Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
What is a reverse or improvement 1031 exchange?
In a reverse exchange, you buy the replacement property before you sell the old one. In an improvement exchange, the replacement property is built or renovated before you take title. In both, an exchange accommodation titleholder holds title for you, generally for no more than 180 days under IRS Rev. Proc. 2000-37. Only work finished before the property is transferred to you counts toward the exchange.
Why the standard sequence does not always fit
Most exchanges are forward exchanges: the investor sells, a qualified intermediary holds the proceeds, and the replacement property is bought within the deadlines described in our guide to 1031 exchange timelines in New York. Two situations do not fit that order. The first is a buyer who finds the right replacement property before the old building is sold. The second is an investor whose replacement property needs construction or renovation to reach the value required to defer all of the gain.
The investor cannot simply buy the replacement property in its own name and sell the old property later. Section 1031 requires an exchange, and the Tax Court has held that a taxpayer who already owned the replacement property before disposing of the relinquished property made a taxable sale (DeCleene v. Commissioner, 115 T.C. 457 (2000)). The solution is to have a third party hold title, or “park” the property, until the exchange can be completed.
The IRS safe harbor for parking
Rev. Proc. 2000-37 provides a safe harbor for a qualified exchange accommodation arrangement. If its conditions are met, the IRS treats the exchange accommodation titleholder (often called the EAT, and often an affiliate of the qualified intermediary) as the owner of the parked property for federal income tax purposes. The main conditions are:
- The EAT, which cannot be the investor or a disqualified person such as the investor’s agent, holds legal title or other qualified indicia of ownership, and is generally subject to federal income tax.
- The investor intends the property to be part of a 1031 exchange, and a written accommodation agreement is signed no later than five business days after the EAT takes title.
- The property to be relinquished is identified within 45 days after the EAT acquires the parked property.
- The parked property is transferred to the investor, or to the buyer of the relinquished property, within 180 days. The combined time any property is held under the arrangement cannot exceed 180 days.
The safe harbor allows the investor to lend the EAT the purchase money or provide a guaranty of its loan, to lease and manage the property, to supervise improvements, and to hold puts and calls on the property. Rev. Proc. 2004-51 later added an important limit: the safe harbor does not apply to replacement property the investor owned at any time in the 180 days before the EAT took title.
Two ways to structure a reverse exchange
| Park the replacement property (“exchange last”) | The EAT buys and holds the new property. The investor sells the old property through a qualified intermediary, and the proceeds are used to acquire the new property from the EAT. This is the more common structure. |
|---|---|
| Park the relinquished property (“exchange first”) | The investor transfers the old property to the EAT and acquires the new property in the same exchange. The EAT then sells the old property to a buyer within the 180 days. This can suit lenders who will finance only a borrower that holds title directly. |
| Either structure | The investor usually funds the EAT, leases the parked property, and pays its costs. The EAT earns a fee and takes no economic risk. |
Which structure fits depends mainly on financing. A lender for the new property must be willing to lend to the EAT, or to the investor in the exchange-first form, and to accept the transfer at the end.
Improvement and build-to-suit exchanges
In an improvement exchange, the EAT acquires the replacement property and the investor, acting under the accommodation agreement, causes improvements to be built with funds advanced to the EAT. The improved property is then transferred to the investor within the 180-day period. The investor receives credit in the exchange for the purchase price plus the improvements in place at that time.
Treasury regulations govern property that is still being built. The identification must describe the land and, as far as is practicable, the planned construction. The property received must be substantially the same as what was identified. If construction is unfinished when the investor receives the property, only the completed portion counts, and work done after the investor takes title is not treated as like-kind property. Unused construction funds left in the arrangement are generally taxable as boot.
The 2004 limit matters here too. Because the safe harbor does not apply to property the investor owned in the prior 180 days, an investor generally cannot deed land it already owns to an EAT, build on it, and count the building as replacement property. The IRS said it was continuing to study arrangements built on leaseholds from related parties, and those structures carry added risk.
Outside the safe harbor
Rev. Proc. 2000-37 states that no inference is intended about parking arrangements that fall outside it. In Estate of Bartell v. Commissioner, 147 T.C. 140 (2016), the Tax Court upheld a pre-safe-harbor reverse exchange in which an accommodation party held the replacement property for more than 17 months. The IRS issued a nonacquiescence in AOD 2017-06, signaling that it may continue to challenge arrangements where the investor, not the accommodation party, has the benefits and burdens of ownership.
Some projects, especially ground-up construction, cannot be finished in 180 days. A non-safe-harbor arrangement is possible but carries real audit risk and should be decided with tax counsel before the property is acquired, not when day 180 approaches.
New York transfer and recording taxes
Parking adds steps, and in New York each conveyance must be analyzed for State real estate transfer tax and, in New York City, the City’s real property transfer tax. The transfer into the EAT is a taxable conveyance in the ordinary way. Whether the later transfer from the EAT to the investor is taxed again depends on the facts. In a 2016 advisory opinion (TSB-A-16(2)R), the State Department of Taxation and Finance concluded that the EAT-to-investor conveyance in a reverse exchange was not subject to the State tax, because the EAT acted as the investor’s agent and received no consideration. The City’s Department of Finance reached a similar result in a 2003 letter ruling, treating the accommodation titleholder as the taxpayer’s agent. Both rulings bind only the parties that requested them and turned on specific documents, so the accommodation and lease agreements should be drafted with the agency factors in mind.
Financing raises a parallel issue. A mortgage given by the EAT is recorded and generally subject to mortgage recording tax. If the investor will keep the loan after the transfer, the loan should be structured so it can be assumed or assigned rather than replaced with a new, separately taxed mortgage. A CEMA may help when new money is added later. Confirm current rates and any available exemption with your title company before closing.
New York City practicalities
- Construction schedules: Department of Buildings permits, Landmarks Preservation Commission approvals, and contractor availability can consume most of 180 days. Interior renovations and tenant fit-outs are far more realistic than ground-up projects.
- Co-ops and condos: a co-op board is unlikely to approve an accommodation titleholder as a shareholder, and condo rights of first refusal add time. See our article on 1031 exchanges with NYC co-ops and condos.
- Lenders: many lenders have approved forms for lending to an EAT, but the loan documents, guaranties, and the lease between the EAT and the investor take time to negotiate. Start early.
- Costs: expect accommodation fees, legal and title costs for extra steps, and the cost of carrying two properties at once.
- Fallback: if the relinquished property does not sell in time, the parked property is transferred without completing an exchange. Our article on what happens when a 1031 exchange fails explains the consequences.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.