Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
What can an out-of-network provider recover from a New York Medicaid managed care plan?
Usually no more than the Medicaid fee-for-service rate, which New York’s Medicaid managed care contracts and federal law set as the ceiling for non-participating providers of emergency care. Patients cannot be balance billed, Medicaid managed care disputes can no longer go to New York IDR, and the federal No Surprises Act process never covered Medicaid. Recovery usually lies in payment accuracy, wrongful denials, late-payment interest, and better contract terms going forward.
Why this comes up
Hospital-based specialists, especially anesthesiologists, CRNAs, radiologists, pathologists, and emergency physicians, often treat Medicaid patients at facilities that participate with plans the practice does not. The practice bills its usual charges, the plan pays a fraction, and the gap looks like an underpayment. For commercial plans, that gap may be worth taking to arbitration. For Medicaid managed care, the rules are different, and the starting question is not what the practice charged but what the plan was required to pay.
What a Medicaid plan must pay a non-participating provider
Medicaid managed care in New York operates under Social Services Law § 364-j and contracts between the State and each plan. The State’s model contract has long provided that a plan pays a non-participating provider for emergency department services, and for physician services furnished while the enrollee is in the emergency department, at the Medicaid fee-for-service rate in effect on the date of service. Plans also may not deny emergency claims because the provider or patient failed to give notice.
Federal law points the same way. Section 1932(b)(2)(D) of the Social Security Act provides that a provider of emergency services without a contract with a Medicaid managed care entity must accept as payment in full no more than it could collect if the patient were in fee-for-service Medicaid. For non-emergency services, a plan generally pays an out-of-network provider only when it has authorized the care or agreed to a single-case agreement, and the rate is set by that authorization or agreement.
The practical result: when a plan has paid a non-participating provider the correct fee-for-service amount, it has usually paid what it owes.
The patient cannot make up the difference
A provider that furnishes covered services to a Medicaid recipient must accept the Medicaid payment as payment in full (42 C.F.R. § 447.15). Billing the patient for the balance is not permitted, and attempting it creates compliance risk for the practice. The only cost-sharing a Medicaid enrollee may owe is the nominal copayment the program allows, if any.
Arbitration is not available
- New York IDR. Part BB of Chapter 57 of the Laws of 2026 excluded Medicaid managed care from the independent dispute resolution process under Financial Services Law Article 6 for disputes filed on or after May 28, 2026. See New York IDR after the 2026 amendments.
- Federal IDR. The No Surprises Act applies to group health plans and individual coverage, not to Medicaid, so the federal process is not an option either. See New York IDR or federal IDR.
Why litigation for billed charges rarely works
A provider can sue a plan, but the claim has to rest on something that entitles the provider to more than the plan paid. Out-of-network providers have no contract with the plan, the State’s contract and federal law set the payment at the fee-for-service amount, and courts are reluctant to find that a plan owes a higher “reasonable value” when public law already fixes the rate. Small claims court does not change the analysis, and it is impractical at volume in any event: a business may bring no more than five commercial claims a month statewide, each capped at $10,000.
That does not mean every Medicaid claim is closed. It means the dispute is usually about whether the plan paid the right fee-for-service amount, paid on time, and paid at all.
Where recovery usually remains
1. Payment accuracy
Fee-schedule payments are calculated, and calculations go wrong. For anesthesia claims in particular, check each remittance for:
- Base units and time units. Missing or truncated time units are a common source of small, repeated underpayments.
- Modifier handling. Payment reductions for medically directed or CRNA services should match the program’s rules for the modifiers billed.
- The rate in effect on the date of service. When the State updates fee schedules, plans can lag in loading new rates.
- Bundling and edits. Separately payable services denied as included in another code.
Across thousands of claims, a few dollars per claim can add up. A sample audit of 835 remittances against the fee schedule in effect on each date of service is the efficient way to find out.
2. Denied and unpaid claims
Denials for missing authorization, eligibility, timely filing, or coding can often be appealed. Plans may not deny emergency claims for lack of notice. Track each denial reason code, the appeal deadline, and the outcome. A pattern of improper denials can also be raised with the Department of Health, which oversees Medicaid managed care plans.
3. Late payment
Medicaid managed care plans are generally organized under Article 44 of the Public Health Law, and New York’s prompt pay statute, Insurance Law § 3224-a, applies to those organizations. Undisputed claims must be paid within 30 days if submitted electronically or 45 days otherwise, and late payments can carry interest. See New York’s prompt pay law for providers.
4. Contracting going forward
The fee schedule is a ceiling for non-participating providers, but not for participating ones. A practice with substantial Medicaid volume at a facility may do better negotiating a participation agreement or single-case agreements, with attention to rate escalators, payment policies, and dispute terms. See Managed Care Contracting.
What to gather before deciding
- 835 remittances or EOBs showing allowed amount, paid amount, and adjustment and denial codes for each claim.
- The plan line for each patient. Payer names alone are not enough, because the same company may offer commercial, Medicaid, and Medicare products.
- Participation status with each plan, and any single-case agreements.
- For each claim: whether the service was emergent, the facility, and any authorization.
- Submission dates and clearinghouse acceptance reports, for prompt pay timing.
- Any appeals already filed and their status.
Because this information includes protected health information, a business associate agreement should be in place before it is shared with outside counsel.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.