Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
How quickly must New York insurers pay provider claims under the prompt pay law?
Under Insurance Law § 3224-a, undisputed claims must be paid within 30 days of receipt if submitted electronically and within 45 days if submitted by other means. If liability is not reasonably clear, the insurer must deny or request information in writing within 30 calendar days. Late payments carry interest at the greater of 12 percent per year or the corporate tax rate. The law covers New York-regulated plans, not self-funded ERISA plans.
Who the law covers
Section 3224-a applies to insurers, HMOs, and other organizations regulated under New York’s Insurance Law and Public Health Law, for claims from policyholders and from health care providers. It does not reach self-funded employer plans governed by ERISA, which are subject to federal claims rules instead. Checking the plan type at the first remittance is the starting point.
The payment deadlines
When the insurer’s obligation to pay is reasonably clear, it must pay within 30 days of receiving a claim submitted electronically, and within 45 days of receiving a claim submitted on paper or by fax. These deadlines do not apply where the obligation to pay is not reasonably clear or where there is a reasonable basis, supported by specific information, to believe the claim was submitted fraudulently.
Denials and requests for information
If the insurer is not obligated to pay, or needs more information, it must notify the provider in writing within 30 calendar days of receiving the claim. The notice must state the reasons for denying the claim in whole or in part, or identify the information needed to decide it. Once the insurer receives the requested information or an appeal, and determines that payment is due, it must pay within 15 days of that determination.
Providers should track the date each claim was received, the date of any request, and the date the response was sent. Repeated requests for information already provided are worth documenting.
Interest on late payments
An insurer that fails to comply must pay the claim plus interest at the greater of the corporate tax rate determined by the Commissioner of Taxation and Finance or 12 percent per year, computed from the date payment was required. Interest under two dollars need not be paid. Each claim processed in violation of the statute is a separate violation.
Timely filing
Under § 3224-a(g), providers generally must initially submit claims within 120 days after the date of service to be valid and enforceable against the insurer, unless the parties agree to terms more favorable to the provider. Participating providers may request reconsideration of a claim denied solely as untimely if the delay resulted from an unusual occurrence and the provider has a pattern of timely submission; the insurer may reduce payment on such a claim by up to 25 percent, and may deny claims submitted more than 365 days after the date of service.
Enforcing the law
- File a prompt pay complaint with the Department of Financial Services, which accepts complaints from providers.
- Demand statutory interest along with the unpaid amount.
- Raise the violation in an underpayment action or as part of a broader dispute with the plan.
- Keep complete records of submission dates, clearinghouse reports, and correspondence.
How prompt pay fits with IDR
Prompt pay and Independent Dispute Resolution address different questions. Prompt pay governs how quickly the plan must pay or deny. IDR, under Financial Services Law Article 6, decides whether the amount the plan paid an out-of-network provider for an emergency service or surprise bill was reasonable. An on-time payment can still be too low, and a late payment can still be disputed in IDR. Track both: prompt pay deadlines from the date of submission, and IDR eligibility and filing rules from the plan’s payment or denial.
Overpayment recoveries
The companion statute, Insurance Law § 3224-b, limits how and when insurers may recover claimed overpayments, including advance notice requirements and time limits subject to exceptions. Providers facing a recoupment demand should compare it against those limits before agreeing to an offset.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.