Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
What is the Empire Plan out-of-network rate in 2027?
Starting January 1, 2027, the Empire Plan allowed amount for non-participating physicians and mental health and substance use providers falls from 275% to 150% of the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule for CSEA-represented enrollees, and UUP’s ratified agreement summary describes the same rate. Whether it reaches other Empire Plan groups is not yet confirmed. Surprise-bill and emergency disputes go to New York IDR.
What changes on January 1, 2027
The changes appear in CSEA’s side-by-side summary of the tentative agreement, which states that all health insurance changes take effect January 1, 2027 unless noted. The main out-of-network terms are:
| Physicians and other medical providers, MHSU providers | Allowed amount falls from 275% to 150% of the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule |
|---|---|
| Member cost sharing for those providers | No change: annual deductible, then 80% of the allowed amount |
| Out-of-network hospital inpatient | 90% of billed charges becomes 90% of an allowed amount |
| Out-of-network hospital outpatient | 90% of the allowed amount or a $75 copayment, whichever is greater |
| Hospital allowed amount | 135% (2027), 130% (2028), and 125% (2029) of the program administrator’s average contracted in-network rates |
| Out-of-network MHSU facilities | 90% of billed charges becomes 90% of an allowed amount: 600% (2027), 500% (2028), and 400% (2029) of average in-network rates |
For a physician practice, the headline is the professional fee schedule. A benchmark that falls from 275% to 150% of Medicare is roughly 45 percent lower, and the plan’s 80% reimbursement is calculated on the lower figure, which leaves a larger balance between the provider’s charge and the plan’s payment.
Who the change covers
The Governor’s office announced on August 6, 2026 that four CSEA bargaining units, representing more than 55,000 state employees, had ratified five-year agreements running from April 2, 2026 to April 1, 2031. The CSEA summary is the source for the out-of-network terms; the State’s announcement describes the health changes only generally, as including incentives to use in-network providers.
Empire Plan benefits are negotiated group by group. The terms above are confirmed for CSEA-represented enrollees, and UUP’s summary of its 2026–2031 agreement, which UUP members ratified in July 2026, describes the same 150% rate for non-participating providers starting January 1, 2027. As of November 13, 2026, we have not found an official statement on whether the State will apply the 150% rate to other unions’ members, management and confidential employees, retirees, or local government employers that participate in the State’s health program. Until that is clear, a practice should verify the patient’s group before quoting estimated benefits or modeling revenue.
What patients can be billed
Federal and New York surprise-billing protections continue to limit what Empire Plan members owe for emergency services and for surprise bills, generally to in-network cost sharing. In those cases the lower allowed amount does not move to the patient; the dispute is between the provider and the plan.
Elective out-of-network care is different. When a patient knowingly chooses an out-of-network provider for a scheduled office or outpatient service, the provider may generally bill the difference between its charge and the plan’s payment, subject to the disclosure rules of Public Health Law § 24 and, where it applies, the federal notice-and-consent process. Anesthesiologists, radiologists, pathologists, emergency physicians, and other ancillary providers at in-network facilities cannot use federal notice and consent at all.
- Update financial policies and estimates for Empire Plan patients before January 1, 2027.
- Expect larger patient balances and more patient complaints on elective out-of-network care.
- Check whether the Empire Plan’s access program for members without a nearby participating provider applies. When no participating primary care provider, or participating provider in certain covered specialties, is available within the plan’s distance standards and the member contacts the Medical/Surgical Program before the service, the plan has provided network benefits, so the patient generally owes only copayments.
- Keep written disclosures current and signed.
New York IDR for Empire Plan disputes
Part BB of the 2026–27 state budget made the Empire Plan and the Student Employee Health Plan subject to New York IDR for disputes filed on or after August 26, 2026, under criteria of their own. The Department of Financial Services explained them in Insurance Circular Letter No. 5 (2026):
- The IDR entity selects the plan’s payment or the provider’s fee, whichever is closer to an allowed benchmark: the 50th percentile of allowed amounts for the service among participating providers in the same or similar specialty and area.
- The law also sets a maximum fee measured at the 80th percentile of those allowed amounts.
- The IDR entity may depart from the benchmark based on factors such as the provider’s training, the complexity of the case, or the patient’s characteristics.
- Disputes involving physicians employed by Article 28 general hospitals, and certain related practices, are decided under the general criteria of Financial Services Law § 604(a).
- No fee may be awarded if the plan shows a contract covering the same service at the same location, or a qualifying prior authorization notice identifying the service as out-of-network.
- Both sides must prepay the IDR entity’s fee.
The benchmark comes from in-network allowed amounts, not from the plan’s 150%-of-Medicare formula. For each service a practice performs, the gap between the plan’s initial payment and the in-network median is the number that will decide whether IDR is worth filing.
Payment timing and records
Whether New York’s prompt pay statute, Insurance Law § 3224-a, reaches a particular Empire Plan claim depends on how that part of the program is structured and administered, and we would not assume it does. Track every claim from submission, document each request for information, and keep explanations of benefits that show the allowed amount and the methodology used. That record matters on appeal, in IDR, and in any later dispute.
Joining the network: a decision to model
The rate change is meant to move providers into the network. Whether that makes sense for a practice depends on its Empire Plan volume, its service mix, the contracted rates it can obtain, and how often its claims qualify for IDR as emergency services or surprise bills.
- Pull 12 to 24 months of Empire Plan claims and reprice them at 150% of Medicare.
- Separate elective out-of-network care from emergency and surprise-bill claims that can go to IDR.
- Compare the result with a realistic contracted rate, including administrative costs and payment speed.
- Account for the contract bar: once a contract covers a service at a location, IDR is no longer available for it.
We represent physicians, practices, and facilities in New York IDR, payer appeals, and out-of-network reimbursement disputes, and we help practices evaluate network decisions against their claims data.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.