Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
What is the difference between probate and administration in New York?
Probate is the Surrogate’s Court proceeding to prove a will and appoint the executor it names, who receives letters testamentary. Administration is the proceeding for an estate with no will: the court appoints an administrator from the people with priority under SCPA 1001, starting with the surviving spouse and then the children, and issues letters of administration. Administrators usually must post a bond, while a will often waives bond for the executor.
The short answer
Probate is for an estate with a will, and administration is for an estate without one. In both, the Surrogate’s Court of the county where the decedent lived appoints a fiduciary and issues letters — the document banks, brokers, title companies, and co-op boards require before they will deal with anyone on the estate’s behalf. The fiduciary’s duties afterward are largely the same.
Probate: when there is a will
In probate, the person named as executor files a petition with the original will and a certified death certificate. Every distributee — the people who would inherit if there were no will — must sign a waiver and consent or be served with a citation. The court reviews the will’s execution, often relying on a self-proving affidavit, and if it is satisfied, admits the will and issues letters testamentary to the executor.
The will controls who inherits, subject to the surviving spouse’s right of election, and it usually controls who serves. A person with standing may object to the will, which turns probate into a contested proceeding.
Administration: when there is no will
In administration, there is no nominated executor, so the court chooses an administrator from the people with priority under SCPA 1001. The estate passes to the distributees under the intestacy statute, EPTL 4-1.1. The petition must identify every distributee, and those with equal or prior rights must consent or be cited. If no family member qualifies or is willing, the Public Administrator or another eligible person may serve. When the family tree is unclear, the court may require kinship proof before distribution.
Who can serve
In administration, priority under SCPA 1001 runs generally in this order: the surviving spouse, the children, the grandchildren, the parents, the brothers and sisters, and then other distributees, with preference to those entitled to the largest share. A person must also be eligible under SCPA 707, which generally disqualifies minors, people adjudged incompetent, felons, and others the court finds unfit, for example because of dishonesty or substance abuse, and restricts service by certain non-domiciliaries who are not U.S. citizens. An executor named in a will must meet the same eligibility rules but otherwise serves by the testator’s choice.
Side by side
| Applies when | Probate: there is a will. Administration: there is no valid will |
|---|---|
| Who serves | Probate: the executor named in the will. Administration: the person with priority under SCPA 1001 |
| Authority document | Probate: letters testamentary. Administration: letters of administration |
| Who inherits | Probate: the will’s beneficiaries. Administration: distributees under EPTL 4-1.1 |
| Bond | Probate: often waived by the will. Administration: generally required unless excused |
| Limits on authority | Probate: as the will provides. Administration: often restricted until the court is satisfied, for example on suing or compromising claims |
Bonds
A bond is insurance that protects the estate if the fiduciary mismanages it. Most wills drafted by lawyers waive the executor’s bond. An administrator generally must obtain a bond, sized to the personal property and certain other assets, unless the court dispenses with it, for example when all distributees are competent adults who consent. Bond premiums are an estate expense, and a fiduciary with poor credit may have difficulty obtaining one.
Small estates
If the decedent left personal property with a gross value of $50,000 or less, excluding certain property set aside for the family under EPTL 5-3.1, the estate may qualify for voluntary administration under SCPA Article 13. A voluntary administrator files a simpler affidavit, receives a certificate rather than letters, collects the assets, pays debts, and distributes. Real property generally is not administered this way, and the short form is not available if the estate needs litigation or a full fiduciary.
Timing
An uncontested probate with signed waivers can produce letters within weeks to a few months, depending on the county’s caseload and the completeness of the filing. Administration often takes longer, because the court must be satisfied about who all the distributees are. Citations, missing relatives, or objections add months. Letters are the beginning, not the end: the fiduciary then collects assets, waits out the creditor period, handles taxes, and accounts before final distribution.
Assets that avoid both
Many assets pass without either proceeding: jointly held property with a right of survivorship, accounts with named beneficiaries or transfer-on-death designations, life insurance, retirement accounts, and property in a funded revocable trust. An estate made up entirely of these may need no court proceeding at all.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.