Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

What is New York City’s non-primary residence property surcharge?

It is the formal name of the pied-à-terre tax, enacted in Tax Law Article 30-C in the 2026–27 State budget. It applies to 1–3 family homes valued at $5 million or more and to condo and co-op units valued at $1 million or more that are no one’s qualifying primary residence. Rates run from 0.8% to 6.5% of Department of Finance market value, and the first charge is due January 1, 2027.

The statute and its name

The tax that most people call the pied-à-terre tax has three names. The statute, Tax Law Article 30-C, calls it the “City Surcharge on Property That Does Not Serve as a Primary Residence.” The Department of Finance calls it the Non-Primary Residence Property Surcharge. The City’s implementing law is a new Chapter 32 of Title 11 of the Administrative Code, beginning at § 11-3201.

The Legislature enacted it in Part HH of the 2026–27 State revenue budget legislation. The Department of Finance says the law took effect May 28, 2026. The surcharge applies to fiscal years beginning on and after July 1, 2026, and each section of Article 30-C is scheduled to be repealed on June 30, 2031 unless the Legislature extends it.

Imposition of surchargeTax Law § 1350
DefinitionsTax Law § 1351
Primary residence determinationsTax Law § 1352
RatesTax Law § 1353
Billing, collection, and penaltiesTax Law § 1354
Administrative and judicial reviewTax Law § 1355
Department of Finance rules19 RCNY chapter 62, effective July 14, 2026

What property is covered

For fiscal years beginning July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2028, § 1350 reaches three kinds of residential property whose Department of Finance “phase one” market value is equal to or greater than the threshold:

  • a class one property other than vacant land, which in practice means a one-, two-, or three-family home, valued at $5 million or more;
  • a residential condominium unit valued at $1 million or more; and
  • a residential cooperative apartment valued at $1 million or more, with the building’s value allocated among units by shares.

The figures are the Department of Finance’s market values for property tax purposes, not sale prices. Condo and co-op values are set under state rules that generally produce figures well below what the units would sell for, which is why the condo and co-op threshold is lower. A unit that sold for several million dollars can sit in the $1 million to $3 million tier.

The law excludes property that lacks a required certificate of occupancy and units under an offering plan that the sponsor has not yet sold. Whether a property is covered is tested as of the taxable status date, January 5 before the fiscal year, so January 5, 2026 for the 2026–27 surcharge.

From July 1, 2028, the statute changes. All covered property, including condo and co-op units, is measured against a single $5 million threshold using a “phase two market value,” and the house rates apply. For condo and co-op units, the statute bases phase two market value on comparable sales without the valuation limits of Real Property Tax Law § 581, so those values are expected to be higher than current condo and co-op values. To our knowledge, the Department of Finance has not yet published how it will apply that method.

Rates for 2026–27 and 2027–28

1–3 family home, $5 million up to $15 million0.8% of market value
1–3 family home, over $15 million up to $25 million1.05%
1–3 family home, over $25 million1.3%
Condo or co-op unit, $1 million up to $3 million4.0%
Condo or co-op unit, over $3 million up to $5 million5.25%
Condo or co-op unit, over $5 million6.5%

The bracket boundaries above follow the statute’s wording. The Department of Finance’s public page describes the same tiers in slightly different terms, so an owner whose value sits exactly at a boundary should check the bill. The rate applies to the whole market value, not only the amount above the threshold. Property tax abatements, credits, and exemptions do not reduce the surcharge, and the surcharge is kept separate from the City’s ordinary tax levy and class shares.

Who is exempt

Under § 1351, property serves as a primary residence, and so is outside the surcharge, if on the taxable status date it was the primary residence of:

  • a covered owner, which for a co-op means the tenant-stockholder;
  • an immediate family member of a covered owner who is a natural person, meaning a spouse, child, sibling, parent, grandparent, or grandchild; or
  • a lessee or sublessee who is a natural person, under a bona fide, arm’s-length lease of at least one year.

For property held by an LLC, corporation, or partnership, the Department of Finance’s rules treat a person holding a majority interest, more than 50%, as a covered owner, and several holders may combine their interests to reach a majority. The rules add two limits that matter in practice: the entity must hold the entire fee interest or all of the co-op shares, and a multi-tier ownership structure does not establish primary residency. For a trust, only a sole beneficiary qualifies, and contingent or future interests are disregarded in deciding who is a sole beneficiary.

The rules also address hard cases. A home generally continues to be treated as a primary residence for one year after the owner’s death, and during a continuous hospitalization or a temporary stay in a nursing or rehabilitation facility, if the estate or owner documents the event and the residence before it. In a two- or three-family house, proof that one unit is a qualifying primary residence excludes the whole property; in a co-op, it excludes only that apartment.

