Published
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.
What is the difference between 485-x and 467-m in New York City?
485-x provides a property tax exemption for new multiple dwellings, and eligible conversions, with six or more units that commence construction by June 15, 2034. 467-m covers rental buildings of six or more units created by converting non-residential buildings, commencing by June 30, 2031. Both require permanently affordable, rent-stabilized units, but affordability levels, wage requirements, benefit periods, and filing deadlines differ, so the program should be chosen at the start.
The two programs
Real Property Tax Law § 485-x was enacted in April 2024 and is administered by HPD under rules adopted in December 2024. It provides a real property tax exemption for new multiple dwellings and certain conversions, excluding hotels. Real Property Tax Law § 467-m, enacted at the same time, provides an exemption for rental multiple dwellings created by converting non-residential buildings, such as office buildings, to housing. Hotels and other Class B multiple dwellings are excluded from both.
Side by side
| Projects | 485-x: new multiple dwellings and eligible conversions. 467-m: conversions of non-residential buildings to rental housing |
|---|---|
| Minimum size | Both: six or more dwelling units |
| Commencement window | 485-x: after June 15, 2022 and by June 15, 2034. 467-m: after December 31, 2022 and by June 30, 2031 |
| Completion deadline | 485-x: by June 15, 2038. 467-m: by December 31, 2039 |
| Affordability | 485-x: varies by option, from 20 to 25 percent of units for larger rentals. 467-m: at least 25 percent of units, including at least 5 percent at 40 percent of AMI |
| Average income level | 485-x Options A and B: 80 percent of AMI, or 60 percent for very large projects. 467-m: weighted average not above 80 percent of AMI |
| Benefit period | 485-x: 35 years for most rental options, 40 for very large projects, shorter for small rentals and homeownership. 467-m: set by HPD’s schedule by location and commencement date |
| When to file | 485-x: registration within six months of commencement, then an application. 467-m: application within one year after completion |
485-x options
485-x is organized around project options. Option A covers large rentals of 100 or more units and requires 25 percent affordable units averaging 80 percent of AMI. Very large projects of 150 or more units in designated zones require 25 percent at an average of 60 percent of AMI and receive a longer benefit. Option B covers rentals of 6 to 99 units and requires 20 percent affordable units averaging 80 percent of AMI. Option C covers small rentals of 6 to 10 units outside Manhattan, with at least half of the units rent-stabilized and a floor area limit. Option D covers homeownership projects outside Manhattan, subject to an assessed value cap and a five-year owner-occupancy requirement. The option is elected in the initial submission.
Wage requirements
Labor costs often drive the decision. Under 485-x, rental projects of 100 or more units must pay construction workers a minimum hourly wage set by statute, and very large projects in designated zones are subject to a higher wage standard. Each figure increases annually and is enforced by the Comptroller. Sites covered by project labor agreements, and certain collective bargaining agreements, may be exempt. HPD’s 467-m program materials impose no comparable construction wage requirement. Both programs require building service employees to be paid prevailing wages during the benefit period, with exceptions for buildings with fewer than 30 units and for certain affordable projects.
Choosing between them
- Is the project new construction, or is it a conversion of an existing non-residential building? A conversion may be eligible under either program, so compare both.
- How many units will there be? The 100- and 150-unit thresholds in 485-x change the affordability, wage, and benefit terms.
- Where is the site? Zone designations affect 485-x terms, and 467-m benefit schedules vary by location.
- When will construction commence and finish? Each program has fixed windows.
- Can the pro forma carry the required affordable units at the required income levels permanently?
- Does the zoning allow the project? City of Yes expanded conversion eligibility and added an affordability bonus that may interact with the tax benefit.
Common pitfalls
Both programs require recorded restrictive declarations, HPD-approved marketing of affordable units, and compliance through the benefit period and beyond. Affordable units remain permanently rent-stabilized, and HPD may revoke benefits and impose fines for noncompliance. Late 485-x registration can carry a penalty. A 467-m application cannot be filed until the building is complete, which leaves a long period of exposure if the project falls out of compliance before filing. Lenders, investors, and buyers will diligence all of this. The program choice should be made with counsel before closing on the site or the construction loan.
Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.