Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Can a New York City co-op or condo be used in a 1031 exchange?

Yes, if it is held for investment or business use. A condo unit is real property under New York law. Treasury regulations finalized in 2020 list stock in a cooperative housing corporation as real property for 1031 purposes. The harder issues are practical: co-op sublet limits, board approval timing within the 180-day exchange period, transfer taxes and flip taxes, and units once used as a home.

The short answer

A 1031 exchange requires real property on both sides, held for use in a business or for investment. A condominium unit, together with its share of the common elements, is real property under Real Property Law § 339-g, so a rented condo can be exchanged for a rental building, land, or another condo.

Co-ops were long the harder case, because the owner holds shares in a corporation and a proprietary lease rather than a deed. Treasury regulations finalized in December 2020 now list “stock in a cooperative housing corporation” among the interests that are real property for 1031 purposes, alongside fee ownership, leaseholds, and easements. A co-op apartment held for investment can therefore generally be exchanged for other investment real estate, and the reverse is also true. Confirm with your tax adviser that the corporation qualifies as a cooperative housing corporation.

Why co-op shares were uncertain

New York law treats co-op shares as personal property for some purposes and as an interest in real property for others. A co-op loan, for example, is generally secured under the Uniform Commercial Code rather than by a recorded mortgage, so mortgage recording tax does not apply to it, while State and City transfer taxes do apply to co-op transfers. Before those regulations, the IRS addressed co-ops through private letter rulings, which bind only the taxpayer that requests them. Because the current regulations name co-op stock directly, the state-law label matters much less for federal purposes than it once did. Some older guidance, including on websites, has not caught up.

The investment requirement

Like any exchange property, the apartment must be held for investment or business use, both the one sold and the one bought. A unit rented to unrelated tenants at market rent is the clearest case. Personal use weakens it, and an apartment used as a primary residence is not held for investment.

  • Co-op sublet policies: many boards cap how long or how often an owner may sublet, and some prohibit it. An owner who cannot rent the unit will have difficulty showing investment intent.
  • Former homes: an apartment that was once the owner’s residence can become investment property, but it should be converted and rented first. The IRS has a safe harbor for dwelling units with limited personal use, and special rules apply if an owner later moves into exchange property. See our article on vacation homes and moving into exchange property.
  • Pieds-à-terre: an apartment the owner uses part of the year is difficult to treat as investment property. Meeting the safe harbor’s rental and personal-use limits gives the most certainty; outside it, the result depends on all the facts. See also our article on the pied-à-terre tax.

Board approval and the 180-day clock

The exchange deadlines do not stop for a board. Replacement property must be identified within 45 days after the relinquished closing and acquired within 180 days, as our guide to 1031 exchange timelines explains. A co-op board package, interview, and decision can take several weeks or more, and a condo board’s right of first refusal often runs about 30 days after the board receives a complete package.

  • Identify backups. If a board rejects you after day 45, you can buy only property you identified. Under the three-property rule, list alternates.
  • Use the contract. Ask for a deadline for the board decision, a right to cancel if approval is not received in time, and cooperation language for the exchange.
  • Expect investor scrutiny. Boards often ask about the purchaser’s plans to sublet and may limit investor purchases. Our article on co-op board rejections covers the options after a rejection.
  • Selling a unit: when the relinquished property is a co-op, the buyer’s board review controls when the sale closes. The exchange clock starts only when it does.

Investor-friendly units

Units held by the sponsor or a “holder of unsold shares” are often the easiest co-op units for investors, because the offering plan may let the purchaser sublet without board approval. Whether that status passes to a buyer depends on the specific offering plan and the co-op’s documents, so it should be confirmed before signing. Condominiums generally allow leasing more freely than co-ops, subject to the declaration and bylaws, and new development condos are frequently bought by investors. A reverse or improvement exchange involving a co-op is rarely practical, because a board is unlikely to approve an accommodation titleholder as a shareholder; see our article on reverse and improvement exchanges.

Flip taxes, transfer taxes, and closing costs

A 1031 exchange defers income tax only. On the sale side, the seller pays New York State and New York City transfer taxes on co-op and condo transfers as it would on any sale, and a co-op may charge a flip tax under its proprietary lease or bylaws. On the purchase side, the buyer of a residential unit for $1 million or more generally pays the State mansion tax even when the unit will be rented. Customary closing costs can generally be paid from exchange funds, but some items, such as loan costs and rent prorations, can create taxable boot, so review the closing statements with your tax adviser. Our guides to seller and buyer closing costs list the current rates.

New York income tax treatment, including the nonresident estimated-tax filing at closing, is covered in New York taxes on 1031 exchanges.

Financing and debt replacement

Replacing the debt paid off on the sale is part of a fully deferred exchange. Co-op boards often set minimum down payments or limit financing, which can make it hard to carry the same debt on a co-op purchase; additional cash can make up the difference. A condo purchase uses a recorded mortgage subject to mortgage recording tax. A CEMA can reduce that tax when an existing condo mortgage is assigned, but it is not available for co-op share loans, which are not mortgages.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.