Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Do I need LPC approval to renovate a landmarked building in New York City?

Usually. Most exterior work on an individual landmark or a building in a historic district, and any work there that needs a Department of Buildings permit, requires a Landmarks Preservation Commission permit first; ordinary repairs generally do not. Most permits are issued by LPC staff, while a Certificate of Appropriateness requires a public hearing and a Commission vote. Unpermitted work can lead to violations and penalties, even when a tenant did the work.

Does your project need LPC approval?

The Landmarks Preservation Commission (LPC) regulates work on individual landmarks, interior landmarks, and buildings within designated historic districts. If the building is covered, any work that requires a Department of Buildings (DOB) permit also requires an LPC permit, and DOB generally will not issue its permit until LPC has signed off. Work that changes protected features, such as windows, doors, storefronts, masonry, cornices, stoops, rooftops, and rear yards, needs LPC approval even if no DOB permit is required.

Ordinary repairs and maintenance, such as replacing broken glass or repainting a door in the same color, generally do not require LPC review. If you are unsure whether a building is designated, check LPC’s online map or call 311.

Permit types

Expedited Certificate of No EffectStaff-level approval for qualifying interior work and similar projects that need a DOB permit but do not affect protected features
Certificate of No EffectStaff-level approval for work that needs a DOB permit but does not affect significant protected features, such as many interior renovations and mechanical work
Permit for Minor WorkStaff-level approval for work that affects protected features but does not need a DOB permit, such as window or door replacement, masonry repair, and restoration
Certificate of AppropriatenessCommission approval after a public hearing for work that does not meet the rules for staff approval, such as visible additions, demolitions, and removing or adding features like stoops and cornices

LPC’s rules spell out many categories of work that staff can approve if the work meets stated criteria. The Commission has amended the rules over the years, including in 2019 and 2023, to move more routine work to staff review. A design that fits the rules can save months.

How long it takes

LPC measures processing from the date an application is complete. A City Comptroller review covering July 2022 through June 2025 reported that, measured in business days from the date LPC deemed an application complete to the date the permit issued, expedited certificates averaged about one day; Certificates of No Effect and Permits for Minor Work averaged about four to six days, with most issued within ten business days; and Certificates of Appropriateness averaged about 25 to 29 days. LPC itself estimates that the full Certificate of Appropriateness process, including the community board presentation and the Commission hearing, takes about three months. The review found that processing improved after LPC launched its online application system, Portico, on March 19, 2024.

Those averages run from a complete application. The more common delay comes earlier: missing drawings, photographs, or material specifications, and the back-and-forth with staff over design details. For a Certificate of Appropriateness, add time for presentation to the local community board, the Commission hearing, and any revisions the Commissioners request.

The Certificate of Appropriateness process

  • Meet with LPC staff early to discuss the design and what the Commission is likely to look for.
  • Prepare drawings, photographs, a materials list, and, for visible additions, a mock-up or sightline study.
  • Present to the community board, which gives an advisory recommendation.
  • Present at the Commission’s public hearing, where the public may testify.
  • Respond to the Commission’s comments. The Commission may approve, approve with modifications, or ask the applicant to return with a revised design.
  • Once approved, finalize drawings with staff, obtain the permit, and post it at the building while work is underway.

Violations and how to resolve them

When LPC learns of work done without a permit, it generally starts with a warning letter. The owner can correct the work or apply to legalize it, and if the matter is resolved, no penalty is imposed. If not, LPC may issue a notice of violation returnable at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, where a finding of violation results in a civil penalty. Repeat notices can follow until the condition is cured. LPC may skip the warning letter for intentional violations, may issue stop-work orders, and may go to court for an injunction. Unauthorized demolition is treated more seriously.

Work that complies with LPC’s rules can often be legalized after the fact; work that does not must be modified or removed. Once the condition is corrected, LPC issues a Notice of Compliance. Owners are responsible for violations at their property even when a tenant or a prior owner did the work, so buyers should check for open LPC violations in due diligence and leases should make tenants responsible for obtaining LPC approval for their work.

Practical tips

  • Confirm designation and review LPC’s rules for your type of work before the architect finalizes the design.
  • File a complete application. Incomplete filings are the most common source of delay.
  • Coordinate the LPC and DOB filings so the DOB application reflects the LPC-approved design.
  • Resolve any open warning letter or violation as part of the application rather than separately.
  • In a lease or alteration agreement, allocate responsibility for LPC approvals, costs, and violations.
  • For co-ops and condominiums, align the board’s alteration approval with LPC requirements for windows, air conditioners, and rooftop work.

We represent owners, boards, tenants, and buyers in LPC approvals, violation resolution, and the leasing and transactional issues that landmark status creates.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.