Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
Should a New York homeowner use a transfer-on-death deed, a revocable trust, or a life estate deed?
It depends on the goal. A transfer-on-death deed is the simplest way to pass one property outside probate while keeping full control. A revocable trust also handles incapacity, co-ops, and multiple assets. A life estate deed gives up control of the remainder, but after the Medicaid look-back it can protect a home in ways the other two generally do not.
Three tools, one goal
Most New York homeowners who ask about these tools want the same thing: to pass the home to family without a Surrogate’s Court proceeding. A transfer-on-death deed, a revocable trust, and a life estate deed can all do that. The right choice depends on what else the owner needs, such as protection during incapacity, flexibility to change the plan, Medicaid planning, or a plan that covers a co-op or several properties. For the basic mechanics of the newest option, see our guide to transfer-on-death deeds in New York.
Side by side
| Avoids probate for the home | TOD deed: yes, if recorded before death. Revocable trust: yes, if the home is deeded into it. Life estate: yes, the remainder passes automatically |
|---|---|
| Owner can change the plan | TOD deed: yes, by a recorded revocation or new deed. Revocable trust: yes, by amendment. Life estate: generally no, unless powers were reserved |
| Owner can sell or refinance alone | TOD deed: yes. Revocable trust: yes, as trustee. Life estate: generally no, the remainder beneficiaries must join |
| Management if the owner is incapacitated | TOD deed: no; an agent under a power of attorney or a guardian is needed. Revocable trust: yes, a successor trustee steps in. Life estate: the remainder beneficiaries already share ownership |
| Medicaid eligibility | TOD deed and revocable trust: the home is treated as the owner’s. Life estate: a transfer subject to the 60-month look-back |
| Co-op apartments | TOD deed: generally not available. Revocable trust: possible with board consent. Life estate: uncommon and subject to the proprietary lease |
| Cost and upkeep | TOD deed: one deed and recording. Revocable trust: a trust agreement, a deed into the trust, and ongoing administration. Life estate: one deed, but it is hard to undo |
The table states general rules. Tax, Medicaid, and title outcomes depend on how each document is drafted and on the owner’s facts.
Control and flexibility
The transfer-on-death deed and the revocable trust keep the owner fully in charge. The owner can sell, refinance, or change beneficiaries without anyone else’s signature. A transfer-on-death deed is revoked only by a later recorded instrument that meets RPL § 424, and a will cannot change it; a revocable trust is changed by amending the trust agreement.
A life estate deed is different. The owner deeds the property to the remainder beneficiaries now and keeps the right to occupy it for life. Unless the deed reserves powers, the owner cannot sell or mortgage the property without the remainder beneficiaries joining, and their divorce, debts, or death can complicate matters. Some life estate deeds reserve a power to sell or to change the remainder, which changes the tax and Medicaid analysis and should be drafted with care.
Incapacity
Only the revocable trust solves incapacity on its own. If the owner of a home in a funded revocable trust loses capacity, the successor trustee can manage, lease, or sell the home under the trust’s terms. A transfer-on-death deed does nothing until death, so an owner relying on one also needs a durable power of attorney that allows real estate transactions, or the family may need a guardianship. With a life estate, the remainder beneficiaries already own part of the property, but any sale still needs a person with authority to sign for the life tenant.
Medicaid
For nursing home Medicaid, a home in a revocable trust is treated as the owner’s, because the owner can take it back. A transfer-on-death deed is treated similarly: RPL § 424 says the deed does not affect eligibility for public assistance, and the owner still owns the home. A life estate deed, by contrast, is a transfer of the remainder for less than fair value, so it is reviewed under the 60-month look-back and can cause a period of ineligibility if care is needed within that period. Our article on the Medicaid look-back explains how that works.
After death, Medicaid recovery in New York is generally limited to the estate passing under a will or by intestacy, under Social Services Law § 369. A life estate ends at death, so the remainder generally is not part of that estate. Property in a revocable trust and property passing by transfer-on-death deed also pass outside the will, but the transfer-on-death statute lets the estate reach the property for allowed claims if the probate estate falls short, and how that interacts with Medicaid recovery has not been settled. Owners planning for long-term care usually look at an irrevocable Medicaid trust as well.
Taxes
All three tools generally keep the home in the owner’s estate for federal and New York estate tax purposes. That has an upside: property included in the estate generally receives a basis equal to its value at death, which can eliminate the capital gain on a later sale by the heirs. An outright gift of the home during life does not, which is one reason families often prefer these tools to simply adding a child to the deed.
A life estate deed is generally a completed gift of the remainder for gift tax purposes, which may require a federal gift tax return even though no tax is usually due. Transfer tax returns accompany the deeds that are recorded, and property tax exemptions such as STAR, senior, or veterans exemptions should be confirmed after any deed is recorded.
Which tool fits which situation
- One home or condominium, simple family, owner wants low cost and full control: a transfer-on-death deed, together with a will and a durable power of attorney.
- Several properties, a co-op, out-of-state real estate, or a concern about incapacity: a revocable trust, often with a pour-over will.
- Medicaid planning with time to get past the look-back: a life estate deed or an irrevocable Medicaid trust, chosen with the tax and control trade-offs in mind.
- A beneficiary who is a minor, has a disability and receives benefits, or has creditor or marital problems: a trust, rather than a deed that passes the property outright.
- Owners who want a child to have a share now: an outright lifetime gift, which none of these three tools is, and which carries over the owner’s tax basis instead of a step-up at death.
These tools can also be combined, for example a transfer-on-death deed for a house and a revocable trust for a co-op. What matters is that the deed, the trust, the will, and any beneficiary designations point the same way. Our article comparing wills and revocable trusts covers the rest of the plan.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.