Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

What legal risks come with using AI in New York real estate deals?

Uploading deal documents to an AI tool can breach a confidentiality agreement or expose client information, so check the tool’s data terms first. AI-drafted contracts and summaries can be wrong in ways that look right and must be checked against the source documents. AI-written listings remain subject to fair housing rules and 19 NYCRR § 175.25, and brokers should keep AI-assisted drafts and listing materials with their transaction records.

Confidentiality of deal data

Purchase agreements, rent rolls, estoppel certificates, and offering memoranda are usually covered by a confidentiality agreement, and brokers owe their principals a fiduciary duty of confidentiality. Many consumer AI tools may retain what is entered or use it to improve their models unless the settings or an enterprise agreement provide otherwise. Before uploading anything, consider:

  • Whether the confidentiality agreement allows disclosure to service providers, and on what conditions.
  • Whether the tool’s terms prohibit training on your data and limit retention.
  • Whether tenant names, Social Security numbers, bank information, or other personal data can be removed first. New York’s SHIELD Act requires businesses that hold New Yorkers’ private information to maintain reasonable safeguards.
  • Who in the organization may use which tools, and for what kinds of documents.

Accuracy of AI-drafted documents

Generative tools can produce a polished rider, lease abstract, or title summary that omits a condition, invents a clause, or applies another state’s law. Common errors include wrong notice periods and dates, reversed obligations between landlord and tenant, and citations to statutes that do not exist or do not apply in New York. A signed contract binds the parties regardless of how it was drafted.

Brokers face an added constraint. In New York, a broker generally may not draft contracts or give legal advice, and producing those documents with an AI tool raises the same unauthorized practice concerns under Judiciary Law §§ 478 and 484. Owners should treat AI output as a first draft for the lawyer or the responsible principal to review, never as the final word on what a document says.

Listing descriptions and fair housing

The Fair Housing Act, 42 U.S.C. § 3604(c), makes it unlawful to publish an advertisement that indicates a preference, limitation, or discrimination based on a protected characteristic. The State and City Human Rights Laws apply the same rule to additional characteristics, including lawful source of income and age. AI tools trained on old listings can reproduce phrases such as “perfect for young professionals,” “ideal for a single person,” or “no vouchers.” Each of these can create liability.

Ad delivery matters as well as wording. Platforms that let an advertiser target or exclude audiences by age, family status, or neighborhood can produce discriminatory results even when the ad text is neutral. Review AI-generated copy and targeting settings before anything is published.

New York broker advertising rules

The Department of State’s advertising regulation, 19 NYCRR § 175.25, applies regardless of who or what drafted the ad. In general, an advertisement must identify the brokerage by name and as a licensed real estate broker, and it may not be false or misleading. The supervising broker remains responsible for advertising placed by its licensees. Untrustworthy or misleading practices can lead to discipline under Real Property Law § 441-c, and members of the National Association of Realtors are also bound by the Code of Ethics duty to present a true picture in advertising.

AI-generated images and altered photos

Virtual staging, sky replacement, and AI renderings are now routine. An image that adds features the property does not have, removes visible defects, or changes the layout can be a misrepresentation under consumer protection law and a ground for license discipline.

As of November 5, 2026, New York has not enacted a listing-photo disclosure law. Bills introduced in 2026, S9584 and A11403, would require disclosure of materially altered images and virtual staging and would make violations by licensees grounds for discipline; both remain in committee. In July 2026, the New York City administration proposed requiring landlords and brokers to disclose digitally altered rental listing images, but that proposal has not been adopted. California’s altered-image disclosure law took effect at the start of 2026.

One New York law already applies. General Business Law § 396-b, as amended effective June 9, 2026, requires anyone who produces an advertisement containing a synthetic performer, a digitally created human likeness, to disclose it conspicuously if they know it is there. Civil penalties are $1,000 for a first violation and $5,000 for each later one. An AI-generated presenter in a listing video is the kind of content to check.

Until a photo rule is adopted, the safer practice is to label virtually staged or digitally altered images, keep the unedited originals, and never use edits that hide defects or add features.

Recordkeeping

Brokers must keep transaction records, including listing agreements, contracts, and agency disclosure forms, generally for at least three years under 19 NYCRR § 175.23. AI-generated drafts and listing copy that go to clients or the public belong in those files, together with the unedited source images. Owners should keep the version of any AI summary they relied on. If a dispute is anticipated, a litigation hold reaches AI outputs and prompts in the same way it reaches email.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.