Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

How is a foreign will used to transfer New York property?

If the will has already been probated where the decedent was domiciled, it can generally be admitted to ancillary probate in the New York Surrogate’s Court where the property is located under SCPA § 1602, and ancillary letters are then issued under SCPA § 1604. In limited cases a nondomiciliary’s will can be originally probated in New York under SCPA § 1605.

When a New York proceeding is needed

Estates are administered mainly where the decedent was domiciled. But a foreign court’s order usually does not by itself let a title company, co-op corporation, or bank transfer property located in New York. Under SCPA § 206, a New York Surrogate’s Court has jurisdiction over the estate of a nondomiciliary who leaves property in the State, and venue generally lies in a county where the property is located.

The same issue arises for people domiciled in other states who own New York property. A Floridian who keeps a Manhattan apartment, for example, will generally leave an estate that needs a New York proceeding for the apartment unless it is held in a trust or otherwise passes outside probate. For residents of New York, by contrast, see our overview of probate and administration in New York.

Ancillary probate based on a foreign probate

SCPA Article 16 governs foreign estates. Under § 1602, a written will that may operate on New York property can be admitted to ancillary probate on proof that it has been admitted to probate, or established, at the testator’s domicile and, if that probate is still open to contest there, that it is not being contested. Once admitted, the will operates on New York property within its terms, subject to the domicile’s rules on capacity and spousal rights to take against the will.

A will offered for ancillary probate can be contested in New York only on the ground that these conditions are not met or that the will has been denied probate here. That narrows the New York proceeding: the merits are generally left to the domiciliary court.

Jurisdiction and venueSCPA § 206: estate of a nondomiciliary who leaves property in New York; county where property is located
Ancillary probateSCPA § 1602: will admitted at the domicile and not being contested there
Ancillary letters on a willSCPA § 1604
Original probate of a nondomiciliary’s willSCPA § 1605
Ancillary letters of administrationSCPA § 1607
Authentication of foreign wills and lettersSCPA § 1614

Who receives ancillary letters

After ancillary probate, SCPA § 1604 directs the court to issue ancillary letters on request, in this order: the executor named in the will to administer New York property; the domiciliary fiduciary, or if none was appointed, the person the will designates to administer all property; the person acting at the domicile to administer and distribute the estate; and then a person entitled to letters of administration with the will annexed. If the person with priority will not or cannot qualify, the court moves down the list or appoints an eligible designee.

Where the decedent died without a will, ancillary letters of administration are available under SCPA § 1607. Either way, the ancillary fiduciary deals with the New York property, pays New York claims and taxes, and generally remits the balance as the law and the court direct.

Original probate in New York

A nondomiciliary’s will that may affect New York property and that New York law treats as validly executed, including under EPTL § 3-5.1, can also be admitted to original probate here under SCPA § 1605, as if the decedent were a domiciliary. If the will has already been probated or established at the domicile, original probate in New York is available only if ancillary probate would be unduly expensive, inconvenient, or impossible, if the testator directed that the will be offered for probate in New York, or if the domicile’s law discriminates against New York domiciliaries as beneficiaries or fiduciaries. A will denied probate at the domicile generally cannot be originally probated here, unless the denial rested on a ground that would not have defeated a New York domiciliary’s will.

Is the foreign will valid here?

Under EPTL § 3-5.1(c), a will disposing of personal property wherever located, or of New York real property, is formally valid and admissible to probate in New York if it is in writing, signed by the testator, and executed and attested in the manner required by New York law, the law of the place where it was signed, or the law of the testator’s domicile when it was signed or at death. Formal validity is separate from what the will can do: under EPTL § 3-5.1(b), real property is generally governed by the law of the place where the land is located and personal property by the law of the domicile at death, though under § 3-5.1(h) a nondomiciliary can elect in the will to have New York law govern the disposition of New York property.

Practical proof matters as much as validity. Courts and title companies typically expect authenticated copies of the foreign will and decree and certified English translations, and assembling them from abroad can take time. For the formalities of a will signed in New York, see how to make a valid will in New York.

Co-ops, condos, and accounts

The type of property affects the process. A condominium unit or house passes by deed from the ancillary fiduciary. A co-op apartment is held as shares and a proprietary lease, so the cooperative corporation’s transfer requirements and board approval apply as well; see our guide to transferring a co-op after death. Banks and brokers may have their own requirements for foreign fiduciaries, and the estate may need New York and federal tax clearances before property can be released or sold.

Avoiding the problem with planning

  • Hold New York property in a revocable trust, so a successor trustee can act without a New York court proceeding; see will vs. revocable trust in New York.
  • Use a New York situs will for New York assets, drafted with the foreign will so that neither revokes the other.
  • Name a fiduciary for New York property who can qualify and act here.
  • Consider a direction in the will about where it should be probated, which SCPA § 1605 recognizes.
  • For foreign owners, address U.S. and New York estate tax at the same time; see QDOTs and non-citizen spouses and our discussion of New York estate tax on property kept by nonresidents.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.