Housing Act limits when and how criminal history may be considered. Disparate impact claims remain available, and a denial based partly on a consumer report requires an FCRA adverse action notice.

How AI screening tools work

Screening products now do more than pull a credit report. Many combine credit, eviction, and criminal records with income verification and identity checks, then produce a score or an accept or decline recommendation. Some rely on models whose weighting the landlord never sees. The legal questions are the same as with a paper application: was the applicant treated differently because of a protected characteristic, and does a neutral policy unjustifiably exclude a protected group?

Disparate impact under federal law

The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination in rental housing because of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, and disability. In Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs v. Inclusive Communities Project (2015), the Supreme Court held that disparate impact claims are cognizable under the Act. A screening criterion that disproportionately excludes a protected group can create liability unless it serves a legitimate, nondiscriminatory interest that a less discriminatory alternative would not.

Federal agency positions have shifted. In September 2025, HUD withdrew a group of fair housing guidance documents, including its 2024 guidance on digital advertising and its 2022 guidance on criminal records. In January 2026, it proposed removing its disparate impact regulation, 24 C.F.R. § 100.500, and it issued a supplemental proposal in August 2026. HUD’s proposal leaves disparate impact questions to the courts. It does not change the statute or the Supreme Court’s decision, and private plaintiffs and state and local agencies can still bring these claims.

New York State and City law

The New York State Human Rights Law and the New York City Human Rights Law protect more characteristics than federal law, including lawful source of income, and the City law expressly provides for disparate impact claims. A tool that treats housing vouchers, public assistance, or other lawful income differently from wages, or that applies income minimums in a way that screens out voucher holders, can violate both laws.

Other state rules apply to any screening process. Real Property Law § 238-a generally limits background and credit check fees to the actual cost or $20, whichever is less, and requires the landlord to give the applicant a copy of the report. Real Property Law § 227-f prohibits refusing to rent because an applicant was a party to a prior landlord-tenant proceeding, so a tool that scores housing court filings must be configured with care.

Fair Chance for Housing in New York City

Local Law 24 of 2024, the Fair Chance for Housing Act, took effect on January 1, 2025. It amended the City Human Rights Law, applies to rental housing and to co-op purchase applications with limited exceptions, and is enforced by the City Commission on Human Rights and through private lawsuits. In general:

  • The housing provider must evaluate non-criminal qualifications, such as income, credit, and rental history, before running any criminal background check.
  • Only certain convictions within a lookback period may be considered, generally three years for misdemeanors and five years for felonies, with limited exceptions.
  • The applicant must receive a copy of the criminal history information and an opportunity to respond with evidence of inaccuracy or rehabilitation.
  • A denial based on criminal history requires an individualized assessment and a written explanation.

Screening products that return every criminal record, or that fold criminal history into a single score, do not fit this sequence. In the City, criminal history generally must be separated from the rest of the report and reviewed only at the permitted stage.

Vendor diligence

  • Ask what data the tool uses, what it outputs, and whether you can set or disable particular criteria.
  • Ask whether the vendor has tested its model for disparate impact and whether it will share the results.
  • Confirm that the vendor operates as a consumer reporting agency in compliance with the FCRA, including its accuracy and dispute procedures.
  • Confirm that the product can follow Fair Chance sequencing in the City and treats lawful source of income neutrally.
  • Negotiate compliance representations, audit and cooperation rights, indemnity, data security, and record retention in the contract.
  • Keep a person in the decision who can override the recommendation, and document the reason for each decision.

Adverse action notices

Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1681m, a landlord that denies an application, requires a co-signer, or imposes other less favorable terms based in whole or in part on a consumer report must give the applicant an adverse action notice. The notice identifies the consumer reporting agency, states that the agency did not make the decision, and explains the applicant’s right to a free copy of the report and to dispute its accuracy. If a credit score was used, the score and its key factors must be disclosed. New York’s Fair Credit Reporting Act, General Business Law Article 25, adds state requirements. A notice that says only that the software declined the applicant does not meet these obligations.

A related development: algorithmic rent setting

New York has also regulated algorithmic pricing. General Business Law § 340-b, enacted as Chapter 437 of the Laws of 2025 and signed October 16, 2025, restricts the use of algorithmic tools to set residential rents. In September 2026, in RealPage, Inc. v. James, the Southern District of New York preliminarily enjoined the Attorney General from enforcing the landlord-facing provision, § 340-b(3), while leaving in place the ban on facilitating agreements among landlords not to compete. The case continues, and the antitrust laws still apply, so owners that use pricing software should review how it uses competitors’ data.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.