Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Should I have a will or a revocable trust in New York?

A will is usually enough for a simple estate with cooperative heirs, while a revocable trust is often the better fit for people who own real estate, value privacy, or want a plan for incapacity. A will takes effect through probate in the Surrogate’s Court; assets properly held in a funded trust pass without probate. A revocable trust does not by itself reduce estate tax or protect assets from creditors or Medicaid.

The short answer

A will is usually enough for a simple estate with cooperative heirs, while a revocable trust is often the better fit for people who own real estate, value privacy, or want a plan for incapacity. Both can carry the same instructions — who inherits, in what shares, and in trust for whom. The choice turns on process, not on what the family ultimately receives.

How each one works

A will has no effect until death and then must be proved in the Surrogate’s Court. The executor gets authority only when the court issues letters testamentary, and every distributee must receive notice or sign a waiver.

A revocable living trust is an agreement under which you, usually as your own trustee, hold title to assets during life. In New York, a lifetime trust must be in writing and either acknowledged before a notary or signed before two witnesses under EPTL 7-1.17. When you die or become incapacitated, a successor trustee you named takes over without a court appointment.

Side by side

Court involvement at deathWill: probate required. Trust: generally none for trust assets
Notice to familyWill: all distributees receive notice or sign waivers. Trust: beneficiaries only
PrivacyWill: becomes part of the court file. Trust: generally private
IncapacityWill: no effect; an agent under a power of attorney acts. Trust: successor trustee manages trust assets
Up-front costWill: lower. Trust: higher, including the work of funding
Estate taxSame for both; tax planning comes from the provisions, not the vehicle
Creditor and Medicaid protectionNone for either while you are alive and can revoke

Cost and time

A will costs less to prepare, but probate adds court filing fees, legal fees, and months before the executor can act. A trust costs more at the start, mostly because assets must be retitled, but it can let a successor trustee act within days of death. For an estate of bank accounts with named beneficiaries and a cooperative family, probate may be quick and the savings modest. For an estate with real estate, a family that might disagree, or heirs who are hard to locate, avoiding probate can save substantial time.

Funding is the whole game

A revocable trust controls only the assets titled in its name or payable to it. A house still deeded to you, or a brokerage account still in your own name, goes through probate under your will, which for a trust-based plan is typically a short pour-over will leaving everything to the trust. Funding means signing a new deed for real estate, retitling bank and investment accounts, assigning co-op shares and the proprietary lease, and reviewing beneficiary designations. Retirement accounts generally stay in your name with beneficiaries named directly, because transferring them to a trust during life would be treated as a withdrawal.

Co-ops and New York real estate

Real estate is where a trust most often pays for itself. A house or condominium can be deeded to the trust, and transfers into a revocable trust for no consideration generally do not trigger transfer tax, although the required forms must still be filed. A co-op is different: moving shares and the lease into a trust usually needs board consent, and many buildings have their own trust forms and requirements. When the board cooperates, a trust can spare the family the wait for letters testamentary before dealing with the managing agent after death. Property in another state should almost always be held in the trust to avoid a second probate there.

Incapacity

A will does nothing during life; a funded trust lets your successor trustee manage trust assets if you cannot. Even with a trust, you still need a durable power of attorney for assets outside the trust, tax matters, and benefits, and a health care proxy for medical decisions.

What a revocable trust does not do

Because you can revoke it, the trust’s assets are treated as yours for estate tax, creditor, and Medicaid purposes. New York estate tax planning, asset protection, and Medicaid planning use separate tools, such as credit shelter provisions or irrevocable trusts. A revocable trust also does not prevent a challenge; beneficiaries can still contest it on grounds such as capacity or undue influence.

Which fits whom

  • A will alone often suits a younger person or couple with modest assets held mostly in accounts with named beneficiaries.
  • A revocable trust often suits owners of New York real estate, especially co-ops and property in more than one state.
  • A trust is often worth considering for people who expect family friction, want privacy, or have heirs who are minors, disabled, or abroad.
  • Anyone planning for possible incapacity should consider a funded trust together with a durable power of attorney and a health care proxy.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.