Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

How much can a CEMA save on New York mortgage recording tax?

A CEMA assigns your existing mortgage to the new lender and consolidates it with the new loan, so mortgage recording tax is paid only on the new money. In New York City, residential borrowers commonly pay 1.8 or 1.925 percent, so the saving depends on the balance assigned. It works for refinances and house or condo purchases, not co-op loans, and requires both lenders’ cooperation and added fees.

Why a CEMA saves money

When a mortgage is recorded in New York, mortgage recording tax is due on the principal it secures. Tax Law § 255 generally exempts a supplemental mortgage that secures no new principal beyond the debt already secured by a recorded mortgage on which the tax was paid. A consolidation, extension, and modification agreement relies on that rule. The existing mortgage is assigned to the new lender instead of being paid off and satisfied. A new gap mortgage for the new money is recorded, and the two are consolidated into a single loan. Tax is paid only on the gap mortgage.

New York City rates

1–3 family or condo, loan under $500,0002.05% combined; borrower typically pays 1.8%
1–3 family or condo, loan $500,000 or more2.175% combined; borrower typically pays 1.925%
Other mortgages, $500,000 or more, including most commercial2.8%

On residential properties with no more than six units, a 0.25 percent portion of the tax is paid by an institutional lender. That is why borrowers commonly pay 1.8 or 1.925 percent. Rates outside New York City are lower. Exact figures depend on the property type and the amount, so confirm them with the title company before closing.

A purchase CEMA example

Suppose a buyer finances $2,000,000 toward a house, and the seller’s existing mortgage has an unpaid balance of $1,200,000. Without a CEMA, the buyer would generally pay about $38,500 in recording tax (1.925 percent of $2,000,000). With a purchase CEMA, the seller’s lender assigns the $1,200,000 mortgage to the buyer’s lender. Tax is paid only on the $800,000 of new money, about $15,400. The gross saving is about $23,100, before the costs of doing the CEMA.

A refinance CEMA works the same way. A borrower who owes $900,000 and refinances for $1,000,000 can assign the existing mortgage to the new lender and pay tax only on the additional $100,000, instead of on the full new loan.

Who it helps

  • Owners refinancing houses, condo units, and commercial property with a meaningful remaining balance.
  • Buyers of houses and condos whose seller has a sizable mortgage and whose seller’s lender will assign it.
  • Sponsors and developers, in some cases, when construction or acquisition loans are being restructured.
  • Not co-op buyers or owners. A co-op share loan is secured by shares, not a recorded mortgage, so there is no recording tax to save.

What it costs and how long it takes

The savings are not free. The existing lender usually charges a fee to prepare the assignment and deliver the original note and loan file. The new lender may charge its own CEMA fee. Attorneys’ fees and title charges are higher because there are more documents to prepare, review, and record. On a purchase, the seller typically must agree in the contract to request the CEMA, and the parties often negotiate who pays the seller’s added costs or how the saving is shared.

Timing is the most common problem. The new lender needs the existing lender’s payoff and assignment documents, and some servicers are slow. Building in time, and stating in the contract what happens if the assignment is not delivered, protects both sides.

Lender cooperation

A CEMA requires two willing lenders. The existing lender must agree to assign rather than satisfy its mortgage, and the new lender must agree to take the assignment. Most large residential lenders participate, and loans sold to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac can generally be assigned, but policies vary. Ask early. A borrower should also confirm that the new lender will close on the CEMA timeline and that the rate lock covers it.

Is it worth it?

As a rule of thumb, a CEMA is worth pursuing when the assigned balance is large enough that the tax saved clearly exceeds the added lender, legal, and title costs. For small remaining balances, the saving may not justify the cost and delay. A careful estimate before the contract is signed, or before a refinance application is made, answers the question.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.