How the Department of Finance decides

Section 1352 requires the Department of Finance to make an initial determination each year. Its rules direct it to look first to income tax data showing the property as a covered owner’s permanent home address, and then to other factors, including whether a covered owner occupied the property for most days of the prior calendar year.

For 2026–27, the Department published a supplemental market value roll on July 24, 2026 and began mailing notices in late July. The Mayor’s Office announced the mailing on July 23, 2026. The Appellate Division put the first wave at approximately 17,000 notices, and in late August the City reported, in court filings and public statements, that it had cleared about 1,210 owners using newly available tax filings, while a second wave of roughly 10,800 letters went out, many to entity- and trust-owned properties. The exemption application window for 2026–27 closed on October 13, 2026, after several extensions. If you received a notice, see what to do next.

For later years, the rules call for initial determination notices by February 15, with an owner’s appeal to the Department due within 30 days after the notice. The statute provides that a failure to send a notice does not affect the validity of the surcharge, so an owner who expects to be covered should not wait for a letter.

Billing, liens, audits, and penalties

  • The surcharge is added to the property’s statement of account and is due and payable in the same manner as real property taxes. For 2026–27, it is due on the same date as the second semiannual installment, January 1, 2027.
  • For co-ops, the surcharge is computed unit by unit but billed to the cooperative corporation, which collects it from the tenant-stockholder under § 1354(c).
  • It is enforced, as far as practicable, like real property taxes, and the Department of Finance’s statement accompanying its rules describes the surcharge, with any penalties and interest, as a lien on the property.
  • The Department may audit primary-residence certifications and documents within six years after they are submitted, and may issue subpoenas.
  • After notice and a hearing, the Department may impose a penalty of up to 50% of the surcharge for a material certification or submission that is inaccurate, made negligently or in bad faith, or for dividing a condo unit into more than three units in bad faith to avoid the surcharge. Under the rules, where a false submission would have eliminated the surcharge, the penalty is 50% and the surcharge is reinstated; where it would only have lowered the value, the penalty is 300% of the difference, capped at 50% of the surcharge.

The O’Brien rollout case

In O’Brien v. City of New York, Index No. 85217/2026, a group of homeowners brought an Article 78 proceeding in Supreme Court, Richmond County, challenging how the Department of Finance rolled out the surcharge. On September 29, 2026, Justice Wayne M. Ozzi held that the process was arbitrary and capricious. According to published summaries, the court read § 1352(a) to require an individualized primary-residence determination before a notice is sent, ordered the Department to take down the supplemental roll, canceled the roughly 17,000 notices, and held that the exemption process improperly shifted the burden of proof to homeowners.

The City filed a notice of appeal to the Appellate Division, Second Department, the same day and took the position that the appeal automatically stayed the judgment under CPLR 5519(a)(1). The Department continued the rollout and kept the October 13, 2026 exemption deadline.

On November 4, 2026, a unanimous four-justice panel of the Second Department reversed and dismissed the proceeding (Matter of O’Brien v. City of New York, App. Div. 2d Dep’t, No. 2026-10762). The panel held that the petitioners lacked standing because they had not shown a concrete injury: a notice serves an informational purpose, the confusion over the roll was too generalized, and the cost of applying for an exemption was not documented. It also found that the notices’ language satisfies Tax Law § 1352(a)(2) and 19 RCNY 62-06(a)(4). The panel did not decide whether the Department acted arbitrarily in choosing whom to notify, and the statute itself was not challenged in that case. The notices stand. As of November 16, 2026, we are not aware of any further appeal; further review would generally require leave from the Court of Appeals or the Appellate Division.

The constitutional challenges

Two cases attack the statute itself, both reported to be pending in Supreme Court, Suffolk County. Ross v. State of New York, Index No. 628629/2026, filed September 28, 2026 by Wilbur Ross, Hilary Geary Ross, and Steve Wynn, seeks declarations that the statute violates the Privileges and Immunities Clause, the dormant Commerce Clause, and the federal and State equal protection guarantees, and that its revenue cannot be excluded from the real estate tax limit in Article VIII, § 10 of the State Constitution. A second suit, filed September 29, 2026 by a co-op corporation and a group of homeowners, raises similar federal and state constitutional claims and challenges the use of the January 5, 2026 taxable status date.

As of November 16, 2026, we are not aware of a decision in either case. Until a court rules otherwise, owners should assume the surcharge applies and that the January 1, 2027 charge must be paid. Whether any refund would be available if the statute were struck down would depend on the ruling and on how and when the owner preserved the claim. We represent owners, co-op boards, and buyers on surcharge exposure, Tax Commission appeals, and the transactions affected by the tax.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.