Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Should a New York family use a private foundation or a donor-advised fund?

A donor-advised fund is simpler and cheaper, allows higher income tax deduction limits, and keeps grants private, but the sponsoring charity has legal control. A private foundation gives the family control of grants, investments, and the board, in exchange for a 1.39% investment income tax, a 5% annual payout, strict self-dealing rules, and public annual returns. The size of the gift and the desire for control usually decide.

Two ways to give over time

Families often want an immediate deduction, perhaps in a year with a large business sale or a real estate gain, but time to decide where the money goes. Both vehicles allow that. The choice turns on control, cost, tax limits, privacy, and whether the family wants an institution that the next generation will run. For the broader menu of charitable tools, including remainder and lead trusts, see the charitable planning page listed below.

Control and governance

A donor-advised fund is an account at a sponsoring organization, such as a community foundation or a financial institution’s charitable affiliate. To claim a deduction, the donor needs the sponsor’s written acknowledgment that it has exclusive legal control over the contributed assets. The donor and named advisors recommend grants, and sponsors generally follow recommendations to qualified charities, but they are not required to. Grants that give a donor or advisor more than an incidental benefit trigger a tax of 125% of the benefit, and certain other distributions, such as grants to individuals, are taxed to the sponsor at 20%.

A private foundation is a separate legal entity, usually a New York not-for-profit corporation or a charitable trust, whose directors or trustees are typically family members. The family decides which grants to make, how to invest, whether to hire staff, and who will succeed to the board. That control comes with fiduciary duties and with New York’s rules on conflicts of interest and related party transactions.

Tax treatment compared

Cash giftsDonor-advised fund: public charity limit, generally up to 60% of adjusted gross income. Private nonoperating foundation: 30%
Appreciated propertyDonor-advised fund: generally fair market value, up to 30% of adjusted gross income. Foundation: 20%, and generally only basis except for qualified appreciated stock
Investment incomeDonor-advised fund: none at the account level. Foundation: 1.39% excise tax on net investment income
Annual payoutDonor-advised fund: no federal minimum, though sponsors may set policies. Foundation: qualifying distributions based on 5% of non-charitable-use assets
Excess deductionsBoth: deductions above the annual limits generally carry forward to later years

Beginning in 2026, federal law allows individuals who itemize to deduct charitable gifts only to the extent they exceed 0.5% of adjusted gross income, which affects both vehicles equally and favors concentrating gifts in fewer years. The 2025 federal tax law did not increase the private foundation investment income tax. The new deduction for taxpayers who do not itemize is generally limited to cash gifts to public charities and does not cover gifts to donor-advised funds.

The private foundation rules

A foundation and its managers must follow a set of federal excise tax rules that do not apply to a donor-advised fund account:

  • Self-dealing. Sales, leases, loans, and most other dealings between the foundation and its substantial contributors, managers, their family members, and controlled entities are prohibited, even on fair terms. The initial tax is 10% of the amount involved on the self-dealer.
  • Minimum distributions. The foundation must make qualifying distributions based on 5% of its non-charitable-use assets, generally by the end of the following year, or pay an initial 30% tax on the shortfall.
  • Excess business holdings. The foundation and its disqualified persons together generally may not own more than 20% of the voting stock of a business.
  • Jeopardizing investments and taxable expenditures. Imprudent investments, lobbying, political activity, and grants made without required procedures are taxed.

These rules are manageable with good advice, but they make a foundation a poor fit for a family that wants to use charitable assets alongside its own business or real estate.

Privacy and reporting

A private foundation files Form 990-PF each year, and its exemption application and annual returns must be made available for public inspection. In New York it also registers with the Attorney General’s Charities Bureau and files an annual report with a copy of the federal return. A donor-advised fund account involves no separate filings by the donor, and many sponsors allow grants to be made anonymously.

Cost and timing

A donor-advised fund can usually be opened in days with no legal fees, and sponsors charge administrative and investment fees. A foundation requires formation documents, an IRS exemption application, state registration, annual accounting and returns, and ongoing governance. For a family giving modest amounts, those costs can outweigh the benefits. For a family committing a substantial sum and wanting a lasting institution, they are often worth it. Our guide to starting a private foundation in New York walks through the steps.

Real estate and closely held interests

For real estate owners, the vehicle choice matters most. A gift of appreciated real estate or a closely held business interest to a private nonoperating foundation is generally deductible only at basis, and the foundation may not lease the property back to the donor or buy and sell with the family. Many donor-advised fund sponsors accept real estate after review and sell it, and if the property was held more than a year, the gift is generally deductible at appraised value within the public charity limits. A supporting organization, which is a public charity tied to specific charities, is a third option for some families but cannot be controlled by the donor.

Choosing, and combining

Families do not have to choose only one. A common pattern is a donor-advised fund for anonymous gifts and for property the family wants sold, and a foundation for a visible family program and for involving the next generation. The estate plan can name either as a beneficiary, which also helps with New York estate tax; see our article on the New York estate tax cliff. In second marriages, a large charitable bequest should be coordinated with any elective share waiver.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.