Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
How does an UPREIT contribution defer tax for property owners?
In an UPREIT, an owner contributes property to a REIT’s operating partnership for OP units, generally without recognizing gain under Internal Revenue Code § 721. Units are typically redeemable for cash or REIT shares after a lock-up, but redemption is taxable. Cash received, debt relief, or the partnership’s later sale of the property can trigger the deferred gain unless the deal includes tax protection. New York transfer taxes can still apply.
What an UPREIT is
In an umbrella partnership REIT, the REIT holds substantially all of its properties through an operating partnership and serves as its general partner. A property owner contributes real estate, or interests in the entity that owns it, to the operating partnership and receives OP units. OP units are limited partnership interests generally designed to track REIT shares, so each unit receives the same distributions as a share. UPREIT contributions are common when a REIT acquires a family-held property or portfolio whose owners do not want to pay tax on a sale.
How the tax deferral works
- Section 721 generally provides that no gain or loss is recognized when property is contributed to a partnership in exchange for a partnership interest.
- The owner’s tax basis carries over to the OP units, and under § 704(c) the built-in gain remains allocated to the contributor if the partnership later sells the property.
- Under the disguised sale rules of § 707(a)(2)(B), cash or other property received at or near the time of the contribution, generally within two years, may be treated as sale proceeds.
- If the contribution relieves the owner of debt, the reduction in the owner’s share of partnership liabilities under § 752 is treated as a cash distribution and can trigger gain to the extent it exceeds basis.
- Redeeming OP units for cash or REIT shares is generally a taxable sale for the redeeming holder.
Many owners hold OP units for life. Under current law, heirs generally receive a basis equal to fair market value at death under § 1014, which can eliminate the deferred gain on the units. That makes estate planning central to the decision.
Lock-ups, redemption, and liquidity
OP units are commonly subject to a lock-up before they can be redeemed. After that, the holder may generally tender units for cash equal to the value of a REIT share or, at the REIT’s election, for shares. Units carry limited voting rights and are subject to transfer restrictions and the REIT’s ownership limits. Points to negotiate include the length of the lock-up, the redemption mechanics and pricing, parity of distributions, registration rights for shares received on redemption, and the ability to pledge units as loan collateral.
Tax protection agreements
Because the contributor bears the tax cost if the partnership sells the property or reduces its debt, contributors negotiate a tax protection agreement. The partnership typically agrees not to sell the contributed property in a taxable transaction for a set period, other than through a tax-deferred exchange, and to maintain debt that can be allocated to the contributor or to give the contributor an opportunity to enter into a guaranty of partnership debt. If it breaches, it makes a make-whole payment, usually calculated to cover the tax and the tax on that payment.
Debt allocation rules deserve care. Treasury regulations issued since 2016 generally disregard so-called bottom-dollar guaranties when allocating partnership liabilities, so any guaranty arrangement must be structured to be respected.
New York transfer taxes
Contributing New York real property, or a controlling interest in an entity that owns it, is generally a conveyance subject to the New York State real estate transfer tax and, in New York City, the City’s real property transfer tax. The exemption for a mere change of identity or form applies only to the extent beneficial ownership stays the same, which rarely covers a contribution to a REIT’s partnership.
Both laws offer relief for certain REIT transfers. Under Tax Law § 1402(b), the State tax on a qualifying real estate investment trust transfer is $1 for each $500 of consideration, half the general rate. For transfers made in connection with a REIT’s formation, the contributors must receive ownership interests worth at least 40 percent of the equity value transferred and hold them for at least two years. City law provides a rate equal to 50 percent of the otherwise applicable rate for qualifying transfers made in connection with a REIT’s formation, with similar conditions, and the availability of the City’s reduced rate for transfers to existing REITs has depended on legislative extensions. Confirm current law and the conditions before pricing the deal.
Comparing the options
| Outright sale | Gain is taxed now; the seller has full liquidity and control of the proceeds; transfer taxes apply |
|---|---|
| 1031 exchange | Gain is deferred if replacement real property is identified within 45 days and acquired within 180 days; the owner keeps direct ownership and management |
| UPREIT contribution | Gain is generally deferred under § 721; the owner receives a REIT-linked interest and distributions; liquidity follows the lock-up, but redemption is taxable |
| 1031 exchange, then contribution | Replacement property, often an interest in a Delaware statutory trust, is later contributed to an operating partnership; timing and terms are typically set by the sponsor |
Partnership interests are excluded from like-kind treatment, so OP units cannot later be exchanged tax-free for real property. The right choice turns on the owner’s age and estate plan, need for liquidity, tolerance for concentration in one REIT, and confidence in its management.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.